Intel Sues Psion Over Netbook Name

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
What’s worse than getting sued by Dell over your attempt to cling to a trademark on the term “netbook?” Having Intel pile on and sue you for the same thing. Psion should probably look into a trademark on the term “reamed” after Dell and Intel are done with them.

Intel sued Psion Teklogik in Federal Court, demanding cancellation of the "Netbook" trademark for little computers. Intel claims the public already uses the term generically, as "extensions of the notebook category, smaller computers purpose-built for mobile Internet access."
 
I wish Psion good luck, they'll need it.

Why? They are no better than pattent trolls. 6 years ago they made a device called a netbook, they then stopped making it and haven't made it for years. Now that a new style of notebooks is out that people have started calling netbooks they came out of their hole and start bitching about how they created that term years ago for a dead product line and how nobody else is allowed to use that name.

If they were selling a device with that name that is one thing. Since it isn't hurting their sales at all, I find their claim to be bull shit and agree with Intel's comment.
 
Google didn't come up with a website for Psion Teklogik. Anyone got a link?
 
Why? They are no better than pattent trolls. 6 years ago they made a device called a netbook, they then stopped making it and haven't made it for years. Now that a new style of notebooks is out that people have started calling netbooks they came out of their hole and start bitching about how they created that term years ago for a dead product line and how nobody else is allowed to use that name.

If they were selling a device with that name that is one thing. Since it isn't hurting their sales at all, I find their claim to be bull shit and agree with Intel's comment.

Remember this is the same company that will send you cease and desist letters if you use the words INTEL-ligence, INTEL-lect or words of similar spelling in your Domain name. You reap what you sow. The big boys don't like it when it happens to them. Remember the David and Goliath story.
 
Remember this is the same company that will send you cease and desist letters if you use the words INTEL-ligence, INTEL-lect or words of similar spelling in your Domain name. You reap what you sow. The big boys don't like it when it happens to them. Remember the David and Goliath story.

I'm not saying that Intel is any better. I don't think any company should do stuff like this.

Like I said, if Psion was being hurt by this it would be one thing, but if they haven't sold anything with the world netbook in it for 5 years then they need to just give it up.
 
I'm not saying that Intel is any better. I don't think any company should do stuff like this.

Thats not what you originally said. But you did say "and how nobody else is allowed to use that name." which was my point about Intell.
 
from psion.com:

"HARDER-WARE"

i think the [H] needs to sue too!
 
Psion should probably look into a trademark on the term “reamed” after Dell and Intel are done with them.

Nah, I think poor Microsoft needs to trademark "reamed" after all the crap the EU and other countries have given them.
 
From Intel to Psion:

6a00c2251d19928e1d00e398cfebfc0004-.jpg
 
Nah, I think poor Microsoft needs to trademark "reamed" after all the crap the EU and other countries have given them.

Microsoft is like a $20 hooker. They don't like getting screwed, but its the cost of doing business and they can take it.
 
Why? They are no better than pattent trolls. 6 years ago they made a device called a netbook, they then stopped making it and haven't made it for years. Now that a new style of notebooks is out that people have started calling netbooks they came out of their hole and start bitching about how they created that term years ago for a dead product line and how nobody else is allowed to use that name.

If they were selling a device with that name that is one thing. Since it isn't hurting their sales at all, I find their claim to be bull shit and agree with Intel's comment.

...Just because you don't use the name now doesn't mean that you don't intend to use it.

Saying this means that any out of production product can be used.

So lets see how INTEL would like it if someone started selling Pentium processors... how about using the Intel Inside logo, it's no longer used, right? how about using Intel's old font which is no longer being used...
 
If you look at the spelling of the names psion.com is not the same company. Psion Teklogix is not Psion Teklogik unless there is a typo in the news.
 
The term Netbook is, by all rights, Psion's.

I don't see why people are siding against them.
 
...Just because you don't use the name now doesn't mean that you don't intend to use it.

Saying this means that any out of production product can be used.

So lets see how INTEL would like it if someone started selling Pentium processors... how about using the Intel Inside logo, it's no longer used, right? how about using Intel's old font which is no longer being used...

Exactly. Thank you.
 
There's a reason why many companies sell "Facial Tissue" and only one sells "Kleenex" still even though kleenex is the name that everyone uses for the product. Also remember only one company sells "Band-aids" even though the next time you cut yourself you'll want a bandaid not necessarily made by that company.

However I am conflicted, as long as these companies are not naming their product the "Intel Netbook" or something, but rather using the term as a classification for a particular product I have no problem with it.
 

See there's the rub, I don't think they're naming it the Mini 9 Netbook, but they're calling it the Dell Mini 9, it's in the catagory of Laptop/Netbook. Personally Dell and Intel should just agree to drop the name all together, and just stick with mini-laptop. Or hell they got cash, offer the company like $100k to drop their trademark of the name, I doubt Psion will be making much money anyways, they should be happy for the scrap.
 
See there's the rub, I don't think they're naming it the Mini 9 Netbook, but they're calling it the Dell Mini 9, it's in the catagory of Laptop/Netbook. Personally Dell and Intel should just agree to drop the name all together, and just stick with mini-laptop. Or hell they got cash, offer the company like $100k to drop their trademark of the name, I doubt Psion will be making much money anyways, they should be happy for the scrap.

Problem is it isn't just them using the name. EVERYONE is calling small laptop like that netbooks. Microsoft even has a category for them when it comes to their OS licensing.

The name took off as a category like you said, not an actual product name.
 
See there's the rub, I don't think they're naming it the Mini 9 Netbook, but they're calling it the Dell Mini 9, it's in the catagory of Laptop/Netbook. Personally Dell and Intel should just agree to drop the name all together, and just stick with mini-laptop. Or hell they got cash, offer the company like $100k to drop their trademark of the name, I doubt Psion will be making much money anyways, they should be happy for the scrap.

So if Puffs sold "Puffs brand tissues/kleenex" it'd be OK?

No, of course not. The way I see it, Psion owns the mark and Dell and Intel should drop it.
 
Problem is it isn't just them using the name. EVERYONE is calling small laptop like that netbooks.

So what? EVERYONE calls Puffs Klneex, but that doesn't mean Puffs gets to market them as Kleenex.
 
this was interesting reading:

http://www.psion.com/documents/com/specSheets/Psion_Netbook _Trademark_ Statement.pdf

go to psion's website, click on 'discontinued products' then the 'spec sheet' for netbook pro.

I also sorta have to side with psion. They may not prevent the eventual use of 'netbook' as I believe the momentum for that is too much, but with regards to being sued by intel and dell to give up the copyright? Yeah, I don't think they'll have a problem.
 
Back
Top