Internet Access IS A Human Right

Damn edit button...


Ugh. I hate when Steve posts these articles and the associated show of dumbassery that follows.

Internet access being a human right simply means that you have the right to purchase unimpeded access to the internet. Same as electricity, gas, and water. It means no one is allowed to cut your internet because you were a heavy user, it means your ISP can't tier your internet to make you pay more for accessing certain types of content, and it means the government isn't allowed to censor the internet.

Internet access being a basic human right does not mean "get ALL the internets for free!"

Exactly. Enough with the posts about socialism and not having to "pay a dime" in an effort to compare this to a program that wants to give Internet at a taxpayer expense. Sheesh. Leave the hypocritical "I hate socialism" crap elsewhere.
 
Consider which are the countries that regularly deny access to the internet:

China, North Korea, Burma, Cuba, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Vietnam, etc

Now consider how these countries rank in terms of human rights. See the correlation now?
 
Just recently I was ranting about how everything is considered a right nowadays. If someone has something you don't, well then you have a right to the same yourself by God!
 
Internet access should be classified as a utility, and there are people working towards this. And it's actually been brought up here on these forums. There are many reasons to do so and they've already been discussed. However, as long as we have people in our government that consider SOPA, and other bills like it, a good idea, I really don't see it ever coming to pass.
 
Consider which are the countries that regularly deny access to the internet:

China, North Korea, Burma, Cuba, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Vietnam, etc

Now consider how these countries rank in terms of human rights. See the correlation now?

Great strawman argument.

Because A = B and C = A, therefore B must equal C?

Not in the real world...ever.
 
So what will be a "human right" in 20 years? You RIGHT to fly via your personal levitation belt?

Inventions are not RIGHTS. I guess the right to be alive is a "God" given right. But as someone else said, if someone controls the internet, does that make them "God" because it is a "Right"?
 
Great strawman argument.

Because A = B and C = A, therefore B must equal C?

Not in the real world...ever.

I'm afraid you'll never make it as a scientist...

Indeed, inductive reasoning is not an expression of definitive fact. Luckily for me, I never claimed as such. However, given the number of equivalent examples that can be found in the "real world," my argument would be considered by most reasonable parties as an example of strong induction. Or more simply stated, a correlation....
 
It seems on the left we have bleeding hearts with entitlement issues and on the right we have warmongering bible beaters...

I just hope that Ron Paul's performance improves so that we can get away from both.

:rolleyes:

Great idea, let's take this country back 60 years in progress and elect Ron Paul. It'll be a victory for freedom of every per...err...white male in America!
 
I'll never understand politics. Clowns on the left, jokers on the right, and both pawns to the larger scheme of things.
 
Sometimes I feel like I'm the most intelligent person I know, then I realize I can't do simple calculus. The point is this should be a human right, but food should be also. However if you come to the point of where food is required for you or your children you should be forced to receive it by feeding tube. Thus making you never desire such a thing for free ever again unless that's your last resort.

Libertarian for life.
 
Ugh. I hate when Steve posts these articles and the associated show of dumbassery that follows.

Internet access being a human right simply means that you have the right to purchase unimpeded access to the internet. Same as electricity, gas, and water. It means no one is allowed to cut your internet because you were a heavy user, it means your ISP can't tier your internet to make you pay more for accessing certain types of content, and it means the government isn't allowed to censor the internet.

Internet access being a basic human right does not mean "get ALL the internets for free!"
A utility is not a right, nor is access. Your water can be cut off, rationed or tiered. You can have it censored for only indoor use, with non-potable water used for outdoor use.

I agree that, should a person have access to internet, the right to use said internet should not be denied. This entails that the person follows the rules governing the internet access.

If a group wants to come to a common agreement stating internet as a right, the actionable means to this can be quite different. China can agree to the right to internet access without it undermining their current standpoint on internet.

When a group agrees to internet access as a right, they agree to cooperate in a manner that helps to achieve that goal. Supplying water to some hick living in the middle of the Rockies is not the responsibility of anyone currently. Cell phone coverage is not a right. Should we see cell phone coverage become a necessity (not a "right"), we would see our govt. (referring to the U.S.) creating incentives for businesses to provide coverage in areas that do not meet their marketable metrics. And that is what we are seeing right now in the U.S. with the broadband measures for rural areas.
 
I'm afraid you'll never make it as a scientist...

Indeed, inductive reasoning is not an expression of definitive fact. Luckily for me, I never claimed as such. However, given the number of equivalent examples that can be found in the "real world," my argument would be considered by most reasonable parties as an example of strong induction. Or more simply stated, a correlation....

Not even close.
 
From the colonial days to the 1800's the government spent a lot of money building roads for mail delivery. I don't think governments need to buy everyone a FIOS connection, but they should be working to make access to the internet cheaper and more widely available.

The internet is the Earth's nervous system, I can see why some people would go so far as to call it a human right. Access to knowledge and mass communication on this scale has never been available until recently. It's causing major social changes throughout the world.
 
People should have the ability to exchange their currency for 100% uncensored access to the Internet.

That's as far as I'm willing to go towards declaring it a "right."

Hell, ELECTRICITY isn't even considered a "human right," and how does one propose to access the Internet without electricity?

Some people are confusing "things that are beneficial that should be able to be used by as many people as possible" with "fundamental human rights."

I think the Declaration of Independence got it right: Life, Liberty, and Pursuit of Happiness are fundamental human rights. At that point, no one is depriving you of your life, no one is holding you against your will, and no one is preventing you from (legally) attempting to live the life you want. Everything else sort of takes care of itself.
 
[Tripod]MajorPayne;1038234233 said:
People should have the ability to exchange their currency for 100% uncensored access to the Internet.

That's as far as I'm willing to go towards declaring it a "right."

Hell, ELECTRICITY isn't even considered a "human right," and how does one propose to access the Internet without electricity?

Some people are confusing "things that are beneficial that should be able to be used by as many people as possible" with "fundamental human rights."

I think the Declaration of Independence got it right: Life, Liberty, and Pursuit of Happiness are fundamental human rights. At that point, no one is depriving you of your life, no one is holding you against your will, and no one is preventing you from (legally) attempting to live the life you want. Everything else sort of takes care of itself.

Actually, electricity is considered a "right" in the US. Every home must have access to phone service (for 911 access) and electricity. You still have to pay for it (except for 911 service, theres no charge for that), it just must be available. In areas of the country where we have very cold winters, electric companies are not allowed to cut off service during the winter.

Just because something is a right does not mean it is provided for you free of charge, like some people here seem to believe. We have free speech and free press, that doesn't mean the government is going to reimburse me for posting an article in a newspaper. We have the right to bear arms, that doesn't mean the government is going to buy me a firearm.
 
Those of you who think that everyone has the right to internet access should ask yourselves: what kind of internet? When government "gives" internet access to everyone, they do it to give themselves an excuse to control the internet. And when governments control the internet then the internet is nothing more than another outlet for government propaganda. Read this article on pcmag.com:

Here Comes the National Internet
It's happening in Iran and the U.S. is only a few steps behind.
By John C. Dvorak
 
Those of you who think that everyone has the right to internet access should ask yourselves: what kind of internet? When government "gives" internet access to everyone, they do it to give themselves an excuse to control the internet. And when governments control the internet then the internet is nothing more than another outlet for government propaganda. Read this article on pcmag.com:

Here Comes the National Internet
It's happening in Iran and the U.S. is only a few steps behind.
By John C. Dvorak

No one is saying that the government should give everyone free internet. Please try to keep up.
 
Back
Top