I'm beginning to wonder as well if I've dismissed P55 out of hand, especially now with the NF200 PCIe bridge making x16/x16 a reality.
My biggest grip with X58 is the obviously the cost. Yeah, the i7 920 D0 is great but it's overkill for my needs. X58 boards sporting the features I require are $50-$100+ more than similar AMD/P55 options. AMD mobos are affordable but lack dual Xfire/SLI support (or any form of decent SLI support, for that matter). I could care less that the X4 965 is neck and neck with the Q9550 E0 I recently sold. The price is right and I'm looking for a better GPU platform, not faster number crunching and/or video encoding.
P55 appears to be the perfect fit: Capable of supporting multiple high end GPUs with NF200, inexpensive mainstream CPU options like the i5 750 (a step up from my Q9550), dual Xfire and SLI support. It appears to be the ideal compromise between AM3 and X58. I'd likely save a similar amount going with P55 as opposed to AM3 and I'd see more performance (not to mention several options I consider crucial).
Of course, the issue with socket 1156: Is it already EOL? I sold my 775 setup for that very reason. I easily could have purchased a cheap 775 board with the ability to accommodate future GPUs, but instead I chose to move to something with upgrade potential. No one seems to know what's in store for 1156 and that makes me nervous. If it's a dead end socket, do I really want to invest ...?
EDIT: Meh. Cost wise, NF200-capable P55 boards are just as expensive as X58 (often moreso). I'd still save $100 going with i5, though. Depending on the cost of the motherboard, I might be less than $80 shy of an X58 rig. At that point I'd be mental not to take the step up.
My biggest grip with X58 is the obviously the cost. Yeah, the i7 920 D0 is great but it's overkill for my needs. X58 boards sporting the features I require are $50-$100+ more than similar AMD/P55 options. AMD mobos are affordable but lack dual Xfire/SLI support (or any form of decent SLI support, for that matter). I could care less that the X4 965 is neck and neck with the Q9550 E0 I recently sold. The price is right and I'm looking for a better GPU platform, not faster number crunching and/or video encoding.
P55 appears to be the perfect fit: Capable of supporting multiple high end GPUs with NF200, inexpensive mainstream CPU options like the i5 750 (a step up from my Q9550), dual Xfire and SLI support. It appears to be the ideal compromise between AM3 and X58. I'd likely save a similar amount going with P55 as opposed to AM3 and I'd see more performance (not to mention several options I consider crucial).
Of course, the issue with socket 1156: Is it already EOL? I sold my 775 setup for that very reason. I easily could have purchased a cheap 775 board with the ability to accommodate future GPUs, but instead I chose to move to something with upgrade potential. No one seems to know what's in store for 1156 and that makes me nervous. If it's a dead end socket, do I really want to invest ...?
EDIT: Meh. Cost wise, NF200-capable P55 boards are just as expensive as X58 (often moreso). I'd still save $100 going with i5, though. Depending on the cost of the motherboard, I might be less than $80 shy of an X58 rig. At that point I'd be mental not to take the step up.
Last edited: