Intel Deliberately Limiting Sandy Bridge Overclocking?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to the crew at Bit-Tech, Intel’s Sandy Bridge is designed to deliberately limit overclocking. Here’s a quote from the news post:

A video leaked to HKEPC and posted on YouTube (see from 2mins onwards) confirms the fact that only a 2-3 per cent OC via Base Clock adjustments will be possible. This is because Intel has tied the speed of every bus (USB, SATA, PCI, PCI-E, CPU cores, Uncore, memory etc) to a single internal clock generator issuing the basic 100MHz Base Clock.
 
Why would they do that? Do they think most enthusiasts will buy Extreme edition chips?:eek: Completely stupid thing to do. Many people will go with AMD.
 
Bad move intel, im going back to amd when the time comes to upgrade my core i7 920. It gives you a little bit of time to think about what you have done but till then.

I am dissapoint
 
I find this very hard to believe. Probably just something they are doing in the early prototype chip.
 
The same thing was said about Nehalem before it was released. And guess what, it overclocked like a beast when it was released.
 
Intel still plans to sell K-series CPUs which come with an unlocked CPU multiplier - and with this move, the K-series CPUs start to make a lot more sense, as they will be the only Intel CPUs capable of overclocking.

It could be a move to develop a k-line of processors for people who want to OC. Perhaps they will introduce a wider range of these chips at more price points. Therefore the cost/efficiency advantages are passed onto large OEM builds and mobile builds, while people who want to OC can still buy the K-series CPUs.

This does affect me though, I had originally wanted to either stick with my current cpu or upgrade to a c2quad and wait out to Sandy Bridge, since lga1156/1366 are effectively end of life with Sandy Bridges socket changes, and to hold off having to replace ram. This is now making me consider going to lga1156.

Still a bit hesitant on going AMD due to the gap in per core performance in certain situations.
 
Isn't this like the 3rd or 4th generation of processors where people said overclocking was over? :p

We chatted about possible work-arounds but at the moment the few 'asynchronous' setups tried were currently not working. It's been claimed to use out-of-the-box the design was deliberately limited with the intention to simplify board design and lower costs.
 
Greeeeeeat. So it means that the only good overclocking is going to allowed on $1000+ 'X' series processors....

And the alternative is AMD. For which, I know of no AMD mobo's that support SLI (at least not without sacrificing some SLI performance)

This is shitty news.
 
Isn't this like the 3rd or 4th generation of processors where people said overclocking was over? :p

I was kind of thinking that too. All we can really do is wait and see I guess. But it wouldn't surprise me if intel did this to force overclockers into their extreme series of processors.
 
Greeeeeeat. So it means that the only good overclocking is going to allowed on $1000+ 'X' series processors....

And the alternative is AMD. For which, I know of no AMD mobo's that support SLI (at least not without sacrificing some SLI performance)

This is shitty news.


theres only a couple with the 980a 780a and 680a.. blame nvidia dont blame AMD.. nvidia's the one that decided to drop AMD motherboard support and honestly i dont care if they did since they havent released a half decent chipset since the NF4..
 
already future proofed my seti builds to accept 1090T's with the boards i bought. also already have one so far ;). can't wait till they are cheaper :)
 
But it wouldn't surprise me if intel did this to force overclockers into their extreme series of processors.

The extreme series is way to expensive for my budget.
I prefer to buy the low-end CPU's, and cheaply over-clocked them to a little faster than the high end CPU's :)

An i3 530 @ 3.6Ghz, on stock voltage & with the stock heat sink, since makes for a cheap, quick and quite system.
 
maybe they'll provide reasonably priced unlocked cpus?

The $1000 price tag isn't necessary right? they just mark it up?

They aren't adding any expensive hardware to achieve the unlock?
 
If it is true...I guess AMD will get its cult following back without much effort.

This.

Amazing how they could go from being the number one overclocker (no better value than i7 920 / i7 930) for $200 at Microcenter's and Fry's around the country to being gigantic pricks in only one generation.
 
Isn't this like the 3rd or 4th generation of processors where people said overclocking was over? :p
Yeah, no kidding. As usual, I'll definitely bite my nails in anticipation of reviews since I don't overclock, anyway. :p
 
This probably has less to do with the enthuiast market than it does the retail market. We make up a VERY small portion of CPU sales. The big names, like Dell, are massive. Dell has started selling overclocked PCs. I think this is what Intel wants to stop. Overclocks were so easy to get that Dell could bump up the frequency on the 920s a bit and charge more, which they did. This is free profit for Dell as they keep their "overclocking fee". Intel made no money on this. They basicly want to stop OEMs from overclocking instead of buying more expensive cpus.
 
Hopefully this is a false report or AMD could stand to pick up some market share. My last build I went AMD simply because I had a budget and a 955be build was about the best bang for the buck inside of that budget......then a month later they released i5.....
 
maybe they'll provide reasonably priced unlocked cpus?

The $1000 price tag isn't necessary right? they just mark it up?

They aren't adding any expensive hardware to achieve the unlock?

i would think it actually costs money to lock the multiplier
 
IF this is true, IF, I may go back to AMD depending on comparative price performance and likelihood of an OC on the AMD hardware. If it is like it is now, where the AMDs have to be OCed a just to compete with stock Intel I7 offerings, it will not change my buying habits.
Then again, I almost regret buying my I7 setup. I have a single 5870 in both an I7 920 @ 3.2 Ghz and a Core2quad (q9300) @ 3.0 Ghz, and whatever the benches might say, I can't tell the difference between the two in games at 1920x1200 - 5760x1200.
 
it sounds like the cost-cutting measure is more appropraite for i5s than i7s so I doubt it will be on the 920 replacement!
 
I find this very hard to believe. Probably just something they are doing in the early prototype chip.

The same thing was said about Nehalem before it was released. And guess what, it overclocked like a beast when it was released.

I agree, Francois Piednoel one of the chief engineers at Intel has stated several times that they see value in overclocking. It's not the first time that this has been claimed before a chip is released.
 
Could be all BS.

But in a way (I don't like it) it does make sense.

For years mobo manufacturers have been finding ways of getting cheaper CPUs to reach the speeds of the expensive ones, which cuts into Intel's/AMD profits, while at the same time charging a big premium on the boards which can do this.

Maybe Intel is thinking now it's their CPU, so they should be making the money of the OCing (via marketing Turbo Mode and marking up K Chips), not the mobo guys.

Be kind of like if Nissan decided to design engines that disabled themselves if a non-factory turbo was detected and at the same time introducing a new line of highly marked up factory turbo-charged engine options.
 
Oh well, back to AMD I guess.

I actually just fired up my old 939 2500+ system, to operate my CnC, sure was easy to overclock it to 3200+.
 
We'll see. Intel isn't going to give away the performance crown if AMD can reach it through overclocking. And I don't think that this is the first time I've heard this claim either for some reason. Didn't this come up a few years back?
 
For years mobo manufacturers have been finding ways of getting cheaper CPUs to reach the speeds of the expensive ones, which cuts into Intel's/AMD profits, while at the same time charging a big premium on the boards which can do this.

This might be true, but even with higher priced boards, we're still not used to paying high prices for CPU's. If this is what Intel thinks then I think they will be in for a shock. Because I'm not paying $600, $700, $800 or more on a CPU just to overclock. I'd either pick up an AMD or I would settle for a *GASP* stock clocked Intel. And I don't think I'm alone here.

There are a few slides showing something about external clocks so I don't think it's as dire as the headlines.
 
That's Intel for you guys.

To be honest, this is all of our fault. Intel is doing this because of all of us who bought an Intel Core i7 920 or 930 from Micro Center for $199 and overclocked to be faster than the extreme edition i7 975 which still retails for $799. Why in the hell should I pay $800 for performance I can get from a $200 cpu?

Well, I hope this isn't true but I doubt that we will put much of a dent on Intel just by all switching back to AMD. After all, all of us hardcore users are only about 2% of the entire cpu market as the other 98% are usually uninformed naive people.
 
Damn this is the first time since the 939 days that I see AMD in my future.
 
all you fair weather fans are not invited back..shoo shoo! :p


p.s. I highly doubt this will be the case when the chips see the light of day, or they'll be mobo's that can get around the issue. Do you realize what this would do to the enthusiast Intel mobo market? It would literally kill it.

Not sure how this plays out for Nvidia either if true...
 
They never lost the cult following. They will just get the sensible ones back.

I wouldn't consider myself part of the amd "cult" but I do use them why I can. Phenom 2 was the first time I used an AMD in almost 3 years and I'd say I'm pretty sensible. They had something competitive and for the right price.
 
sounds like intel is trying to get more money from the overclockers to me. thanks assholes, guess i'll be going back to AMD next time around.

kinda defeats the purpose of overclocking....wasn't it partly to get a fast computer for cheaper? always worked for me...
 
Guess I'm going to be toughing it out with my Q9550 for longer than I thought if this news turns out to be true.
 
all you fair weather fans are not invited back..shoo shoo! :p


p.s. I highly doubt this will be the case when the chips see the light of day, or they'll be mobo's that can get around the issue. Do you realize what this would do to the enthusiast Intel mobo market? It would literally kill it.

Not sure how this plays out for Nvidia either if true...

That is basically my hope that if Intel is really serious about this crap, that they accidently leave a backdoor open that the motherboard makers can exploit. However, it doesn't sound like they will be able to do much if you lock down bus speeds as that was the only way to overclock a cpu with a locked clock multiplier.

AMD really needs to get their game on and kick Intel in the balls like they did when the K7's first came out.
 
Back
Top