Intel G2 - RAID1, TRIM, and performance questions

night_2004

2[H]4U
Joined
May 31, 2007
Messages
2,229
From what I understand, TRIM and RAID still do not play well together with Intel G2 drives. Has that changed at all?

If not, then how well does the G2 gracefully age without TRIM? Is that something I even need to worry about?
 
As far as I know, there's still no TRIM for RAIDed drives, but wait for someone else to confirm that because I haven't been paying attention too closely.

But here are some benchmarks showing how the G2 ages: http://www.anandtech.com/show/2738/13

Your random write speed will eventually come down to 23mb/s from 39mb/s, still much faster than any hard drive.
 
To be frank I'm not holding my breath until for RAID with trim until 3rd gen SSDs arrive.
 
I guess the next big question at this point...are there any outstanding concerns or problems with the Intel drives? I remember all the fun that Intel users had with firmware bugs a while back...

I'm not trying to scare up problems or be a troll, I'm just trying to get the facts. I don't really feel like dropping $600 in SSDs until I've got the facts and addressed all my concerns :).
 
The BIOS password bug introduced itself when intel released the first TRIM-capable firmware for the G2.

I can imagine they overlooked this BIOS password thing; as its not something you usually test; you usually test whether your SSD corrupts with heavy use of TRIM in a heavy load simulated environment.

Assuming the Intel is one of the best sold SSDs, that means if they had any obvious weakness; you would see long forum threads talking about them and alot of people coming with horror stories. Though i've seen some people with a failed intel SSD, i cannot rule out any external cause (i.e. voltage problems; hot-plugged with cold-plug connector; etc). Given the low volume of these stories, i would assume there is no inherent weakness with the Intel SSD.

So as far as track record, i think the Intel is likely the most reliable SSD available at this time.
 
I've got 2 of the 80gb G2 SSDs, haven't had a single problem. I also had an OCZ Agility for a while, and also was relatively problem free. There were firmware bugs for both Intel and OCZ/Indilinx drives a while back (check the OCZ forums, there have been some horror stories), but it seems like almost everything has been ironed out. My Intels have been humming along for the past 6 months and couldn't be happier.
 
Yeah, the reason I'm considering the Intel SSDs?

I'm one of the "nicer" OCZ horror stories. The drives drop out of my RAID array once every month or two.
 
Back
Top