Intel: NVIDIA Ion is Overkill

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
During an interview with LAPTOP Magazine, the director of netbook marketing at Intel said that the ION is overkill and overpriced. Whether or not you agree with his assessment, one thing he said is an absolute fact, it is the market that will decide the winning platform.

To run multimedia you don’t need a huge Graphics chips are responsible for processing all images sent to your computer?s display. Learn Moregraphics chip. And that’s what those third-party decoder solutions will show in the marketplace. There are much more innovative ways to get multimedia capabilities that will continue to provide lower power and longer battery life. In terms of usages, netbooks are not meant for gaming. You can run Internet games fine today with the existing solutions. We believe (Ion) adds unnecessary additional cost and the other trade-offs make it less desirable. Our customers have the option to design netbooks how they want to but ultimately the market is going to decide.

Comments
 
No hardware H.264 acceleration limits even the new pinetrail systems in the HTPC sector. Everyday light use, Intel is correct, Ion is overkill as long as you aren't a heavy user or want to use it for a portable htpc.
 
That sounds about right. Ion an expensive niche product. Unless you need a tiny, portable HTPC you're better off putting together a mini itx/micro ATX system with a serious processor/GPU. You get a lot more for your money.

Now, if Ion were to get cheaper...
 
I don't buy his argument about using offboard acceleration for HD video. The concept will likely bear fruit in the market because ION is indeed expensive and power hungry, but I still think the integrated decoder approach makes a lot more sense. The video chip already has an architecture well-suited to HD decoding, I would think it'd be more efficient from both a power and die size/cost (not to mention integration cost) standpoint to just bolt on a few more cores and stream parser to the existing video processor. Given Intel's apparent difficulty at creating a power efficient and cheap HD decoder though, perhaps this is a naive assessment.

I'm not sure the market will lean their way due to cost and much less penetration, but personally I think the video hardware is one of the biggest limitations of Intel's solution. I'd rather pay the few more dollars for an ION solution, if nVidia can get the power consumption down a bit.
 
Intel's got a narrow mind. They're thinking of netbooks when there's other reasons to have an Atom powered PC, especially in the HTPC field.

ION is definitely not overkill, especially when the 4500MHD can't handle full screen Flash h.264 videos even with Flash 10.1 (so far).
 
It might be a netbook, but there is a market for people who want a netbook, and grfx, not necessarily for gaming, but something more than the lame the intel grfx. Why is HD video on a netbook out of the question?

This is bitterness over their inability to create a decent graphics solution, as if monopolizing their way around that problem wasn't enough. Great CPU's though guys, but don't crush the video players, they're kinda cool.
 
To Intel: Anything over a P4 2.4GHZ for Joe Sixpack is overkill. Seriously, i7 to browse the web?
I on the other hand would not mind an offloaded H.264 accelerator as long as it runs cool. Cool=Quiet in an HTPC. Last thing I want is a humming HTPC while watching movie with a quiet scene.
 
ion will be used for:
wii 2 (rumor)
laptops (gaming and multimedia)
iphone (rumor?)
new phones

so its trying to revolutionize the gpu into a smaller format for other purposes. hopefully it doesnt suck... as bad as most portable gpus do
 
ion will be used for:
wii 2 (rumor)
laptops (gaming and multimedia)
iphone (rumor?)
new phones

I think you're thinking of Tegra. 3 of your list are extremely unlikely to ever use Intel's IA32/AMD64 CPUs.
 
ION is definitely not overkill, especially when the 4500MHD can't handle full screen Flash h.264 videos even with Flash 10.1 (so far).

the 4500MHD can't even wipe it's own ass let alone do it without getting shit all over it's hand:)
 
Hey Intel! Bill Gates called. He suggested that you should also mention that 640K is all you ever need.
 
i just love that intel, who normally sells dual and quad core processors to businesses that do spreadsheets and run word, is now saying that a MORE CAPABLE system for netbooks is "overkill". I mean, scratch the bluray and stuff, but seriously, most people i know buy netbooks thinking they are smaller laptops and are sad that it moves so slow and can't handle more than two programs open at a time. Intel will then introduce larrabee (sic) and then oh, look, its small, efficent, and you get a little extra boost.

I dont normally like to bash intel like that...but geez, they screwed over nvidia and now people are like ooooo...low power AND powerful...and they're like, pssshhh...well...you don't need it.
 
this guy should talk to my girlfriend, who has a 1 year old near-$800 HP laptop that chugs trying to load low-res Flash games, or anything more GPU-hungry than solitaire. I want him to do that, then try to stand by this statement again.

intel graphics suck, plain and simple, and this guy knows it.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Next time Intel says something is overpriced, I'm just going to respond with a link to an Extreme series processor.
 
huge Graphics chips
The 9400M is diminutive. There's a reason Apple can jam a 9400M in alongside a 9600M in the MacBook Pro, and it's not due to some amazing feat of engineering.
 
I don't buy his argument about using offboard acceleration for HD video. The concept will likely bear fruit in the market because ION is indeed expensive and power hungry, .

Oh? My Atom desktop system with ION chipset pulls 22 watts.
 
I got my wife a netbook for Christmas, and I paid the premium for Ion. (Ion LE) It's just nice having a graphics card that can run her display at 720p and not choke. I hooked up my friends netbook to my 720p display, and it was struggling.

I honestly don't know if it affected her battery life better or worse than the intel solution, but the Atom needs all the video decode help it can get. ;)
 
intel graphics can't play HD flash?

blame that on shitty coded adobe/flash software.

as a video codec/player/whateveryouwannacallit, flash is inefficient, and unnecessarily cpu hungry. WTF is it calculating? the performance to power ratio is low as hell.

everything should be encoded in something like xvid, which doesn't even stress a 7 year old cpu like flash does.
 
In terms of usages, netbooks are not meant for gaming.
Tell that to my phone which was never "meant" to: Show my exact position on the globe, identify any song on the radio, take pictures and videos, play movies, recognize voice commands, give me driving directions, surf the net, and oh yeah- play games. What a bitter lil' man. I bet when he flies cross-country to give his dumb little monologues that he holds the toe brakes while the pilot gets out to grab a giant wooden prop, leap in the air and fire up the Waco Mystery Ship. Buddy, we are the market, we are gamers, and, we- will- decide.:eek:
 
[X];1035096542 said:
Tell that to my phone which was never "meant" to: Show my exact position on the globe, identify any song on the radio, take pictures and videos, play movies, recognize voice commands, give me driving directions, surf the net, and oh yeah- play games. What a bitter lil' man. I bet when he flies cross-country to give his dumb little monologues that he holds the toe brakes while the pilot gets out to grab a giant wooden prop, leap in the air and fire up the Waco Mystery Ship. Buddy, we are the market, we are gamers, and, we- will- decide.:eek:

Netbooks are not meant for gaming.
 
intel graphics can't play HD flash?

blame that on shitty coded adobe/flash software.

as a video codec/player/whateveryouwannacallit, flash is inefficient, and unnecessarily cpu hungry. WTF is it calculating? the performance to power ratio is low as hell.

everything should be encoded in something like xvid, which doesn't even stress a 7 year old cpu like flash does.

OK then. I'd like to see a video demonstration from you showing an Intel Atom powered netbook, with Intel integrated graphics, running at 24fps a 1080p video encoded with Xvid.

Intel integrated graphics are utterly useless for slightly more intensive media tasks. 1080p h.264? Nope. VC-1? Nope. Magic Super Top-Secret Experimental Intel Proprietary Codecs? Obviously.
 
Netbooks are not meant for gaming.
I suppose notebooks are just for taking notes?
Perhaps if you were the HundredWattMan you
would be bright enough to see that by the de facto
progression of technology you most certainly will
be gaming on netbooks. Well, maybe not you. No,
you'll just whine til' you can watch Teenage Mutant
Ninja Turtles in Blu-Ray quality on your "Netbook".:mad:
You fail to grasp Tai Kwon Leap... Boot to the head.:D
 
Seems like intel is fearing for it's line of entry level gfx chips, I think it's great that solutions such as the ion platform exist for netbook en small form factor desktop computers....although I would love to see a simular system from AMD perhaps :)
 
Seems like intel is fearing for it's line of entry level gfx chips, I think it's great that solutions such as the ion platform exist for netbook en small form factor desktop computers....although I would love to see a simular system from AMD perhaps :)

AMD does have one, and it is in fact about the price of the ION platform. It's got an X1250 chip.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834152141

I came really close to buying it, and then almost bought this model:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834110399

But then went with the Atom/Ion solution because the reviews said the ion had better battery life. The Wife's requirement was Flash Movies, DVD Rip's, and battery life.

The HP Mini satisfied all of that.
 
[X];1035096702 said:
I suppose notebooks are just for taking notes?
Perhaps if you were the HundredWattMan you
would be bright enough to see that by the de facto
progression of technology you most certainly will
be gaming on netbooks. Well, maybe not you. No,
you'll just whine til' you can watch Teenage Mutant
Ninja Turtles in Blu-Ray quality on your "Netbook".:mad:
You fail to grasp Tai Kwon Leap... Boot to the head.:D

Current netbooks are not meant for gaming, period, end of story. They are not equipped with the hardware, not a decent CPU, GPU, or even an optical drive for that matter which is needed for some games. The default ion platform consisting of the Intel graphics is barely equipped for flash video and cannot do 720p. Oh and guess what? They are selling like fucking free blowjobs, I guess the consumers have spoken.
 
Current netbooks are not meant for gaming, period, end of story. They are not equipped with the hardware, not a decent CPU, GPU, or even an optical drive for that matter which is needed for some games. The default ion platform consisting of the Intel graphics is barely equipped for flash video and cannot do 720p. Oh and guess what? They are selling like fucking free blowjobs, I guess the consumers have spoken.

I said ion platform and I meant Atom. Is there some reason we still don't have Edit on this forum?

Also Told Status
[X] Told
[ ] Not Told
 
You realize that's less than two hours of battery life on a large-ish netbook battery, right?

Where did you get that number? Sounds very low!

I have a small Sony Viao laptop that pulls 33 watts (at idle, can't recall while playing) and it will run for 4 hours playing digital movies for a point of reference.
 
Current netbooks are not meant for gaming, period, end of story. They are not equipped with the hardware, not a decent CPU, GPU, or even an optical drive for that matter which is needed for some games. The default ion platform consisting of the Intel graphics is barely equipped for flash video and cannot do 720p. Oh and guess what? They are selling like fucking free blowjobs, I guess the consumers have spoken.

And consumers are playing games on them, which sort of shoots your argument all too hell.

Consumers have no clue what the platform is suppose to be aimed at, they just see a small laptop.
 
And consumers are playing games on them, which sort of shoots your argument all too hell.

Consumers have no clue what the platform is suppose to be aimed at, they just see a small laptop.

Most retailers also market them as such...
 
The only reason I would've ever bought an ION is the fact that it can play most modern games, but I just got the cheapest netbook I could find, which was $230 ;)
 
Where did you get that number? Sounds very low!
Egads, you're right. I picked the largest random one from eBay (should be vastly overspecced from OEM, so conservative), plugged the specs into Wolfram Alpha because I was too lazy to do simple multiplication, and then misread the result, not realizing it was misinterpreting me.

With the battery I picked out, the figure should have been a bit under 4h. (7900mAh @ 11.1V = 87.7Wh @ 22W = 4h). Not that bad really, assuming that's at full load.
 
I dunno, how about letting the consumers decide what they want instead of telling them?

I think proper, hardware accelerated video playback is more important for nettops than for netbooks. A nettop is a perfect HTPC, except it can't play high quality video. With a netbook and a 10" screen or so, running at 1024x600, high-quality video becomes less important than on a 32" TV. It's a shame the new Atoms with integrated GPU don't accelerate video properly.

As for games...well Ion allows you to play most games at 800x600 with minimum detail settings. Is that really so important?
 
ION is overkill because intel has nothing to match it and wants to keep nvidia out of the market :rolleyes: How many anti trust cases is it going to take for these dolts to play nice with other companies.
 
Back
Top