Intel Insists Atom Only For Intel Chipsets

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Despite their best efforts, the folks at NVIDIA just don’t seem to be making any headway with Intel and its Atom platform. Earlier this month, there were reports that NVIDIA was trying to force itself on Intel but it would seem those efforts didn’t bear much fruit either.

Intel reiterated that Atom CPUs for netbooks and nettops are only available bundled with its 945GSE and 945GC chipsets, the makers said. When asked to comment, Intel indicated that it has no plans to validate the Nvidia MCP79 chipset on Atom-based nettop or netbook platforms. Intel also has no plans to form a partnership with Nvidia to support nettop or netbook platforms based on the Intel Atom CPU, the company added.
 
So Intel insists on pushing Netbook and Nettops with rock bottom GPU power? You can't even decode H.264 1080p with the 945, and you have dropped frames with 720p....

Greedy Intel.
 
Perhaps this could be an opportunity for AMD or another competitor to bring a worthy competitor to the Atom? My lot of Nvidia stock would appreciate it.
 
This is stupid.

It leaves a huge opening for AMD... Even if it's not as profitable as other platforms right now it's a growing market and they shouldn't waste any time.
 
sad, because Nv has a different chip set that corresponds with a slightly fast Atom (forget its name, but its 1.86 ghz) and it can do a funky SLI between the GPU (a 9300m gs) and the chipset and create performance of a 16 shader 9400m (the 9300 only has 8)

Still, the Atom is the weakest link, but after seeing what the feeble little 9300 can do, Id love to see it with twice the shaders

(Ive tried out the N10 with the 9300 and mine is already on the way, good bye EEE)
 
This is stupid.

It leaves a huge opening for AMD... Even if it's not as profitable as other platforms right now it's a growing market and they shouldn't waste any time.

except for the fact they dont have a low power processor, or one that even comes close to rivaling intel's atom..

thus taking time and money on R&D for one, ultimately leading them to join the party way later and missing the profitable parts.
 
Edit: What's up with that new VIA processor? Status?
Waffles. Remember how nvidia teamed up with VIA to make a non-Intel "gaming" platform with a demonstration of Crysis running? Probably not a great strategy in retrospect. :D
 
This is stupid.

It leaves a huge opening for AMD... Even if it's not as profitable as other platforms right now it's a growing market and they shouldn't waste any time.
AMD dropped by 2% at Dell and HP, and Atom has 3% of the market already. What were you saying? :p

AMD doesn't even have a competitor for Atom anyways, and probably won't for a long time (if ever). ARM may get a share of the toy netbook segment, but anyone who wants more than a slow PDA's speed* and Windows/x86 Linux compatibility is going to buy Atom. Atom will continue to do very well, even without nvidia chipsets. AMD is only going after the ultra mobile (4lbs vs ~2lb netbooks), a much smaller niche than netbooks.

* me = suffering with a slow ARM-based Nokia handheld, so I know what to expect and no one is buying the current ARM based netbooks.
 
umm the atom is a pos processor and nvidia wanted to push SLI for netbooks come on peope netbooks are speced the way they are for a reason your not supposed to decode 720P/1080P its a basic web/email notebook for sh!ts sake
 
So Intel insists on pushing Netbook and Nettops with rock bottom GPU power? You can't even decode H.264 1080p with the 945, and you have dropped frames with 720p....

Greedy Intel.

It's a netbook not a HiDef mutlitmedia entertainment system.
 
to add they are not supposed to be all powerful its for basic users yet some people waht their 10" to preform like a laptop get real people
 
Anybody that looks at Netbooks as some high definition mobile multimedia solution needs to have their heads kicked again so they reset. I'm glad Intel is giving Nvidia the finger, I really am. In my own experience of having to resolve issues with so many non-Intel parts over the years, I'm absolutely assured I'll never use anything but Intel hardware. It was a decision I made decades ago and I don't regret it to this day.

If someone gave me the best laptop on the market today, maxed out to the brim with all that you can do in a laptop form and it was based on an Nvidia chipset or some other non-Intel brand, it would be on Craig's List or fleaBay within an hour of taking possession of it...

"That's my story... and I'm stickin' to it..."
 
except for the fact they dont have a low power processor, or one that even comes close to rivaling intel's atom..

thus taking time and money on R&D for one, ultimately leading them to join the party way later and missing the profitable parts.

amd has a lowpower A64 and with the 780m chipset the power usage comes within a few watts of an atom platform prob see it sometime next year
 
nVidia should team with VIA with their Nano CPU. If only big names would buy the Nano.... Everybody seems to be blindly stuck with the Atom.

Don't forget, theirs a dual-core Atom, so the Atom is not just for basic low performance needs. And even if Netbook are not supposed to be performance laptop, I'd be happy to watch some movies on it while traveling. I don't need a Core2 for my basic needs, but the Atom+945 are very poor performers.
 
nVidia should team with VIA with their Nano CPU. If only big names would buy the Nano.... Everybody seems to be blindly stuck with the Atom.

Don't forget, theirs a dual-core Atom, so the Atom is not just for basic low performance needs. And even if Netbook are not supposed to be performance laptop, I'd be happy to watch some movies on it while traveling. I don't need a Core2 for my basic needs, but the Atom+945 are very poor performers.

you can watch a movie on it not 1080p or 720P but you can your not supposed to watch high def on it
 
Maxius. Please type in sentences with punctuation. Reading a bunch of run-on fragments is very difficult.
 
nVidia should team with VIA with their Nano CPU. If only big names would buy the Nano.... Everybody seems to be blindly stuck with the Atom.

Don't forget, theirs a dual-core Atom, so the Atom is not just for basic low performance needs. And even if Netbook are not supposed to be performance laptop, I'd be happy to watch some movies on it while traveling. I don't need a Core2 for my basic needs, but the Atom+945 are very poor performers.

I watch movies on a Efficeon with an ATI Mobility Radeon w/16mb of video memory....the Atom+945 is better than that setup.
 
I had an Eee 900 a few weeks ago, and that's based on the lowly Celeron chip at 900 MHz and it was playing back x.264 files I have in AVI format without much hassles, no skipped frames, etc. Same thing for some Xvid stuff I have also... but trying to look at Netbooks for really serious HD playback? Get real, it's not even in their design capabilities most of the time, even with the GMA950 or something else which can handle HD playback without much trouble at all.

It is amazing that so many people keep trouncing on Netbooks because they're not "normal" laptops/notebooks - do people simply not realize they're another class of product entirely, or is this still being missed overall?
 
Buy a Sony Vaio UMPC if you want mobility and horsepower. Don't add stuffs to the netbook because the idea behind netbooks is cheap and mobile. Keep adding more to the netbooks, soon the price will reach the Vaio UMPC price minus the faster CPU.
 
I could care less about getting more graphic content out of the netbook platform. I just want lower power consumption so that smaller batteries can be used and still get decent life.
 
So Intel insists on pushing Netbook and Nettops with rock bottom GPU power? You can't even decode H.264 1080p with the 945, and you have dropped frames with 720p....

Greedy Intel.

That is a lie the Atom 320 has ample power to run this video:

"Beijing Olympics 2008 HD 1080p Opening Ceremonies"
I've have seen this done IRL myself.
Don't post FUD.
 
So Intel insists on pushing Netbook and Nettops with rock bottom GPU power? You can't even decode H.264 1080p with the 945, and you have dropped frames with 720p....

Greedy Intel.

I was thinking the same thing. I guess Intel really wants to push the low power consumption/low cost capability as they have newer chipsets than can handle HD decoding. I really wish NVIDIA could offer a competing chipset for those users wanting a bit more power.
 
Yea, I'm wondering why anyone is even bothering with Intel netbooks...
 
sad, because Nv has a different chip set that corresponds with a slightly fast Atom (forget its name, but its 1.86 ghz) and it can do a funky SLI between the GPU (a 9300m gs) and the chipset and create performance of a 16 shader 9400m (the 9300 only has 8)

Still, the Atom is the weakest link, but after seeing what the feeble little 9300 can do, Id love to see it with twice the shaders

(Ive tried out the N10 with the 9300 and mine is already on the way, good bye EEE)

IIRC the only difference between the 9300 and 9400 is clock speed.
the 9400 runs at 580 MHz core and 1400 MHz shader clocks while the 9300 runs at 450 MHz core and 1200 MHz shader clocks
Many over at AVS opted to buy the 9300 based boards and try to bump up the clocks as the 9400 had yet to be released.
 
hmm, could have swore it had 16 shaders.. but o well, it still performs better, Ive seen the 9400m and its not bad.

And about the netbooks being just for web and email, ya, thats the primary, but its nice to be able to watch some movies (you can do 1080p with HW accel) do some more complex tasks, and play a small game here or there (Far Cry 2 actually at low/med settings, and many others except Crysis)

Its not designed to do that, but its sure nice to be able too. All in a small form factor, thats why I love the N10.
 
NV is getting a taste of their own medicine. They locked out SLI on 975 chipsets, so they could sell more of their own. I agree that we get shafted by this, but NV deserves this.
Locking us out of SLI and offering their sub par chipset junk for their own profit back in the day was BS.

Soon they will be back to making just video cards again.
 
NV is getting a taste of their own medicine. They locked out SLI on 975 chipsets, so they could sell more of their own. I agree that we get shafted by this, but NV deserves this.
Locking us out of SLI and offering their sub par chipset junk for their own profit back in the day was BS.

Soon they will be back to making just video cards again.

QFT!

They hardballed Intel, Intel is now returning the favour by saying no to NVIDIA's chipset for i7 and Atom...:D
 
i just dont understand why intel cant make decent graphics. i mean their stuff isnt even capable of normal shit... i just dont get it.
 
AMD doesn't even have a competitor for Atom anyways, and probably won't for a long time (if ever).

It may not be an absolute direct competitor to the Intel Atom processor, but AMD does in fact have low power processors that have power ratings less than 2W: The AMD Geode LX 800 and 900.

http://www.amd.com/us-en/ConnectivitySolutions/ProductInformation/0,,50_2330,00.html

I do not know how they compare against the Intel Atom in terms of compute power and performance nor do I know what modern chipsets would work with them... but AMD can at least leverage the Geode LX processors for nettops and such.
 
poorly. The Geode is an ancient design and badly shows its age. The XO uses a geode, noone else in the laptop/netbook world has been foolish enough to do the same.
 
I'm glad at least a couple people in here understand a bit of the backstory on why Intel wants to let Nvidia fail. Look up some past stories at about how Nvidia basically thumbed their noses at Intel in every which direction they could. Their CEO publically saying that Intel was a company of the past, that Nvidia's chips were all that mattered and that CPUs would die. Nvidia flexes it's muscle at every opportunity. They are running their company the wrong way. They did the same thing to Microsoft several years ago - pissed off Microsoft because they wouldn't lower the price of their graphics card chips which ultimately is the reason the original xbox is defunct. Microsoft couldn't get cheaper prices on the video card! and so they just stopped producing the box all together. That's the reason Microsoft went with ATI this generation (for the 360). After the Nvidia company spit so much trash out of their mouths about Intel being old hat and not worth anything any more it's no wonder Intel is angry. What's funny is that Intel sits on a HUGE pile of cash, and I've heard it said that if Intel wanted to go into performance graphics cards - it could beat Nvida and ATI at their own games within two generations of graphics cards - but they don't want to go there. That's not where the money is -- -they like their integrated graphics cards that OEMs buy in huge volumes. Nvidia better straighten up some of their partnerships and relationships or they are going south fast. I say that regretably because I vestment in their stock.
 
I'm glad at least a couple people in here understand a bit of the backstory on why Intel wants to let Nvidia fail. Look up some past stories at about how Nvidia basically thumbed their noses at Intel in every which direction they could. Their CEO publically saying that Intel was a company of the past, that Nvidia's chips were all that mattered and that CPUs would die. Nvidia flexes it's muscle at every opportunity. They are running their company the wrong way. They did the same thing to Microsoft several years ago - pissed off Microsoft because they wouldn't lower the price of their graphics card chips which ultimately is the reason the original xbox is defunct. Microsoft couldn't get cheaper prices on the video card! and so they just stopped producing the box all together. That's the reason Microsoft went with ATI this generation (for the 360). After the Nvidia company spit so much trash out of their mouths about Intel being old hat and not worth anything any more it's no wonder Intel is angry. What's funny is that Intel sits on a HUGE pile of cash, and I've heard it said that if Intel wanted to go into performance graphics cards - it could beat Nvida and ATI at their own games within two generations of graphics cards - but they don't want to go there. That's not where the money is -- -they like their integrated graphics cards that OEMs buy in huge volumes. Nvidia better straighten up some of their partnerships and relationships or they are going south fast. I say that regretably because I vestment in their stock.
Until Intel can do a proper IGP like AMD 780G, I don't think they will fight in the high end segment within two generation.
 
That's just so typical Intel. But the Atom would still be a bottleneck.
How much would the nvidia 9400m solution differ from Intels chipset in power consumption? Isn't the 945 eating a lot more power than Atom itself?
 
Back
Top