intel mobo question

PCnoob4now

n00b
Joined
Sep 18, 2004
Messages
2
This question is concerning the "Intel D865 PERLL" i'm going to buy one configuered so i'd just have to pop it into my case and go.... my question is this.... which config is better AND why??

Intel Pentium 4 3.2Ghz 1mb Cache (800MHz FSB) w/ 2 GB PC3200 DDR (512 MB PC3200 x4)


OR

Intel Pentium 4 3.4 GHz (i'm assuming no cache since it wasn't stated) (800MHz FSB) w/ 1 GB PC3200 DDR (512 MB PC3200 x2) and Kingston HyperX Low Latency (CAS-2)
 
I don't much about memory but the 3.4 GHz does have 2 levels of cache with the 2nd level being at least 512Kb.

There are a few different 3.2 and 3.4GHz. You are most likely looking at either a prescot or a northwood core chip. I'v read the northwood wins out head to head against the prescot in most applications and that the prescot runs hotter.

Don't focus only a cpu's clock speed. Good luck.
 
There are only 3 3.4GHz chips that will work in a D865PERL, a Northwood Pentium 4 and a Prescott 3.4. Finally theres a 3.4 Extreme Edition that works in that board as well.

Differences

Northwood 3.4GHz 512K L2 Cache 800MHz FSB HT Enabled
Prescott 3.4GHz 1024MB L2 Cache 800MHz FSB HT Enabled
Gallatin 3.4GHz 512K L2 Cache, 2MB L3 Cache 800MHz FSB HT Enabled

Some sites still refer to the Extreme Edition CPU's as Northwoods. They aren't. Northwood's cache design doesn't allow for L3 cache. It's not really a Gallatin either as it doesn't support SMP, but it is closer to a Gallatin Xeon chip than a Northwood.

The 3.4 Extreme Edition is the fastest. Also the most expensive. Not worth it IMO. The

Prescott is a little slower in some apps. It has a longer pipeline that affects it's performance negatively Vs. Northwood cores. However the extra cache ram offsets this penalty somewhat. HT is also improved as there are more data pipelines for the HT to work with. Thus improving overall efficiency. Prescott also runs hotter, but is a great overclocker. With proper cooling.

Northwood CPU's are tried and true favorites of the Intel enthusiest. Good OC'ing ability, low heat and very reliable. Also has a greater list of motherboards that are compatible.

You can use any of the three on that board. I've currently got a D865PERL and a Pentium 4 3.0E Prescott CPU running in my other computer. Rock solid and the temps are only about 10-20 higher, but aren't a problem because I have decent case ventalation and I'm not overclocking.

The newer versions of that board are capable of some OC'ing but not much. Intel boards historically do not allow the end user to do much if anything with OC'ing. So if you want to OC, I'd choose another board. If you've got insane cash to blow, I'd go with the 3.4EE but I'd probably choose a more well featured board, such as the P4C800-E Deluxe or the Abit IC7 Max 3.

The Northwood and Prescotts will perform about the same. Some apps favor Prescott and others favor Northwood. Although if you don't keep your house cold and don't want to upgrade to a monster heatsink and fan I'd stick with Northwood.

Between the two choices of configuration I'd go with the 3.4GHz chip and 1GB of ram. You won't see any performance increase with 2GB of ram in 95% of all the apps you could possibly run. The faster CPU will be a better use of your money as overclocking won't be part of the equation since you've chosen an Intel board.
 
Back
Top