timtheenchantor
Gawd
- Joined
- Jun 17, 2005
- Messages
- 962
Let's hope most people here know the difference between a privilege and a right.
+1. Some of the people here obviously don't know the difference.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Let's hope most people here know the difference between a privilege and a right.
Ugh. I hate when Steve posts these articles and the associated show of dumbassery that follows.
Internet access being a human right simply means that you have the right to purchase unimpeded access to the internet. Same as electricity, gas, and water. It means no one is allowed to cut your internet because you were a heavy user, it means your ISP can't tier your internet to make you pay more for accessing certain types of content, and it means the government isn't allowed to censor the internet.
Internet access being a basic human right does not mean "get ALL the internets for free!"
Consider which are the countries that regularly deny access to the internet:
China, North Korea, Burma, Cuba, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Vietnam, etc
Now consider how these countries rank in terms of human rights. See the correlation now?
Great strawman argument.
Because A = B and C = A, therefore B must equal C?
Not in the real world...ever.
It seems on the left we have bleeding hearts with entitlement issues and on the right we have warmongering bible beaters...
I just hope that Ron Paul's performance improves so that we can get away from both.
A utility is not a right, nor is access. Your water can be cut off, rationed or tiered. You can have it censored for only indoor use, with non-potable water used for outdoor use.Ugh. I hate when Steve posts these articles and the associated show of dumbassery that follows.
Internet access being a human right simply means that you have the right to purchase unimpeded access to the internet. Same as electricity, gas, and water. It means no one is allowed to cut your internet because you were a heavy user, it means your ISP can't tier your internet to make you pay more for accessing certain types of content, and it means the government isn't allowed to censor the internet.
Internet access being a basic human right does not mean "get ALL the internets for free!"
I'm afraid you'll never make it as a scientist...
Indeed, inductive reasoning is not an expression of definitive fact. Luckily for me, I never claimed as such. However, given the number of equivalent examples that can be found in the "real world," my argument would be considered by most reasonable parties as an example of strong induction. Or more simply stated, a correlation....
[Tripod]MajorPayne;1038234233 said:People should have the ability to exchange their currency for 100% uncensored access to the Internet.
That's as far as I'm willing to go towards declaring it a "right."
Hell, ELECTRICITY isn't even considered a "human right," and how does one propose to access the Internet without electricity?
Some people are confusing "things that are beneficial that should be able to be used by as many people as possible" with "fundamental human rights."
I think the Declaration of Independence got it right: Life, Liberty, and Pursuit of Happiness are fundamental human rights. At that point, no one is depriving you of your life, no one is holding you against your will, and no one is preventing you from (legally) attempting to live the life you want. Everything else sort of takes care of itself.
Those of you who think that everyone has the right to internet access should ask yourselves: what kind of internet? When government "gives" internet access to everyone, they do it to give themselves an excuse to control the internet. And when governments control the internet then the internet is nothing more than another outlet for government propaganda. Read this article on pcmag.com:
Here Comes the National Internet
It's happening in Iran and the U.S. is only a few steps behind.
By John C. Dvorak