Intel: NVIDIA Ion is Overkill

You realize that's less than two hours of battery life on a large-ish netbook battery, right?

He said desktop genius not netbook.

The Ion netbooks get about 4 hours battery life which is more than enough for what most people will be using them for.
 
Got a Zotac ionitx-a ion are pretty nice I still consider it low power usage compare to my main system.

Is it overkill? no. I had to overclock my atom to 2100mhz from 1600mhz. Also overclock 9400m to 525mhz from 450mhz core and 1250mhz shader from 1100mhz shaders.

I think it makes a great HTPC.
 
Ion should be pointless on netbooks but it's not becasue most people who buy them don't realise they're not intented for gaming and HD video. While people are buying them for those tasks there is nothing wrong with Nvidia making netbooks capable of them. It's simply catering for market demand.

Personally I'd never bother with an Ion netbook becasue I know what a netbook is intented for and thats all I'd use it for.

Ion HTPC's are another matter. Ion is a great platfrom for HTPC's and I intend to build one soon, it will be the only PC I ever built without ATI grahics so well done Nvidia for that alone.
 
OK then. I'd like to see a video demonstration from you showing an Intel Atom powered netbook, with Intel integrated graphics, running at 24fps a 1080p video encoded with Xvid.

Intel integrated graphics are utterly useless for slightly more intensive media tasks. 1080p h.264? Nope. VC-1? Nope. Magic Super Top-Secret Experimental Intel Proprietary Codecs? Obviously.

Really? We're concerned about 1080p on a netbook, when the majority of netbooks don't even have a vertical resolution of 720 pixels, let alone 1080?

Seems there's a bit of putting the cart before the horse in this thread.
 
Really? We're concerned about 1080p on a netbook, when the majority of netbooks don't even have a vertical resolution of 720 pixels, let alone 1080?

Seems there's a bit of putting the cart before the horse in this thread.

3 words: portable media center.

Netbooks with HDMI ports can plug into televisions that DO support 1080p.
 
Really? We're concerned about 1080p on a netbook, when the majority of netbooks don't even have a vertical resolution of 720 pixels, let alone 1080?

Seems there's a bit of putting the cart before the horse in this thread.

Who said that we're using Ion on a netbook?

Ion is a great platform to make a nice, low-power HTPC, where the resolution is overwhelmingly 1080p.
 
Oh? My Atom desktop system with ION chipset pulls 22 watts.

My netbook, at full load with full screen brightness, pulls 14 watts maximum.

In throttled mode, my Asus G1 laptop with screen brightness set to 1/4 and DVD drive going... (and this is a Core2Duo with GeForce 7700, mind you) pulled 27 watts.

Does your 22 watt figure even include the screen?
 
Maybe it wouldn't cost so much extra if Intel didn't charge more for getting the CPU without Intel's accompanying chipset ... It at least makes a little difference in the cost to the end user.
 
My netbook, at full load with full screen brightness, pulls 14 watts maximum.

In throttled mode, my Asus G1 laptop with screen brightness set to 1/4 and DVD drive going... (and this is a Core2Duo with GeForce 7700, mind you) pulled 27 watts.

Does your 22 watt figure even include the screen?

Apples to oranges, I have a desktop with a load of stuff plugged into the USB ports,

Nothing optimized either (aside from XP being stripped down for maximum speed.)

And no, I have not checked the power consumption of the 24" Samsung HDTV it's driving at 1920 x 1200 =)
 
Why do people always come into these kinds of debates and provide comments like "Well they're not intended for gaming so, people who game on them are stupid or shouldn't be using the product like that as its not intended for that".

What the fuck happened to all the tech people who are proponents for using their hardware and software in manners such that they want?

Ion is providing a solution for people who want to do light gaming/htpc tasks on netbooks.

Those of you who don't want them, DON'T BUY THEM.

I'm sorry but are people that ignorant to think that nvidia/manufacturers would do all the R&D and production related costs to create these items if they didn't think they would sell?
 
I'm not quite as upset about it as you appear to be, Weenis, but I have to agree. Form factor is extremely important to some, and might even have some job-related importance. Having some extra graphics power in a very small and portable package opens up a wide range of presentation opportunities to some situations. Maybe you are a traveling professional, and you need to pack as light as possible (Most airlines actually charge even for one bag now!). So you want a device you can slip in your carry on while still having room for a change of clothes and some other travel items. You can do some light gaming with older titles on your netbook, catch up on some paperwork, and then do an HD presentation on the projector in the office when you get where you're going. And you can do it on a computer that costs less than $500. That hardly seems such a high price for a device that you're going to do so much with that takes up less than half the space and also weighs half as much as a full-sized laptop.

And competition is NEVER BAD for the consumer. Any company that can put pressure on Intel to improve their graphics capabilities is a friend to the consumer. I don't want nor need a netbook, but I can certainly see the appeal that they will have to some, and many of those customers will want Ion.
 
The ION basis of the nvidia chip with the atom cpu is innovation IMO. I always wanted to buy a netbook. My only reason for not is the god awful intel graphics. Be it a netbook or a laptop (c2d system) didnt matter as anything with that chip was a no go for me. My sister who is an internet and word user wanted one and I recommended she not get one. For petes sake a freakin pentium 2 would do her okay. Yet I still wouldnt recommend it. She did buy one though and didnt like it at all. I got her one with a 9400 chip after reselling hers on ebay and its as she puts it "omg i love my new baby". Its pretty smooth and once I show her how she can actually game on it and use it to connect to the tv she has, she was as excited as winning a brand new car. I kid you not. This is a person who doesnt know an intel from an AMD.

Anyone short changing this idea from nvidia isnt aware of how great this is.
 
I love my Ion box.. it makes a wonderful media machine under Linux with XBMC + VDPAU

Just right for the job I have for it.
 
Apples to oranges, I have a desktop with a load of stuff plugged into the USB ports,

Nothing optimized either (aside from XP being stripped down for maximum speed.)

And no, I have not checked the power consumption of the 24" Samsung HDTV it's driving at 1920 x 1200 =)

Eh, unfair comparisons mostly, but ever since having a way to measure consumption, I'm pleasantly surprised how some stuff stacks up. A lot of things use *a lot less* than I thought it would. Dell 22" 1080p monitor, at my preferred brightness setting, only pulls in about 13 watts. My mini server pulls about 15 and my desktop does just shy of 100 normal, about 130 when playing L4D.
 
I love my Ion box.. it makes a wonderful media machine under Linux with XBMC + VDPAU

Just right for the job I have for it.

I think you might have just hit what Intel is really upset about.

They blew their chances with VIIV.

(What's VIIV? Exactly.)
 
The ION basis of the nvidia chip with the atom cpu is innovation IMO. I always wanted to buy a netbook. My only reason for not is the god awful intel graphics. Be it a netbook or a laptop (c2d system) didnt matter as anything with that chip was a no go for me. My sister who is an internet and word user wanted one and I recommended she not get one. For petes sake a freakin pentium 2 would do her okay. Yet I still wouldnt recommend it. She did buy one though and didnt like it at all. I got her one with a 9400 chip after reselling hers on ebay and its as she puts it "omg i love my new baby". Its pretty smooth and once I show her how she can actually game on it and use it to connect to the tv she has, she was as excited as winning a brand new car. I kid you not. This is a person who doesnt know an intel from an AMD.

Anyone short changing this idea from nvidia isnt aware of how great this is.

I love my Ion box.. it makes a wonderful media machine under Linux with XBMC + VDPAU

Just right for the job I have for it.

Yep, and if AMD had done it first, we would've liked AMD's option, too, providing it was also quite good, but they don't have a modern chipset that can run Intel's crazy-efficient Atom CPUs. nVidia still has access to certain sockets that Intel continues to make CPU's for. AMD needs a solution like this with their own CPUs now. I would LOVE for someone else to have a supremely efficient, tiny, but reasonably capable CPU other than Intel right now.
 
pfff- the atom sucks though. only in cases where its imperative to save every bit of energy would i use one. intel meant for them to be in netbooks only... and the industry decided that they can also be used for htpc's and notebooks. we are in a very 'green' mindset these days, so people are willing to waste their time with them... but my god, for 30w more you can get so much back in performance and unless youre running on batteries you wont know the difference on the power bill. i want to install a pc inside my boombox, that is atom territory. a good htpc or notebook to me is one that can run an operating system somewhat transparently... and from what ive seen its always fairly obvious when youre running with atom chips....
 
pfff- the atom sucks though. only in cases where its imperative to save every bit of energy would i use one. intel meant for them to be in netbooks only... and the industry decided that they can also be used for htpc's and notebooks. we are in a very 'green' mindset these days, so people are willing to waste their time with them... but my god, for 30w more you can get so much back in performance and unless youre running on batteries you wont know the difference on the power bill. i want to install a pc inside my boombox, that is atom territory. a good htpc or notebook to me is one that can run an operating system somewhat transparently... and from what ive seen its always fairly obvious when youre running with atom chips....

I think you're mistaking "green" with "efficiency". Atom isn't about being green. It's about having another 4-5 hours of not being harnessed to your desk because of battery life.
 
I think you're mistaking "green" with "efficiency". Atom isn't about being green. It's about having another 4-5 hours of not being harnessed to your desk because of battery life.

i thought thats what i said... ive been hung over all day though.
 
You can run Internet games fine today with the existing solutions

my 1000HE has issue with any of those facebook Zygna games and any decent flash games can be not exactly smooth.

i think it is a joke with todays tech they cant get smooth game play for anything online.
 
i thought thats what i said... ive been hung over all day though.

Sorry, I'm also a little buzzed from the holidays :-P

I skimmed through your post too fast.

Merry Christmas :-D
 
my 1000HE has issue with any of those facebook Zygna games and any decent flash games can be not exactly smooth.

i think it is a joke with todays tech they cant get smooth game play for anything online.

That's because Flash sucks, not because Atom sucks.
 
Classic case of pretending certain market demand doesn't exist because you have nothing to supply it with :)

Meanwhile nVidia has hit a homerun with its 9400M and is making Intel look like a fool, so that Intel is now trying its best not to cry while pouting about 'overkill' and what not. Got to love how the market at times is just like a playground :p
 
On one hand, the GMA950 (and apparently the new Pine Trail GPU) is absolute garbage. It's slow, it's power hungry (at least the GMA950 is, and it doesn't support outputs like HDMI, which is kind of irrelevant since it doesn't do H.264/VC-1 decoding anyway.

But, that said, there is a certain truth here. Ion systems *do* suck at gaming. It's not really NVIDIA's fault, though, it's Intel. The GeForce 9400M is more than enough to run games like WoW or The Sims with decent settings, but they still chug on a 1.6GHz Atom.

Intel *does* have a CPU that could run such games decently (Core 2 CULV), but so far no one has done a GeForce 9400M / CULV combo system.

As a result, we end up with Ion systems that have way better 3D performance than Intel-GPU systems, but it's still not enough to really play recent games. That leaves a range of games (e.g. Warcraft III) that run like crap on the GMA 950 but aren't CPU-bound enough to be unplayable on Ion.

If you want to run these games, or if you want to use your system as an HTPC, Ion is perfect. The problem is, most people don't fit into that category - either they want to play more recent games (in which case Ion isn't adequate) or they don't care at all (in which case the power consumption and cost of Ion are disadvantages).

As for the Flash HD thing, if it becomes a bigger factor for more people, Intel 's current platform is screwed. The external decoders don't support HDMI to my knowledge, so it's kind of irrelevant whether or not you can watch videos in HD on the 10" 1024x600 display.
 
Classic case of pretending certain market demand doesn't exist because you have nothing to supply it with :)

Meanwhile nVidia has hit a homerun with its 9400M and is making Intel look like a fool, so that Intel is now trying its best not to cry while pouting about 'overkill' and what not. Got to love how the market at times is just like a playground :p

And now Apple have supposedly rejected the 32nm mobile Allendale CPUs with integrated Intel GPUs because they don't measure up to the baseline 9400M that's in every Mac. Instead they are demanding custom packages that leave off the integrated graphics. I dunno, maybe Intel needs to come up with a competitive part that their customers want instead of hating on competition that are doing a better job.
 
And now Apple have supposedly rejected the 32nm mobile Allendale CPUs with integrated Intel GPUs because they don't measure up to the baseline 9400M that's in every Mac. Instead they are demanding custom packages that leave off the integrated graphics. I dunno, maybe Intel needs to come up with a competitive part that their customers want instead of hating on competition that are doing a better job.

I guess when you're pairing a GPU with a CPU on the same die you better make sure they're more or less on-par instead of one dragging the other down. Somewhat like a Core2Duo laptop with GMA950 graphics. Having fun playing 'edit the Word document' with that powerhouse :p

It's making me question the wisdom of pairing i3 CPUs with on-die GPUs and whether it won't completely nuke this budget segment of the market. Even less technically-inclined users like to watch HD video now and then.

On the other hand, AMD has to be rubbing its hands in glee :p
 
Here's the thing: What is the purpose for a netbook? Light computer use such as web browsing and office applications, and maybe some online chatting?

Then wouldn't this guy's argument that ION is overkill be correct? The netbook was not intended nor initially intended to be a multimedia powerhouse, but to cater to those who want to do light computer usage. It boggles my mind when I read netbook reviews and time and time again they negatively review it for not being able to playback 720p/1080p movies and having a smallish screen. Well, for fuck's sakes it's a netbook, not a multimedia laptop. And, it's meant to do light computer work, nothing more.

For a thin and light multimedia replacement, a dual core Atom plus ION platform would be more than sufficient than a desktop replacement with a more powerful dedicated GPU.

And, for medium to heavy gaming, a more powerful dedicated GPU than the ION would be needed.

However, Intel's GMA 950 has to fucking go and be buried 6 feet under. There obviously has to be a more efficient and powerful integrated GPU solution than that crap.

If the netbook is meant for light computer work, then let it be that.

If the ION is for a thin and light multimedia solution, then use it for that.

If the ION has its place in HTPC machines alongside an Atom CPU, then use it for that.

But, in no ways, try to make a netbook for what it shouldn't be in the first place. Let other laptops with more powerful configurations do that job. The netbook platform was not intended to be an all-in-one laptop device. Reviewers and consumers are looking in the wrong place if they think a netbook will do that.
 
People have different demands. If a netbook can have laptop-like performance with video and games, then people will buy it apparently. Trying to keep people from defining netbooks as just a smaller laptop is truly an exercise in futility. Heck, there are full-sized laptops with a bloody Celeron M CPU and GMA graphics which are about as anemic as a 100% Intel netbook. Wouldn't that fly straight into the face of Intel when trying to define what a 'netbook' is supposed to be?

Things get smaller, faster and more powerful. Can't really stop it, now can one? :)
 
People have different demands. If a netbook can have laptop-like performance with video and games, then people will buy it apparently. Trying to keep people from defining netbooks as just a smaller laptop is truly an exercise in futility. Heck, there are full-sized laptops with a bloody Celeron M CPU and GMA graphics which are about as anemic as a 100% Intel netbook. Wouldn't that fly straight into the face of Intel when trying to define what a 'netbook' is supposed to be?

Things get smaller, faster and more powerful. Can't really stop it, now can one? :)

I'm waiting to see a Snapdragon chip power the next netbook. Those were impressive. There were concepts being shown sometime earlier this year and it was posted on Engadget several months ago. There was also a Tegra-based netbook.

I think a convergence of both a power efficient AND powerful CPU plus GPU integration is where we should be headed. We wouldn't have these criticisms and arguments about what a netbook or laptop should be. It'll probably be an all-in-one powerful solution, but we are not there-- yet.

However, we are getting ever so close now.
 
Trying to keep people from defining netbooks as just a smaller laptop is truly an exercise in futility

Plus, it's hard to classify any technology as "This is what it does, deal with it." Thousands of people will buy it, then they'll want more from it, and demand that they make them smaller and more powerful than before. Kind of like mobile phones "This phone is a little slow, I tried playing the latest port of FFXII and it ran choppy, and the screen's a little small"
 
intel is secretly backing ion platforms.

...and you're all falling for the "overkill" nonsense :)
 
Gee SixtyWattMan, seems I found a little backup to my argument that successfully shoots down your simplistic statement that "Current netbooks are not meant for gaming, period, end of story." If that's the case then why is Anandtech running gaming benchies on this CURRENT netbook? Excerpt: "Enter the latest netbook offering from ASUS: the Eee PC 1201N...So the good news is that the 1201N can definitely handle gaming… but the bad news is that it's only in some games. Falling into the "acceptable performance" category are titles like Empire: Total War, Fallout 3, Devil May Cry 4, Spore, Sims, and any other less demanding titles. A few titles are borderline, like Batman: Arkham Asylum, Borderlands, Crysis, FEAR2, Half-Life 2 EP2, Oblivion, and Enemy Territory: Quake Wars." Once again I say you have failed to grasp Tai Kwon Leap- Approach me now, that you might see...BOOT TO THE HEAD. Now I will predict your response- "Owww, you booted me in the head..." :mad:
 
As for the Flash HD thing, if it becomes a bigger factor for more people, Intel 's current platform is screwed. The external decoders don't support HDMI to my knowledge, so it's kind of irrelevant whether or not you can watch videos in HD on the 10" 1024x600 display.

It does. I bought one of these silly Ion-atom netbooks (HP mini 311) and it streams 1080p Youtube videos smoothly though it's HDMI port. I like it actually, it's far better than my POS Lenovo S10 which I sold for 200 bucks surprisingly last week before X-mas to make up the cost of my HP mini. I'm running Win7 w/ 3 gigs of RAM and use it daily (my work PC). Atom does it hold it back though, that's for sure.
 
Back
Top