Intel, AMD? Halp!

I'm beginning to wonder as well if I've dismissed P55 out of hand, especially now with the NF200 PCIe bridge making x16/x16 a reality.

My biggest grip with X58 is the obviously the cost. Yeah, the i7 920 D0 is great but it's overkill for my needs. X58 boards sporting the features I require are $50-$100+ more than similar AMD/P55 options. AMD mobos are affordable but lack dual Xfire/SLI support (or any form of decent SLI support, for that matter). I could care less that the X4 965 is neck and neck with the Q9550 E0 I recently sold. The price is right and I'm looking for a better GPU platform, not faster number crunching and/or video encoding.

P55 appears to be the perfect fit: Capable of supporting multiple high end GPUs with NF200, inexpensive mainstream CPU options like the i5 750 (a step up from my Q9550), dual Xfire and SLI support. It appears to be the ideal compromise between AM3 and X58. I'd likely save a similar amount going with P55 as opposed to AM3 and I'd see more performance (not to mention several options I consider crucial).

Of course, the issue with socket 1156: Is it already EOL? I sold my 775 setup for that very reason. I easily could have purchased a cheap 775 board with the ability to accommodate future GPUs, but instead I chose to move to something with upgrade potential. No one seems to know what's in store for 1156 and that makes me nervous. If it's a dead end socket, do I really want to invest ...?

EDIT: Meh. Cost wise, NF200-capable P55 boards are just as expensive as X58 (often moreso). I'd still save $100 going with i5, though. Depending on the cost of the motherboard, I might be less than $80 shy of an X58 rig. At that point I'd be mental not to take the step up.
 
Last edited:
I'm beginning to wonder as well if I've dismissed P55 out of hand, especially now with the NF200 PCIe bridge making x16/x16 a reality.

My biggest grip with X58 is the obviously the cost. Yeah, the i7 920 D0 is great but it's overkill for my needs. X58 boards sporting the features I require are $50-$100+ more than similar AMD/P55 options. AMD mobos are affordable but lack dual Xfire/SLI support (or any form of decent SLI support, for that matter). I could care less that the X4 965 is neck and neck with the Q9550 E0 I recently sold. The price is right and I'm looking for a better GPU platform, not faster number crunching and/or video encoding.

P55 appears to be the perfect fit: Capable of supporting multiple high end GPUs with NF200, inexpensive mainstream CPU options like the i5 750 (a step up from my Q9550), dual Xfire and SLI support. It appears to be the ideal compromise between AM3 and X58. I'd likely save a similar amount going with P55 as opposed to AM3 and I'd see more performance (not to mention several options I consider crucial).

Of course, the issue with socket 1156: Is it already EOL? I sold my 775 setup for that very reason. I easily could have purchased a cheap 775 board with the ability to accommodate future GPUs, but instead I chose to move to something with upgrade potential. No one seems to know what's in store for 1156 and that makes me nervous. If it's a dead end socket, do I really want to invest ...?

EDIT: Meh. Cost wise, NF200-capable P55 boards are just as expensive as X58 (often moreso). I'd still save $100 going with i5, though. Depending on the cost of the motherboard, I might be less than $80 shy of an X58 rig. At that point I'd be mental not to take the step up.



Hey Deeky, if I you were you and looking for a new socket I would go straight for 1336, it would be silly for you to go from a q9550 to i5 as it is really a small upgrade (depending on what it's used for) for a Hundred dollars less you are getting someone that will hold you over for a long time.


edit: I7 with HT will come in handy for any design stuff that will be hard on the CPU, it's a no brainer!
 
Hey Deeky, if I you were you and looking for a new socket I would go straight for 1336, it would be silly for you to go from a q9550 to i5 as it is really a small upgrade (depending on what it's used for) for a Hundred dollars less you are getting someone that will hold you over for a long time.


edit: I7 with HT will come in handy for any design stuff that will be hard on the CPU, it's a no brainer!

You speak the truth. I'd thought i5 was a viable option until I priced out some NF200 boards. I could easily snap up a capable X58 mobo for less, and for the same price I'd get something with every ridiculous feature under the sun (including some I'll likely never use). Add to that reports of "latency" and the blistering temps NF200 introduces ... it really is a no brainer.

Not sure how long I'll be able to hold out waiting for info. If I find a decent deal on an 920 I'll probably jump all over it. Bad Company 2 is kicking the stink out of my value ram and stock e6600; the 285 GTX can't save it.
 
To throw more stir the MCP99 is supposed to hit in march but digitimes is saying that nvidia may push GF100 back to april. Not sure what the impact is going to be but it was mentioned here:
http://www.alacrastore.com/research...Corporation_Earnings_Conference_Call-T2509700
"Results
1 instance of 'mcp99' was found in this document.
Page 12

* ... that mean you are going to come out with an MCP##, and what would that product look like if it's...
"

which is an ion chipset that supports i7 chips. Only nvidia is being really hushed up about it for some reason.
 
Damn. If even half of the rumors are true, March is goan be crazy.

Well. To be honest, I think my heart belongs to Intel, at least for another tick tock. I've come to that conclusion twice now. It may be time to stop waffling.

AMD is great - the 790FX is a solid chipset - but no SLI support and I'm holding my breath for Fermi. The 890 chipset is too far off to serious contemplate ... April? May? June? No one seems to know. Maybe it'll offer Xfire/SLI support; no one can confirm.

I'd only consider P55 with the NF200 PCIe bridge as part of the equation ... but those mobos cost just as much as a decent X58 board. Sure, I'd save maybe $100 going with i5 750 over an i7 920 D0, but that's about the extent of it. If I can find a halfway decent deal on a used 920 (or the Canadian equivalent of the Micro Center fire sale) that margin will be cut to almost nothing.

X58 offers everything I want and even some stuff I could do without (but is nice to have). It's a little pricey, but not beyond reason when I sit down and really crunch the numbers, especially when I factor in the peace of mind I'll enjoy knowing I'm covered. ATI. Nvidia. Tons of room to grow. CPU upgrade potential (Sandy Bridge in Q1 2011 won't instantly obliterate 1366, I'm sure it'll be a slow death akin to 775). Seems like the way to go.
 
- The money I'd save can go towards a 5850 or 5870 (or maybe 2 if BC is still such a beast after the official release)

You've got nothing to worry about. My i7 at 2.8 GHz with a stock GTS 250 plays BC2 at 1080p on all high settings with 16x AF and 4x MSAA, combined with supersampling transparency AA. A 5850 or probably even a 5770 would run it at 8x MSAA I'm sure.
 
Welp, I've decided to go with X58. I just finished posting my colorful WTB thread in the FS/T forum, hoping to score a used i7 920 D0 and some DDR3 on the cheap. I figure if I manage to save some coin on second hand memory/CPU, I can stand spending a little more on the mobo and thus justify the juicy Asus P6X58D Premium. :D

I suppose I could wait on i7 930 news, but I doubt the arrival of the new CPU will make much of a difference in terms of pricing. Maybe we'll see new 920s selling for $270 CDN instead of $320. I could be wrong, but such is life. I'm covered when it comes to Fermi. Crossfire, SLI, it's all good.

Thanks to everyone who contributed! Your input was a big help.

... and good luck to Roman79. It's not an easy decision. :p
 
eddieck: That's good to know, thanks.

Congrats on your decision Deeky! I'm jealous.

I'm going away on business next week, but when I get back something is getting purchased! Right after I decide on a case. haha
 
I'm beginning to wonder as well if I've dismissed P55 out of hand, especially now with the NF200 PCIe bridge making x16/x16 a reality.

My biggest grip with X58 is the obviously the cost. Yeah, the i7 920 D0 is great but it's overkill for my needs. X58 boards sporting the features I require are $50-$100+ more than similar AMD/P55 options. AMD mobos are affordable but lack dual Xfire/SLI support (or any form of decent SLI support, for that matter). I could care less that the X4 965 is neck and neck with the Q9550 E0 I recently sold. The price is right and I'm looking for a better GPU platform, not faster number crunching and/or video encoding.

P55 appears to be the perfect fit: Capable of supporting multiple high end GPUs with NF200, inexpensive mainstream CPU options like the i5 750 (a step up from my Q9550), dual Xfire and SLI support. It appears to be the ideal compromise between AM3 and X58. I'd likely save a similar amount going with P55 as opposed to AM3 and I'd see more performance (not to mention several options I consider crucial).

Of course, the issue with socket 1156: Is it already EOL? I sold my 775 setup for that very reason. I easily could have purchased a cheap 775 board with the ability to accommodate future GPUs, but instead I chose to move to something with upgrade potential. No one seems to know what's in store for 1156 and that makes me nervous. If it's a dead end socket, do I really want to invest ...?

EDIT: Meh. Cost wise, NF200-capable P55 boards are just as expensive as X58 (often moreso). I'd still save $100 going with i5, though. Depending on the cost of the motherboard, I might be less than $80 shy of an X58 rig. At that point I'd be mental not to take the step up.

I don't think NF200 is actually terribly useful or honest compared to how it has been marketted. Yes, it will allow you to go into a system info utility and see two cards connected at "16x", but I don't think there are pretty much any circumstances in which you will be able to use that bandwidth - because it doesn't exist in the CPU-NF200 link. Charitable people (like those who depend on review copies for their livelihoods) will assert that it allows the cards to "talk to each other" at 16x, but I havn't seen a performance test that confirms this.

I doubt you will be able to find a difference between using two x8 links in x16 sockets (hey, perhaps making this type of switching easier is what manufacturers were actually shooting for), and using two "16x" nf200 links in two 16x sockets.
 
I don't think NF200 is actually terribly useful or honest compared to how it has been marketed ...

I doubt you will be able to find a difference between using two x8 links in x16 sockets (hey, perhaps making this type of switching easier is what manufacturers were actually shooting for), and using two "16x" nf200 links in two 16x sockets.
I would agree. NF200 was too big of a question mark to hinge my entire purchase decision on. That, and once I started considering NF200 boards with the layout and features I require, I wasn't saving any serious money compared to X58.
 
Back
Top