Intel Core 2 Duo vs AMD 4400+ X2

DarkCyber

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
May 14, 2003
Messages
1,273
Ok, I have been running an AMD 4400+ X2 for a couple of years now and it is seeming a little slow to me now. I just ordered a refurb Dell Inspiron 530, for my office, that has an Intel Core 2 Duo E64020 (4MB L2 Cache, 2.13 ghz, 1066 FSB) processor in it. I thought about swapping it out with my personal pc at home, if the Intel is faster.

My AMD X2 system and the Intel Core Duo both have 2 gigs of memory. My AMD system is running an BFG 7800 GTX 256 meg PCI-e video card and the Intel system is running a Nvidia 8300 GS 128 meg PCI-e video card.

Now to my question...is the Intel Core 2 Duo faster than my AMD 4400+ X2 to justify replacing my 4400+ with the Core 2. I have looked over some reviews and comparisons and they show the Core 2 to be faster, but just trying to see in the real world if it is fast enough to justify the headache of swapping them out.

Thanks for any input.
 
My AMD system is running an BFG 7800 GTX 256 meg PCI-e video card and the Intel system is running a Nvidia 8300 GS 128 meg PCI-e video card.

short answer is NO

if your gaming, you will notice a big drop in performance, if encoding a big increase and a 10-20% increase for most other tasks.

or if you can swap the video cards over the intel system will beat it in almost everything.

if i were you id just do a fresh install of your os and wait till phenom.
 
Yeah, mix an match to get the best of both systems. Keep the 7000 series card, use the Core 2 Duo, and if the AMD system you've got is AM2, put all the RAM in the primary system. Then sell the A64 X2 parts to some poor fool in the FS/FT forum that still thinks AMD is winning this war. :p

That chart is such a freakin joke, it is unreal...

Actually, it's not that big of a joke. PCMark is a benchmark Intel has always done well in, thanks to better multithreading back int he Hyperthreading days. Still, PCMark is a joke of a benchmark; looking at a more relevant benchmark (1080p AVC encoding) put things in slightly better perspective:

http://www23.tomshardware.com/cpu_2007.html?modelx=33&model1=916&model2=878&chart=431
 
Actually, it's not that big of a joke. PCMark is a benchmark Intel has always done well in, thanks to better multithreading back int he Hyperthreading days. Still, PCMark is a joke of a benchmark; looking at a more relevant benchmark (1080p AVC encoding) put things in slightly better perspective:

In this AVC encoding, Q6600 really shines out beating all AMD chips by 2x margin.
 
In this AVC encoding, Q6600 really shines out beating all AMD chips by 2x margin.

Because AVC encoding is a highly multithreaded application that chews up every core you throw at it. Notice how the "worst" quad-core did better than the "best" dual core? Look past the quads and only at the duals to get an idea of Core 2 versus X2 performance.
 
Yes, I can take the BFG 7800 GTX and put it into the Intel Core 2 pc. So, that would be the best match up of everything?

My AMD 4400+ X2 is the 939 cpu.

Thanks for the link...wow, looks like a big difference.
 
Back
Top