Intel Tears Apart NVIDIA Ion in Document

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Bit-Tech says they have seen an internal document from Intel that supposedly details what the company feels are shortcomings in the Ion platform. Obviously we can’t comment on documents we haven’t seen with our own eyes but we do know this, with these two companies going head to head in court, one of those cans o’ whoop-ass sure would come in handy right about now.

The first point that Intel makes about Ion is that the chipset is nothing new, saying that it’s "rather a SKU of the existing MCP79M/MCP7A chipset family (branded in part as GeForce 9400M, GeForce 9400, GeForce 9300, GeForce 9100M G or GeForce 8200M G." Intel points out that "despite Nvidia’s continued execution and power problems with this chipset, Nvidia is partnering the same chipset with an Intel Atom processor and creating hype around what it calls the 'Ion Platform'."
 
And before anyone says anything, that isn't our title, that is the title of the Bit-Tech article.
 
lol, from everything I've seen, those nvidia chipsets are pretty kick-ass.. I like the point Intel made about the customers not caring about superior video decoding and light gaming duties.. hah. They needs to work on their shit in that arena before bashing Nvidia.
 
Do you stick your face on chipsets a lot? I just leave mine in the computers and don't worry about them. They do their job just fine. I've never had an nvidia overheating problem, and I've owned almost every generation since the beginning.. riva/tnt2/g4 ti4600/fx5950/7900gt/8200/8800gtx/9500m/295gtx..
 
oh, forgot about the gf2 gts... and probably a few other mobile chipsets I've had. :p
 
So is Intel bashing Nvidia for rebranding and repackaging existing tech?
 
Anyone get the feeling Intel doesn't like nvidia?

Well, NV has been publicly picking a fight with them forever (over Larabee, SLI support, Ion, Cans o' whoop-ass, etc .etc. etc.)...I am actually amazed they haven't wound up in court together before this. :eek:
 
All hail the disappearing edit button!

My thoughts are as follows... What do you get when you take a current gen laptop and remove the keyboard, LCD and battery?

The ION
 
Well, NV has been publicly picking a fight with them forever (over Larabee, SLI support, Ion, Cans o' whoop-ass, etc .etc. etc.)...I am actually amazed they haven't wound up in court together before this. :eek:
I think Jen-Hsun Huang's ego is writing checks his body (and his company) can't cash. :eek:
 
All hail the disappearing edit button!

My thoughts are as follows... What do you get when you take a current gen laptop and remove the keyboard, LCD and battery?

The ION

And shrink it all down to a little over the size of a credit card..
 
while i don't really know enough to argue which side is right or wrong, i would like to comment on the poor state of graphics in current netbooks. i haven't seen one netbook capable of running vista or windows 7 in aero mode. somebody needs to do something about this, i don't care if it's nvidia or intel.
 
while i don't really know enough to argue which side is right or wrong, i would like to comment on the poor state of graphics in current netbooks. i haven't seen one netbook capable of running vista or windows 7 in aero mode. somebody needs to do something about this, i don't care if it's nvidia or intel.
My Asus F8Sn runs Aero just fine..
 
I think most current (if not all, since I believe they all use the same GPU) can run Vista or 7 in Aero mode. My EEE 900 run aero fine.
 
oh.. I missed that he said "NETbook" ..lol. I thought he said notebook. :p In that case, I've seen the EEE run Aero just fine, as well as the Asus N10. Those are the only two netbooks I have worked with though.
 
I meant Asus N10J, I was talking to my friend about the EEE 900 and I typed that here for some reason, I know for a fact that the 900 can NOT run Aero.
 
The first point that Intel makes about Ion is that the chipset is nothing new

...oh, and the Intel GM945 chipset (or whatever Intel's using in most Atom notebooks) is anything new either? Hah!
 
Couldn't have said it better. NVIDIA chipsets have always sucked, and nothing will change that.

nforce2 and nforce4 were great, their recent intel chipsets not so hot though. I could see ion being great, well at least being better than the intel 945.
 
Couldn't have said it better. NVIDIA chipsets have always sucked, and nothing will change that.
And intel integrated graphics chipsets suck even worse.:p

I honestly would love to see a 10" netbook with integrated graphics from anyone other than intel. Integrated would keep it small, relatively cool, decent battery life, and only a slight increase in price (max +$50). The only thing that came close was the N10J that had the discrete nvidia graphics, but its price was relatively high for a netbook.
 
Do you stick your face on chipsets a lot? I just leave mine in the computers and don't worry about them. They do their job just fine. I've never had an nvidia overheating problem, and I've owned almost every generation since the beginning.. riva/tnt2/g4 ti4600/fx5950/7900gt/8200/8800gtx/9500m/295gtx..

Not sure if you ever had the 8 or 9 series mobile chipset but those were terrible.

You would be surprise the countless forums threads across HP and Dell about their videocards overheating, failing, etc. Many people are facing failures right after their 1 year warranty is over and are screw with a $400+ repair service. Some of my friends had their laptops repair under warranty only to find the same problem to happen again down the road. You can only go through a number of repairs before the warranty is over.

HP has a little band-aid for this problem which they will not admit as a manufacture defect. They release a new bios which will run the fan 24/7 in LOUD or SUPERLOUD mode. Let me tell you, it really kills the battery life.

What has nvidia done? Almost nothing the entire time. It was about 3 months ago or so they ask manufactures to not buy the old chipsets anymore but buy the new ones.

Where does this leave for the hundreds of thousands of consumers who are going through the defect chipsets? Nothing. They get nothing at all. Well except for the Dell consumers. Dell has admit the defect and is working on it. HP however turns a blind eye to it. They did a small recall on very specific models (the least produce models) but that still leaves 90%+ out in the cold.

Sorry I rant on so long. I live on campus and alot of people around knows I'm a bit more tech savvy than an average person. Not only did both my brother and father's laptop crap out from nvidia chipset, so many of my friends and people around me.

I welcome ATI and Intel mobile chipsets with open arms :).
 
Pot meets kettle. Yes, the nVIDIA 8x and 9x mobile chips are not that great, but its not like Intel has anything good in their graphics department AT ALL.

I'd rather have a shitty nVIDIA mobile chip than a sad excuse for a graphics chip from Intel.
 
I have the 9500m in my laptop.. it's pretty awesome and games quite well, also doing cuda and dxva decoding.
 
Pot meets kettle. Yes, the nVIDIA 8x and 9x mobile chips are not that great, but its not like Intel has anything good in their graphics department AT ALL.

I'd rather have a shitty nVIDIA mobile chip than a sad excuse for a graphics chip from Intel.

The 4500 series from Intel is not so bad. At least it doesn't die after a year.
 
I've never liked nvidia's backward compatibility. They always dump driver support faster on chipsets and video cards than anyone else. Amd still supports 9800pro while nvidia dumped nforce3 support while saying it was vista capable forcing people to upgrade.
 
I've never liked nvidia's backward compatibility. They always dump driver support faster on chipsets and video cards than anyone else. Amd still supports 9800pro while nvidia dumped nforce3 support while saying it was vista capable forcing people to upgrade.
Maybe that explains why ATI's drivers suck so much. Possibly it's because they are sticking with old things and not putting enough resources into their newer cards.
 
Say what you want about NVIDIA's problems their integrated graphics are vastly superior to Intel's. There is just no comparison. Whoever made these claims is either out of touch or just speaking the company line.

The claim that people dont need any more performance than intel provides is especially grating. Increase the performance and people will use it.

I wish Intel would just stop trying to run the competition out of business with lawers and exclusive agreements. Make a better product and people will buy.
 
Say what you want about NVIDIA's problems their integrated graphics are vastly superior to Intel's. There is just no comparison. Whoever made these claims is either out of touch or just speaking the company line.

Especially if you're talking about 3d acceleration in Linux. :cool:
 
Well, NV has been publicly picking a fight with them forever (over Larabee, SLI support, Ion, Cans o' whoop-ass, etc .etc. etc.)...I am actually amazed they haven't wound up in court together before this. :eek:
Any wonder why? Intel going after NV's slice of the pie and maybe NV should roll over and let Intel have it all.
 
I dont know wtf you are smoking, but ati drivers are better than nVidia lately, even on linux.
 
Say what you want about NVIDIA's problems their integrated graphics are vastly superior to Intel's. There is just no comparison. Whoever made these claims is either out of touch or just speaking the company line. .

Let's try this again:

Netbooks are for browsing the internet (hence the net in netbook). You don't need any sort of graphics power whatsoever to browse the internet. Normal people don't care about discrete graphics, only the geeks on [H].
 
intel has a point though about the rebranding stuff of nvidia, in my experience nvidia chipsets suck in the notebook environment, starting with the first one i had which was a 7200go, to even a new 9xxx series (on a macbook though), im been having problems with them (I even had a xps m1330 with the 8400gs failing just after 5 months), man before nvidia even thinks of releasing something so-called "new" can they just atleast fix what the hell is wrong with their packaging?, i had 2 ati based laptops in my office which is now more than 3-4 years of age that doesnt have catastrophic failures like most of our nvidia units have
 
whats amusing to me is that how this all started with intel saying "nvidia doesnt have the license to make chipsets for memory integrated procs" and now suddenly all of that is lost and what it feels like, is a five year old complaining...cause my daddy's car is betterrrr then your dads!!!! :D
 
intel has a point though about the rebranding stuff of nvidia, in my experience nvidia chipsets suck in the notebook environment, starting with the first one i had which was a 7200go, to even a new 9xxx series (on a macbook though), im been having problems with them (I even had a xps m1330 with the 8400gs failing just after 5 months), man before nvidia even thinks of releasing something so-called "new" can they just atleast fix what the hell is wrong with their packaging?, i had 2 ati based laptops in my office which is now more than 3-4 years of age that doesnt have catastrophic failures like most of our nvidia units have
I had two ATI based mobile chipsets, and I could never get a version of ATI's drivers that didn't give me a BSOD randomly during every day use.
 
Back
Top