Instability is driving me crazy. Any suggestions?

Yippee38

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Apr 21, 2000
Messages
3,388
Specs:
A8N-SLI - 1003 BIOS - 6.39 drivers
Zalman passive chipset cooler
Corsair Twinx1024-3200C2 mem
Athlon64 3500+
Zalman 7000 series cooler
(2) BFG 6800GTs - 67.66 drivers
Turtle Beach Santa Cruz - 4193 drivers
IDE DVD-ROM
IDE DVD+-RW
(2) Seagate SATA 160Gb HD
IDE WD 40Gb HD
Antec TruePower 550
(4) 80mm case fans running on "fan only" lead from PSU
Windows XP SP1 fresh install (over and over again)
DX9c

My problem is that this system is not stable. I am testing it using 3dMark03 and 3dMark05. No problems whatsoever in 2d. In 3dMark, I get lockups, application CTDs, and system reboots.

What I've done so far:
Ran memtest for over 15 hours with no errors.
Ran MS memory diagonstics for 2+ hours with no errors
Tried a pair of MSI 6800 vid cards (non-GT, non-Ultra, no power connectors)
Tried a BFG 6600 GT
Tried nvidia video driver version 66.93, 67.66, and 71.80.
Tried nForce chipset drivers version 6.39 and 5.10
Tried BIOS 1002, 1003, 1003.007, and 1004.001
Removed sound card and drivers.

The results I've gotten are:
6600GT ran better than either one of, or both of the 6800s
Pair of 6800s runs about as well as the 6600GT
As I mentioned, no errors on memory tests
Under load, I'm getting the following power reading (multimeter readings)
12v - 11.86v and 11.84v (depending on which ground I use)
5v - 4.97v and 4.99v (depending on which gound I use)
7v - 6.87v
Immediately after crashing in 3dMark05 (CTD), I got the following readings
Video card 1 - 48 degrees C
Video card 2 - 49 degrees C (based upon reading from nVidia driver app)
CPU temp - 45 degrees C
Motherboard temp - 38 degrees C
12v - 11.712v
5v - 4.919v
3.3v - 3.232v
vCore - 1.504v (all read by Asus PC Probe, and suspect)

Does anybody have any suggestions? My original thought was that the 6800s were pulling too much power through the PCI-Express slots and that was causing the instability. I assumed this, since it seems like a power issue to me. Also, since the 6600GT seemed to run more stably than the 6800, I figured that the wimpier card used less power. So I switch to 6800GTs - since they have power connectors on the cards - thinking that would be even better. It isn't. The memory seems to run well. I'm not having temp problems. I've got enough power based on the +/- 5% theory. I'm running out of things to try.

Oh yeah. One more thing. Sometimes when the PC crashes (reboots), after restarting I get a "Widnows error reporting" thingy. Sometimes it will say that there was a problem with the GeForce 6x00 driver. Sometimes after I submit it takes me to a MS page saying that there was a device driver problem, and sometimes it says a video driver problem.

HELP!
 
I forgot to mention that I talked to Asus Tech Support. They said, "Well, you've done everything that we would have recommended, and it looks like none of those things are the problem. We're going to escalate this to our engineers. They will do some testing and get back to you." I'm not holding my breath though.
 
Already did try the 1004.001 BIOS. Didn't help.

FWIW, after a crash (reboot), I got the exact following message:
=======================================================
Computer started after an unexpected shutdown.
Microsoft Windows detected a possible device failure.

The driver for the display device was unable to complete the drawing operation. Please check with teh device manufacturer fro a driver update.

Please tell Microsoft about this problem.
The display driver for NVIDIA GeForce 6800 Series GPU seems to be responsible for the system instability.
========================================================

I've tried uninstalling and re-installing the drivers a bajillion times (using Driver Cleaner Pro every time) and it doesn't help.
 
Damn, that really bites. My A8N-SLI Deluxe has been rock solid so far (knocks on wood).

This is a frustrating problem you're having. I would have tried all the things you already said you did. The only other thing I can think of is RMAing the board, but that seems drastic.

The really curious thing is the (lack of) performance you're getting from your dual 6800's. That's probably a clue, but as to what I'm stumped right now.
 
Makave7i Tha Don said:
do you have a 6 pin connector going to your gpu?

I have 6600 GT's, the only external connector they use is the SLI one. The 6800's require additional power. I do of course have the extra power feed going to the PCI-e slots.
 
Oh the performance is there. I'm getting 18569 in 3dMark03, and 8461 in 3dMark05 (finally got a score after 3 tries).
 
Yeah. I have the 6-pin going to the GPUs. I got them so they'd have the external power. I have the molex, 4-pin power connector going to the motherboard (just about the first PCI-express slot).
 
I know this is a dumb question, but is your CPU overclocked? Is your gfx card overclocked? Have you tried to underclock your CPU/GFX?
 
Yippee38 said:
Oh the performance is there. I'm getting 18569 in 3dMark03, and 8461 in 3dMark05 (finally got a score after 3 tries).


Ah you meant the 6600 was more stable though?
 
Nothing is overclocked. I haven't tried underclocking.

The 6600GT is more stable than the 6800 (non-GTs). I think the 6800 GTs are about as stable as the 6600GTs. Of course, that's a subjective observation. The scores above are for the 6800GTs.
 
I'm just sitting here scratching my head right now, but I haven't given up on you. You've already been so thorough though. I might just keep bugging Asus, perhaps even swap the board for a new one.
 
Despite all rhetoric in reality it is extremely hard to diagnose system instability when it is at the hardware level. The bottom line is you simply need to keep switching parts out until you isolate the exact problem. I'd shoot for the motherboard directly at this point - could be a faulty PCI-E interface. I know that seems like a slim chance but your whole situation is such that whatever is wrong is a rare problem anyway. It can't be the video card clearly, you have tried 3 of them. It must either be a defective CPU or a defective board.
 
try the 71.81 driver maybe that will help if not you definately have a hardware issue...sorry didnt wont to repeat why becuase the previous post covered it
 
Matrices,

I have pretty much come to the same conclusion. This is my second A8N. The first had two bad memory slots. I just hope they'll RMA it.

Oh yeah, I did insulate the motherboard mounts with a little bit of duct tape to make sure that I'm not grounding out anywhere.
 
I forgot to mention that I pulled the motherboard from the case and ran it that way. Same result.
 
Here's something to try. I noticed your power supply is a Antec Truepower 550. Now, that's a damn good PSU, but.....................I've noticed that PCI-Express motherboards do some damn funny things with legacy power supplies hooked up to them. Even though they are supposed to support it.

I work in a tech shop and even some enthusiests that are friends of friends have brought their systems to me because they simply can't find the problem. And in more than a couple cases a ATX 2.0 compliant PSU made all the differences.

If you read more about the differences between ATX 1.x and ATX 2.0 specifications it does make sense for issues to occur using the legacy PSU's on the newer boards.

Not saying that's the problem in your case, but you might want to give it a shot.
 
Sir-Fragalot,

I'm starting to think it may be the PSU. It's within the voltage limits, but only just barely. I think I may fork over the money for a better supply. (Hope I can get rid of this one since the return period is over). Oh yeah, this one is the EPS12v BTW.

BTW, I drive
2002 Firehawk #1149
 
I think you both may be right. Over the years many of the subtle, pull-your-hair-out problems I've encountered that managed to stump me turned out to be the PSU. Good luck, let us know what happens!
 
You might want to try testing the memory with prime95. I have seen memory that will run memtest86+ for 24hrs without error but fail prime95 after several hours. Your PSU might be a problem also.
 
I kicked my abit kt7-raid board to the curb because i thought it had stability problems. Turned out to be my cheap POS 300watt psu that alpine computers sold me. I went back to get a better one and all they had were these flimsy nobody brand psu's. I learned a valuable lesson that day, don't buy local.
 
Yippee38 said:
Already did try the 1004.001 BIOS. Didn't help.

FWIW, after a crash (reboot), I got the exact following message:
=======================================================
Computer started after an unexpected shutdown.
Microsoft Windows detected a possible device failure.

The driver for the display device was unable to complete the drawing operation. Please check with teh device manufacturer fro a driver update.

Please tell Microsoft about this problem.
The display driver for NVIDIA GeForce 6800 Series GPU seems to be responsible for the system instability.
========================================================

I've tried uninstalling and re-installing the drivers a bajillion times (using Driver Cleaner Pro every time) and it doesn't help.


The last time I recieved that error it was because I had fastwrites enabled,I disabled them and I was O.K. after that.Of course when you have brand new cutting edge technology it could be alot of things which is why I wait until all the bugs are fixed.

Chris
 
I would try the following, in this particular order.

1.) Exchange the board for a new one.

Failing that,

2.) New PSU. While the Antec is a fine unit, with two HOT video cards, and no doubt a power-hungry CPU and mobo, two 7200rpm hard disks, and two DVD burners, you could be pushing the redline of what the power supply is able to handle. My experience in the past has been that when you suddenly lose video performance, and it is being followed by lockups, the power supply is to blame.
 
I've decided to pick up a new PSU first. Right now I'm looking at the PCP&C 510 Deluxe SLI and the Enermax EG701AX-VE (W)SFMA. The downsides to the PCP&C are the price and the noise. Yeah, I can get them to put in quieter fans, but that just irks me. If they can put in quieter fans, why don't they? Could it be because it will cost you more? Based upon how they rape you for shipping, I'd guess that the answer is, "Yes." The problem I'm having now is that neither the Enermax nor the PCP&C have much better numbers than the Antec. However, my experience with the Antec is that it is performing BELOW rated output rather than above. It looks to me like the other consistantly perform above rated output. Maybe that will be the difference. I wonder if I'd have been better getting the TrueControl so I could tweak the voltages. I just love how much this system is going to cost me. :(
 
Back
Top