Internet ‘Fast Lane’ Proposal Crumbles

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Tom Wheeler, Chairman of the FCC and proponent of the paid Internet ‘fast lanes’, has found himself suddenly standing virtually alone on a burning deck. Over 100 Internet companies have expressed opposition to the FCC’s plan.

Tech titans, including Facebook, Ebay, Google, Netflix, Microsoft, Twitter, Reddit, and dozens of startups, have all signed on to a letter [PDF] urging the commission to reject the proposed changes.
 
They'll just bring it back under a different name, "Slow Lanes" maybe?
 
It was never going to happen. They just need to classify it as a utility and be done with it. People aren't going to pay any more than they already are for shitty internet. And slowing it down more? Come one, we are toward the back of the pack in speed. 1 Gb/s internet for $45 in South Korea. 30 Mb/s internet for $45 or more here. :rolleyes:
 
I have major issue with calling it the "Fast Lane", which implies something good. Abolishment of NN is anything but.
 
It was never going to happen. They just need to classify it as a utility and be done with it. People aren't going to pay any more than they already are for shitty internet. And slowing it down more? Come one, we are toward the back of the pack in speed. 1 Gb/s internet for $45 in South Korea. 30 Mb/s internet for $45 or more here. :rolleyes:

But if we had fast and cheap internet how would all those CEOs ever afford to live? :rolleyes:
 
I get 50Mbs in the UK, unlimited data for £20. (Speed test says 62Mbs)
Not looking forward to when I move back to Canada after my degree.
 
It was never going to happen. They just need to classify it as a utility and be done with it. People aren't going to pay any more than they already are for shitty internet. And slowing it down more? Come one, we are toward the back of the pack in speed. 1 Gb/s internet for $45 in South Korea. 30 Mb/s internet for $45 or more here. :rolleyes:

Imagine that, in a country roughly the size of the distance between LA and SF.

In all seriousness though, people also forget that South Korea's internet is government subsidized too. Get anywhere close to suggesting that in the US and conservatives and libertarians go insane. Calling it a utility would also likely trigger the same reaction.

Imagine if the telephone or power was created today, but with no government regulation. It would probably be like broadband today. In areas where it's deemed profitable to run the cables, but remote or rural areas would be out of luck because they aren't profitable. Don't get me wrong, I don't think regulation is the answer, look at how USF turned out but I do know leaving up to market competition isn't helping.
 
The solution is simple, force last providers to offer wholesale access at published rates, with published quality of service. Ideally mandate that the wholesale rate not be more than the retail rate. If Comcast chooses not to have enough capacity to other networks, then there is room for third parties to compete.
 
The US internet was government subsidized also, but most of the grants did not go into infrastructure but right into pockets.
 
The voters have spoken (corporations) so Wheeler's gonna have a hard time keeping his promise to his crony buddies in Telco. One can hope this will save us second class citizens from further bondage.
 
Imagine that, in a country roughly the size of the distance between LA and SF.

In all seriousness though, people also forget that South Korea's internet is government subsidized too. Get anywhere close to suggesting that in the US and conservatives and libertarians go insane. Calling it a utility would also likely trigger the same reaction.

Imagine if the telephone or power was created today, but with no government regulation. It would probably be like broadband today. In areas where it's deemed profitable to run the cables, but remote or rural areas would be out of luck because they aren't profitable. Don't get me wrong, I don't think regulation is the answer, look at how USF turned out but I do know leaving up to market competition isn't helping.

You might want to read the the 1996 telecommunications act. The reason we are in the monopolies right now is because of de-regulation. The fact is that we paid taxes for the infrastructure and all they did with that grant money was line their pockets.
 
"Freedom Lanes"

"Freedom of Internet Traffic for the Protection of Children Act" .. What kinda monster would vote against such a thing.

Wouldn't be the first time they used this a name to get a bill through. If you oppose it, they can use it in attack ads as most of the public doesn't know what the bill is actually about.
 
It was never going to happen. They just need to classify it as a utility and be done with it. People aren't going to pay any more than they already are for shitty internet. And slowing it down more? Come one, we are toward the back of the pack in speed. 1 Gb/s internet for $45 in South Korea. 30 Mb/s internet for $45 or more here. :rolleyes:

This.
 
Internet 'fast lane' isn't always fast so it should appropriately called internet 'toll' lane.
 
"Freedom Lanes"
LMAO!

You know the sad part of all of this though is that the PUBLIC'S opinion on this, which has been overwhelmingly negative, did not factor in at all.

What mattered is that a group of powerful corporations (content providers) was able to possibly overpower the lobby effort of another group of corporations (infrastructure providers).

The little guy and Joe Public? No shits were given.
 
You might want to read the the 1996 telecommunications act. The reason we are in the monopolies right now is because of de-regulation.
Uhhh, no the exact opposite happened. Regulation is what ensured these monopolies, the exact opposite of regulation, and what we need to see is the same deregulation we've seen in Texas with electricty (I'm paying 7.8 cents kwh; compared to my sister in NY with her monopoly paying LITERALLY double that).

Declare it a public utility and just like they tell Reliant Energy that they will be compensated for laying the lines down, but that's it, and any powerplant on the grid or in this case ISP on the grid can then provide you service.

Capitalism works better than anything we have when there is competition, and the only thing the government should be doing is ensuring that COMPETITION can thrive. Their job is to ensure that everyone is playing by the same rules, that rules are not in place that favor large companies and instead favor startups to encourage competition, and to break up monopolies that are otherwise inherent to any free market over a long enough period of time.

Unfortunately, its the large companies that are able to spend fortunes to BUY politicians in order to create regulations that are in their favor, not the other way around.
 
Err, the opposite of de-regulation I meant. It was in 1996 that the ISPs were afforded protection based on the premise that they acted as common carriers, and following that governments got into the mix and started setting up contracts as single-provider localized monopolies, something that never should have happened. In any case, I think everyone knows the fix now, get the government OUT of setting up no-bid local monopolies and allow the free market to flourish, and declare ISPs a public utility so that there isn't a great risk in laying down fiber and yet little guys can still gain access to those lines without having to lay a million redundant networks to every home.
 
I have no problem with tiered internet... Tier1 consumer level 100mbps down 50mbps up 1,000 gb of data a month, 50ms ping or better and sub 10 packet loss per year with a 99.99% uptime 100% money back guarantee. Tier2 consumer level 1000mbps down 500mbps up 100,000 gb of data a month, 50ms ping or better and sub 10 packet loss per year with a 99.99% uptime 100% money back guarantee.

Anything less and fuck off.
 
I have no problem with tiered internet... Tier1 consumer level 100mbps down 50mbps up 1,000 gb of data a month, 50ms ping or better and sub 10 packet loss per year with a 99.99% uptime 100% money back guarantee. Tier2 consumer level 1000mbps down 500mbps up 100,000 gb of data a month, 50ms ping or better and sub 10 packet loss per year with a 99.99% uptime 100% money back guarantee.

Anything less and fuck off.
This wasn't about tiers though.

This was about me starting up a service called "Awesomesauce" that really kicks butt and that you'd love to have, but that Comcast intercepts because it competes with their own streaming service and slows down so that it runs like crap and either you as the customer get pissed at me telling me to upgrade my server (when its Comcast's fault) or realizing its your ISP that's the problem and are told to go suck an egg because the only other option in your area is slow ass DSL.
 
1996 that the ISPs were afforded protection based on the premise that they acted as common carriers
No it didn't. That act gave the FCC the -option- to do so but they never did since they'd have to be reclassified as 'telecommunication services' which hasn't happened due to political pressure from ISP lobbyists.

It was the FCC's attempt to regulate them as 'common carriers' without classifying them properly that got them batted down in court.

"Given that the Commission has chosen to classify broadband providers in a manner that exempts them from treatment as common carriers, the Communications Act expressly prohibits the Commission from nonetheless regulating them as such. Because the Commission has failed to establish that the anti-discrimination and anti-blocking rules do not impose per se common carrier obligations, we vacate those portions of the Open Internet Order."

and following that governments got into the mix and started setting up contracts as single-provider localized monopolies
Local and state govts that are easily bought and bullied did and/or allowed that, not the federal govt. That is a corruption issue not a 'free markets!!!!!!!!!!!!!!' issue.
 
Back
Top