Inside India’s CAPTCHA Solving Economy

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
ZDNet has an interesting blog entry looking at the burgeoning CAPTCHA solving industry in India. Workers make around $2 for solving a thousand CAPTCHAs and companies are hiring “data processing” workers for this activity. Crazy.

Let’s analyze the shady data processing economy of India… and take a tour inside the web applications of several Bangladesh based franchises, whose team of almost 1,000 international workers is actively soliciting deals for breaking Craigslist, Gmail, Yahoo, MySpace, YouTube and Facebook’s CAPTCHA, promising to deliver 250k solved CAPTCHAs per day on a “$2 for a 1000 solved CAPTCHAs” rate.
 
Wow... that's seriously fucked up stuff. As a regular Craig's List user (I probably check the Computers/Electronics categories 50x a day or more looking for good deals when they appear, and other categories as well), the constant and absolutely insane level of spam we have here in the Las Vegas Computers category is unbelievable.

First it was some lamer named "Jeremy" (Baro) who's now under indictment in Redmond by Microsoft for selling pirated copies of their products (Adobe is also on the case I think), then people that hated the asshole started spamming their comments, then he fired back, using some autoposting/distributed posting crap with CAPTCHA defeating stuff (now I have some idea how thanks to this thread), and it's just been escalating ever since. For nearly 2 years now this crap has been going on, and Craig's List doesn't seem to give a shit as they only seem to make money off people looking for work and posting jobs/resumes.

And now we're getting people spamming their eBay auctions by posting ads on Craig's List for items that, even though they're local here in Vegas, are still only being sold on eBay so they do the entire ad on CL and then leave a link to the eBay auction page. Plus, the "Beijing" contingency with spam from outside the US and hundreds of useless posts per day.

I really can't comprehend how CL stays alive, considering the bandwidth costs (it's a 95% text only service with some basic image hosting, but even so the bandwidth ain't free and they're freakin' popular as hell. Alexa ranks the site in 39th place, and that's a LOT of bandwidth for such a simple service.

Bleh. Ruining a good resource for everyone, it only takes a small number of total fools and idiots with nothing but greed on their mind.

But thanks for the heads up, Terry, this helps make a lot of crap far more understandable now. Interesting...
 
I actually had an idea like this for leveling bots (MMOs basicly)
For $1/day the company will respond to tells that your bot gets. One worker could easily handle thousands of accounts.
 
Some CAPTCHAs are already so bad I have to hit refresh a few times to find one I can figure out. The ones Rapidshare had a few months back for example... man those were horrid.
 
lol - my parents are from Bangladesh, no wonder people would go into those jobs.
It's tough trying to make enough money over there trying to feed your family and hopefully eventually educate them.
Went their earlier this year from the UK

Not got a solution to this though (captcha bashing)
 
Very interesting portal into the workings of India, and a case study on how such a mechanism could be used for constructive puposes.

But doesn't this massive effort, condoned by government, and supported by business to support/engage in cybercrime on a mass scale, really smell like an ACT OF WAR? :cool:

Someone smart better come up with a much better equivalent to captcha, and soon. Because the Orc's of Mordoor are busy felling trees and building cyberweapons :eek::rolleyes::p
 
Back
Top