Intel, AMD? Halp!

Deeky

Gawd
Joined
Feb 7, 2008
Messages
982
So I'm leaving socket 775 for greener pastures. I find myself in the market for a new motherboard, CPU and memory. The question is, which platform?

I've assumed up 'til this point that it would be Intel, but now I'm beginning to wonder ...am I passing up an amazing price/performance opportunity by ignoring AMD?

The machine will be used for gaming moreso than anything. I'll have at least two GPUs; possibly a third for PPU but that's all dependent on whether Batman proves to be the start of something big for PhysX.

Given the intended usage, would I be retarded not to go with Intel X58? I'm WAY out of the loop when it comes to the AMD versus Intel debate - I haven't been a part of it for some time, since Intel clowned AMD with the release of C2D, back when Intel was the obvious choice. I'm not really sure what AMD offers these days, to be honest.

Any tips or suggestions? I'm simply looking for the best bang for buck to support an SLI/Xfire system. Thanks in advance!
 
What are you upgrading from? what's your budget? What are you expecting?

I went AMD because I got a cpu/mobo/ram/vga for the price that a cpu and mobo would have cost me with intel. Basically Intel was out of my budget range.

If you've got money to burn then buy the best you can afford. For me it was either quad core intel and integrated graphics, or quad core AMD and a 5770. I went with AMD :)
 
I can stomach spending an extra $200 if it'll net me a noticeable performance increase.

I'm upgrading from a Q9550, which I'm learning is fairly on par with what AMD offers at the moment, so that's a little too parallel for my liking (not that i5/i7 will do me much better). The whole reason for the upgrade is to accommodate SLI/Xfire, something my P35 board could not do. I almost upgraded within 775 but decided it would be worth it to move to a different, upgradeable socket assuming I could part out my rig (which I've since done). With that income, plus what I would have spent moving to an dual GPU capable 775 mobo, I've pocketed about $450 USD. I'll glady toss another $100-$200 on top of that if it means big gains.
 
Intel is still a step ahead of AMD when it comes to all around CPU performance, but AMD still has alot to offer especially when you mention "bang for buck".

AMD's high end CPU as of right now is the Phenom II X4 965. As far as gaming goes it is about on par with the I5 750. AMD has nothing to offer when compared with the I7 lineup but when you consider price/performance, AMD is a no-brainer.

When I built my new system I looked at both and ended up going AMD because of my budget. It would've been nice to have an Intel system but i'm wholly satisfied with my new rig. Now if I could just come up with the money to upgrade my 9800gt and 19" monitor.:mad:
 
Answer me these questions [Strike=Option]three[/s] ten.

Will do!

1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc

Gaming is a big factor, requiring the majority of horsepower ... with a side order of Photoshop/In Design and browsing/word processing.

2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
I'd say about $600 USD. Though cheaper is better, of course! If I could pull it together for $600 including taxes and shipping I'd be happy.

3) Where do you live?
Canada. BC (west).

4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. Please be very specific.
Motherboard, CPU and RAM. Everything else is being recycled from my previous build.

5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? Please be especially specific about the power supply. List make and model.

Corsair HX850w, BFG 285 GTX OC, CM Storm Sniper Black Ed. (case), 160gb Intel G2 SSD, DVD-RW, fan controller, etc.

6) Will you be overclocking?
Damn straight.

7) What size monitor do you have and/or plan to have?

Currently on 24" HP LP2475w. I am considering downgrading to 22" and going three wide for Eyefinity or Nvidia Surround, however.

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
ASAP. Having parted out my rig I'm running gimped with old components until I pull together the new build.

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? etc.
SLI/Xfire is a must, that's the entire point of the upgrade! Interested in eSATA, USB3, SATA 6.0. Need room for a PCIe x1 sound card alongside at least two GPUs. Would like an additional x4 or x8 slot for potential PPU upgrade down the road.

10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license? If yes, what OS? 32bit or 64bit?
Yes. Windows 7 Professional 64-bit.
 
There's no reason to switch to an AMD setup from an LGA775 rig, since you won't be getting any better performance than you would from just popping in a Q9550. Within your budget, you could put together a very nice LGA1156 setup, and possibly even an LGA1366 rig.
 
There's no reason to switch to an AMD setup from an LGA775 rig, since you won't be getting any better performance than you would from just popping in a Q9550. Within your budget, you could put together a very nice LGA1156 setup, and possibly even an LGA1366 rig.

OP said they are looking to upgrade from a q9550. Personally, I think thats a waste of money. Q9550 is still a great cpu, won't notice much from an upgrade.
 
OP said they are looking to upgrade from a q9550. Personally, I think thats a waste of money. Q9550 is still a great cpu, won't notice much from an upgrade.
I missed that; it wasn't in his first post. Definitely not worth going AMD. I think the most significant upgrade would be to an i7 920 and X58 rig.
 
Okay. So you sold your core 2 quad CPU, mobo, & RAM. Unfortunately, the preferable advice would have been to keep them, and upgrade the GPU, monitors, & perhaps RAM. Crossfire/SLI mobos are not really overly necessary at this time, with the existence of powerful 5870 and 5970 GPUs, and the tendency of game developers to shoot for console ports. HOWEVER, you're not looking to upgrade your GPU or monitors at this time, you just want a new reasonably powerful mobo/RAM/CPU combo. Have I got that?

Next we need to know how much you have planned to spend on GPU/monitors, and when.
 
Unfortunately, from the reviews I'm reading and the prices I'm seeing, going with a second GTX285 probably won't equal spending the money on AMD cards after parting out your card. Have you thought about going with a 5970 and using a double-slot mobo?
 
Last edited:
OP said they are looking to upgrade from a q9550. Personally, I think thats a waste of money. Q9550 is still a great cpu, won't notice much from an upgrade.

That was my thought initially. I was prepared to upgrade to a new 775 mobo in order to accommodate an SLI or Xfire setup. Would have cost me at least $130 USD to get a decent one with x16/x16 lanes (5870 already shows a 4% bottleneck on 2.0 x8, who knows what Fermi and the ATI refreshes will look like? not to mention new tech a year or two down the road?) But then I started thinking, I can part out my current system, bring in maybe $300 USD while my components are still worth something, toss that $130 on top and have a respectable $430+ to move to a socket that's not EOL. Upgrading to a platform with upgrade potential is worth the extra $150-$200 in my opinion. I'm not expecting any revelations comparing the Q9550 to the i7 920 (or whatever), but at least I won't be sinking money into a dead socket.

To address Squalish, I'm currently laying the ground work for a move to SLI Fermi to support Nvidia Surround (multi-monitor) - something you need SLI to accomplish. True, I can go with a 5970 (or the eventual refresh) and bust out some Eyefinity, but if Fermi does what it's supposed to and takes back the crown, that's where I'll sink my money. I've remapped this upgrade about a half dozen times, believe me.

You are correct, though. All I require at this time is a mobo, CPU and RAM. I want SLI capability to accommodate a possible move to Nvidia Surround. However, I would prefer that the board be capable of both SLI and Crossfire in the event that Fermi resembles the maiden voyage of the Hindenburg, GPU-style.

EDIT: tl;dr? Basically, I was GOING to spend approx. $130 on a new 775 mobo. Instead, I parted out my rig, made about $300 USD. Now, the $130 I'd earmarked for the 775 SLI/Xfire board buys some DDR3, the $300 I made from resale gets me a new 1366 (?) mobo and I'm left buying a CPU with anything left over plus additional funds. In my view, the additional investment is worth it to move to a platform with legs.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, from the reviews I'm reading and the prices I'm seeing, going with a second GTX285 probably won't equal spending the money on AMD cards after parting out your card. Have you thought about going with a 5970 and using a double-slot mobo?

Should be noted I will likely be parting out my 285 once Fermi is settled in and ATI has had time to respond (or at least threaten a response). I suspect DX11 will catch on much faster than DX10. My fingers are crossed for AvP.

EDIT: I will be spending a good chunk of change on new GPUs and possibly monitors down the road, though not for at least 4 months I would estimate. I intend to let the dust settle on the March release and see what comes. I'm simply preparing for that eventuality. For now, the 285 is more than enough grunt to carry me on a single display running 1920x1200. Might end up selling the HP 24" as well, but that has yet to be determined.
 
Last edited:
In games there wont be a huge difference between an AMD or Intel CPU....the difference will mainly come from your GFX......

If you go intel you will have: break neck speed, and good OC potential, and as long as you use an intel chipset you will have xfire and sli.

if you go AMD yuo will have: an almost guranteed upgrade path to the next generation of AMD CPU, excelent overclocking(assuming you get the 965 C3 stepping), but are limited to either xfire or SLI, not both(atleast to my knowledge the AMD chipset does not support SLI setups)


so judging by your criteria, an intel build is the only real selection due to it supporting both GFX makers
 
Hmm. Wasn't aware that AMD was Xfire only. Thanks for that, obviously a big push towards Intel.

Also, though I realize PCIe 2.0 x8/x8 offers enough bandwidth to accommodate a pair of 5870s in Xfire with minimal performance loss, I'm of the opinion that x16/x16 is about to come into it's own.

... I guess that kind of answers my own question:

No AMD. It's too parallel and doesn't support both Xfire and SLI. I consider dual-support an important feature, both short and long term.

No P55. It only supports PCIe 2.0 x8 in multi-card configurations. Again, x16/x16 is something I consider a key feature for maintaining upgrade-ability in the months and years to come. I've been rockin' the same P35 motherboard since they released in mid-2007. I expect longevity from my next platform. I'd probably still be with the P35 if not for the single PCIe x16 slot and no SLI support. :D Hoping I can squeeze at least 3 years out of my next build. Assuming I'll be able to ride it out until full x16 lanes are no longer sufficient (and that'll be quite some time, I suspect).
 
Last edited:
AMD ISNT xfire only and in order to go X58 you will need more than what you have 1156 seems moreso in your price range. i.e. mid range motherboard (msi, biostar, asrock,ecs etc) i5 750, though the i7 860 is much better, some nice dual channel lower voltage ddr3 maybe value series, and a lower range hd5770 or 4870 of you can find them. unless all you need is cpu, mobo, ram
 
unless all you need is cpu, mobo, ram

This. :p

So AMD supports SLI? I assumed they did. Do they support both on the same board? (EDIT: Google would indicate "no"). I'm really out of touch when it comes to AMD products. Not because of any bias, simply because I haven't been shopping for a mobo in 2 1/2 years ...
 
Last edited:
If anyone has mobo/CPU/RAM recommendations within my budget, I'd be glad to hear them. There's a ton of choice and I'm out of the loop with regard to the newest tech; I'd really appreciate a place to start!
 
sorry let me clarify......to use an AMD chipset(790 FX/785G/etc for NB, 750 SB) you cannot have SLI

if you wish to use the 790a chipset, released by Nvidea you can use SLI......

if you are willing to go Xfire only route(dont think you are) i would recommend the Crosshair III with a 965 and go to town OCing it, and throwin in 8 Gig of memory(should still be under your budget)....

if not, get a X58 board, and a 920 and go to town the intel route
 
Sorry, I misread your previous post. Of course AMD supports SLI. Ignoring that particular portion of their consumer base would be suicide.

If I had to choose a dedicated SLI or Xfire board, I'd probably err on the side of SLI. I'm no fanboy but I'm definitely interested in what they're doing with their Fermi architecture. That said, I'd much rather have support for both ..... though I'd definitely consider it long and hard if choosing one over the other saved me a butt load of cash.

Nvidia chipsets make me nervous, though. I've always thought Nvidia should stick to making GPUs. Have they gotten any better with the 790a?
 
Last edited:
Nvidia chipsets make me nervous, though. I've always thought Nvidia should stick to making GPUs. Have they gotten any better with the 790a?

coudn't agree more, since nVidia chipsets for AMD system are old, it's better for you to either go

(.) AMD with AMD chipset, that means Crossfire only, since you go AMD you will have money to spare for upgrading to a 5970, considering you sell previous system...

(.) Intel with Intel chipset, that means you can get SLI and Crossfire both, I don't know if you will have enough money to get a new 285, but you will be able to.
 
Good suggestion. Looks like I'm going with Intel again. If AMD manufactured a board offering both SLI and Xfire, I'd have given it serious consideration. Even if the flagship AMD processor is more or less parallel to the Q9550, for me it's not about upgrading the CPU, it's about additional features on the mobo and guaranteed upgrade potential in the future, something I don't get sinking more money into 775. If I could part out my system and spend maybe $100 extra to get the top shelf AMD processor on an SLI/Xfire capable mobo, I'd probably do it.

But I can't. So I won't. :p

Upgrading the GPU will happen, but not right away. I'll definitely wait for Fermi to settle in, wait and see what ATI has in store to level the playing field. Four, five months down the road (once I've built up another budget). I'll likely sell the 285, though finding a cheap one on [H] FS/T (Nvidia Surround apparently works on G200 cards as well, or at least it will) isn't out of the question, nor is a 5970 (or the refresh) ... it'll be nice to have options.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, I misread your previous post. Of course AMD supports SLI. Ignoring that particular portion of their consumer base would be suicide.

If I had to choose a dedicated SLI or Xfire board, I'd probably err on the side of SLI. I'm no fanboy but I'm definitely interested in what they're doing with their Fermi architecture. That said, I'd much rather have support for both ..... though I'd definitely consider it long and hard if choosing one over the other saved me a butt load of cash.

Nvidia chipsets make me nervous, though. I've always thought Nvidia should stick to making GPUs. Have they gotten any better with the 790a?

to answer your question, no the 790a chipset(by Nvidea) is no where near as good as the 790FX(by AMD)....especially in OC potential...


and i agree, AMD needs to get chipsets that support both Xfire and SLI(lets hope the 890's do...they are just around the corner)
 
and i agree, AMD needs to get chipsets that support both Xfire and SLI(lets hope the 890's do...they are just around the corner)

How long, approximately? I may wait for the i7 930 to drop at the end of February, if only to drive down the price of the 920 D0 (prolly why Micro Center is selling them at a loss). If the new AMD platform is due to release in the same time frame, I'd have no problem playing the wait and see game. It sucks ... I'll have to play AvP on an e6600 for a few weeks ... but I'll suffer the indignity if it means buying with confidence. :D
 
Don't remember when. Pretty sure it is q1 of this year.....if you do a google search for 890 chipset you should find plenty of Info. I'm on my iPhone right now so I can't easily look it up
 
I'm seeing everything from March to June 2010. No one seems to have an accurate read on when the chipset will release. Meh. I can stand waiting a month, but I have no intention of spending two or more wallowing in e6600 land.

Thanks!
 
If you can hit a Microcenter near you get an i7 920 for $199, a decent board can be had for $250 (ASUS P6T comes to mind, but it may not have the expansion slot config you are looking for), and a decent set of DDR3 for right around $150. That would give you a nice base for a modern platform with lots of overclocking potential for the future.
 
If you can hit a Microcenter near you ...

Man, I'd love to! No such love in Canada, though. The cheapest 920 I can find online is $300. :( I'll wait it out for a few weeks, see if a combo deal on NCIX catches my eye. Hoping the imminent arrival of the 930 causes retailers to move their 920s with extreme prejudice.
 
Last edited:
Unless I get lucky and stumble across a smokin' deal over the next 30 days, I'll likely end up spending over $700 CDN on this particular bump. If retailers in Canada start offering 920 D0s at a reduced rate, I might save $100.

Asus P6X58D.
Mushkin Enhanced Blackline 1600.
i7 920 D0.

Thoughts on the selection?

The mobo, all the goodness of the P6T w/ USB3, SATA 6.0 and 32nm CPU support. Sexah. Almost the perfect layout for my needs (no dual slot GPU in the bottom x16), but close enough considering I'm 99% sure I'll never want/need a third card; even if I did I'd be running x16/x8/x8 (I prefer the x16/x16/x1 config, ideal for two high end GPUs and my PCI x1 sound card). Very positive review at Bjorn3D. I could save $60 going with a lesser variant of the P6T lineup, but I'm not one to scrimp when it comes to my mainboards. I want something that will carry me for quite some time.

I've always been a Mushkin fan. This stuff is reasonably priced and (judging from the reviews) appears to be a solid performer. Plus it's nice to look at. Never a bad thing.

The CPU is no surprise. I may end up with the i7 930 depending how that goes.

Regardless, I'll likely wait out the month, see if I can't wrangle a good combo deal or snipe something on eBay. I'll keep my eye on [H] FS/T. Time will tell! $600 USD shipped is starting to look like a pipe dream, but maybe I'll get lucky and keep it close. :D
 
Good suggestion. Looks like I'm going with Intel again. If AMD manufactured a board offering both SLI and Xfire, I'd have given it serious consideration. Even if the flagship AMD processor is more or less parallel to the Q9550, for me it's not about upgrading the CPU, it's about additional features on the mobo and guaranteed upgrade potential in the future, something I don't get sinking more money into 775. If I could part out my system and spend maybe $100 extra to get the top shelf AMD processor on an SLI/Xfire capable mobo, I'd probably do it.

Yep, I don't get it.
I read that SLI doesn't require special hardware support, so this is either AMD's arrogance or nVidia's stupidity. Someone even able to create a tweak to enable SLI on non SLI enabled chipset, although not yet stable.

If Fermi is a decent card, and this goes on to 890 series chipset, I would say Intel is the best choice for guaranteed upgrade potential.
 
Seems like AMD is always playing catch up to Intel, so if you're looking for longevity out of your upgrade, intel with eye's to Fermi seems like the way to go. You already mentioned that you are willing to pay a little more for the built in future proofing. On a side note, have you considered getting used equip? You could probably get the most bang for your buck with used asus p6t and an i7 920. With the money you saved, might even look into watercooling to stabilize your overclock on the 920! haha, it never ends!
 
So I'm still banging away at this. Though I'd thought the decision was clear cut considering my requirements (INTEL!) ... I'm no longer so certain.

After several hours of skimming articles and lurking threads, I've come up with two possible builds (prices listed in CDN dollars):

INTEL
Asus P6X58D Premium $300
i7 920/930 $300
Triple channel DDR3 kit $180-$200

OR

AMD
Gigabyte 790FXTA-UD5 $200
Phenom II X4 Black Edition 965 $200
Dual channel DDR3 kit $140

Honestly, the CPU choices are a foregone conclusion. The ram could be anything at this point. Brand name notwithstanding (likely Mushkin) it depends whether I want a dual or triple channel kit. I suppose I could ignore triple channel altogether to cut costs on the Intel build.

Regardless, the motherboards are where the action is.

The Intel build is a safe bet (it provides anything and everything), though it costs at least $240 CDN (+shipping and taxes) more than the AMD config. I get much better CPU performance and a few bells and whistles on the mobo (triple channel, etc) I otherwise do not get with AMD. Provides full x16/x16 plus a couple x1 slots (though I could run x16/x8/x8). Good layout, but not perfect. SATA 6.0, USB3, "future proof" in that regard. Provides BOTH SLI and Xfire.

So going with AMD saves my $200+ CDN and nets me CPU performance similar (slightly better?) to the Q9550 and the perfect board layout for my needs. Unless I've misread the spec sheets, I get full x16/x16 (??) performance plus an additional x8 slot and, though oddly placed, the PCIe x1 slot I require for my Auzentech sound card (should I be worried that the card would end up buried in the NB heatsink?). Also, SATA 6.0, USB3, all the goods. Crossfire only. I don't mind trading across with regard to the CPU (Q9550 to X4 965). I sold the Q9550 for $184 CDN so it wouldn't be that bad a deal (though taxes and shipping widen the gap). This upgrade is less about CPU horsepower and more about bettering my GPU setup and providing new transfer tech. If it's CPU I want, I'll wait for Sandy Bridge. EDIT: Damn, it's hard to determine, but I think this board runs x16/x8/x8 if all the slots are populated. x16/x16/x8 obviously isn't feasible.

In choosing AMD, I'd be stuck with Crossfire. If I had to choose one glaring concern with the build, that would be it. I love what AMD is doing with their 5xxx series, I wish there were more concrete info on Fermi. I can't make an informed decision! ... I may end up simply waiting until March to make the leap, see what Fermi brings. Which sucks, as I'm stuck running an e6600 and 2gb of 667 value ram until then ... but I suppose that's my own fault. Waiting one month to part out my system wouldn't have made that big a difference. :p

Just thinking out loud. Feel free to add your thoughts, suggestions, corrections! Cheers.
 
Last edited:
Wow, very nice choice of boards,
I thought there's a third option in LGA 1156, sadly I see they can only do x8 x8 on two GPU option.
If motherboard features really matters to you, perhaps waiting for AMD's new 890FX boards is more significant than Fermi, it's released around April.

If you really need to chose now, I'd go with personal brand preference (AMD or Intel), cause either setup can last a couple of years and may be more with good upgrade path.
 
Thanks! I'm also considering the GA-X58A-UD3R. It's a good board, though it lacks some features and has an unfortunate PCIe arrangement (too close together). Still, it's $219 CDN. The Gigabyte X58A-UD5 is also shortlisted, though it's the same price as the P6X58D and given the choice, I'd probably side with the Asus due to the layout.

P55 crossed my radar, but the x8/x8 isn't ideal. Also, the CPU wouldn't be much cheaper unless I went i5, nor would the board. I'd only save a notable sum of money if I made a number of sacrifices (even then, I might not get the layout I require). All told, I'd rather spend a little more and go 1366 or spend less and build on an AMD platform better suited to my needs.

Before making the decision to go with AMD, I'd have to give serious consideration to the GA-X58-UD3R (the original model with no USB 3.0 or SATA 6). I'd be losing a ton of features, and I'd have to decide between the new transfer technology or combo SLI/Xfire support, but it's $169 CDN (almost half the price of my P6X58D). Naturally, it all depends what I'm ultimately willing to spend.

EDIT: Yeah, I keep hearing April-June for the 890 chipset. Not sure if I can wait THAT long! Just making it through February is gonna be a nightmare. =P
 
Last edited:
Wow I really enjoyed reading this thread, glad I'm not the only one having trouble making that decision :D

Just wanted to mention a couple things that you may find interesting:

- I read a customer review on newegg.ca on one of the Gigabyte X58 boards with USB 3.0 / SATA 3. He seemed rather upset...apparently you can't boot from the SATA 3 controller. You might want to confirm that if you're looking at one of those, but I just thought I'd mention it.

- another option might be an AMD PII 550 (or 555 which should be available soon). Good overclockers even on a cheap board and many people have had luck unlocking the other 2 cores. So basically you have a $100 PII 965 if you're lucky, pair that with a $100 xfire capable board and you're set for a while. If something new comes out in a few months from either side you can always resell and upgrade.

It's not perfect, but it does prevent you from laying down serious cash on a i7 920 platform when a refresh is so close.
 
speaking for the AMD set up there....it is rock solid....only thing i would suggest is doing this mobo if you can spare the extra $20 CAD - http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131392 -- it is more than proven itself, and gives you all you need(yes it is x16 and x16...same for the Gigabyte one linked above....thats a feature of the 790 FX chipset).....


anyhow, if you can hold off, wait until Fermi is released and see what happens, if performance is close to the 58**, then you will have a decision made......you have two nice setups.....btw, the 965(AMD) will perform in games at almost identical levels as Intel chips out there....slightly slower in some, faster in some.....its in video encoding and transcoding where Intel wins the crown by a HUGE margin......
 
Wow I really enjoyed reading this thread, glad I'm not the only one having trouble making that decision :D
:p Glad to have someone else along for the ride. It's a tough call.

Yeah, the guy on Newegg.ca, I saw that too. He was complaining about the X58A-UD5, claiming you couldn't boot from the Marvell controller. He went as far as to accuse them of false advertising. Though it's likely an isolated incident, it's definitely something I'll be investigating before pulling any triggers.

Hmm. The AMD PII 550 is an excellent candidate for a potential budget build. Thanks for bringing it to my attention. My only beef with AMD at the moment is the lack of decent SLI support (their Nvidia boards are a joke). I'm keeping a close eye on the Fermi release; if it does what it claims, I'll be one of the first on the bandwagon ... emphasis on the word "if". :rolleyes:

Which refresh are you referring to? Sandy Bridge in 2011? Or is there something even closer I'm not aware of?

speaking for the AMD set up there....it is rock solid....only thing i would suggest is doing this mobo if you can spare the extra $20 CAD - http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131392 -- it is more than proven itself, and gives you all you need(yes it is x16 and x16...same for the Gigabyte one linked above....thats a feature of the 790 FX chipset).....

The Crosshair is a great board. You can't start a thread discussing the best 790FX mobos without half the participants mentioning that board. High praise. My only niggle is the lack of USB3 and SATA6 (and of course SLI support, but that's 790FX in general), and with my x1 sound card I won't have any room to accommodate an expansion card like the U3S6.

I was wondering about the third x16 slot on the Gigabyte board I listed. If it's populated, I assume the second x16 slot runs at x8 (x16/x8/x8). That would be no problem but I'd be forced to leave that bottom slot empty to maintain max lanes for my GPUs. Since I'd likely be running hacked PhysX with an ATI rig, that's not an option.

Well, I've basically committed to waiting out February. AvP and Bad Co. 2 are gonna suck on an e6600, but that's a sacrifice I'm willing to make if it means I can make a more informed decision. That'll give me the inside scoop on the i7 930 and hopefully some more concrete numbers on Fermi. Time will tell.

EDIT: If the GF100 fails to provide a sizable performance lead over the 5870 (or costs a mint, or runs hotter than the sun, or is louder than a Learjet), I'll likely end up siding with ATI. If that happens, I'll keep my 285 GTX for crazy overkill hacked PhysX. If Fermi does the deed, I'll sell the 285 and stick with green for another few years. No way of knowing at this point, but either outcome will seriously impact my decision between AMD and Intel. The Gigabyte board I've listed is ideal for a three GPU setup (two ATI and the 285 for PhysX; though my second GPU drops to x8, that translates into maybe 4% loss on a 5870 - I can live with that). The Asus board is actually a little overkill for me as I won't technically need a third PCIe x16 slot should I choose to stick with Nvidia, but layout and feature concerns are making the Intel decision difficult at a lower price point. Too many sacrifices to be made.
 
Last edited:
Maybe "refresh" wasn't the right word; I was referring to the i7 930.

Heh funny you should mention BC2, that's pretty much my entire reason for upgrading. I'm playing the beta right now on a laptop (C2D 2.5GHz, 9600M GS). It's playable on low settings, but it's rough.

I'm going to wait 2 weeks then order something. I'm leaning towards AMD atm for the following reasons:

- The money I'd save can go towards a 5850 or 5870 (or maybe 2 if BC is still such a beast after the official release)
- I won't feel too bad if something new and shiny comes out in the next few months, since my AMD setup will be cheap
 
I just finished downloading the beta on Steam, though I won't have time to play until later tonight. Can't wait! I've been a fan of the Battlefield franchise since the good ol' days of defending Wake Island and wing surfing in 1942.

Yeah, I'm gonna give it at least two weeks, likely more. The money I could potentially save is tempting but I'm still leaning toward Intel at this point. Not holding out much hope for the 930. If it manages to drive down the price on the 920 D0 I'll be happy. Hell, I wish there were a cheaper 1366 CPU option. Gaming is my primary concern and the CPU plays a relatively small part in that equation.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top