0xygenthief
Weaksauce
- Joined
- Sep 11, 2007
- Messages
- 83
Fellow H'ers,
I am about to trek down the watercooling path again and would like to run my proposed system by everyone to make sure I am not making any huge mistakes. I have broken down this post to facilitate easier reading. I am sure most of you will probably find it easier to read this way.
Purpose
The purpose here is twofold. The main reason is to reduce the noise created by my rig. Some of you lucky bastards get to have your own gaming den to escape from the wife and kids. I on the other hand get a corner in our living room. Granted most of the time when I game the kids are asleep and the wife can simply turn the TV up. However, I have had friends comment on my system noise over Ventrilo. So what’s the secondary purpose? Well, if I am going to do anything to my rig that costs me money I better see some results in game! Not really a rock solid justification for buying two new graphics cards but hey that’s my story and I’m sticking to it. I plan on going with the 480 GTX cards for the upgrade. The cards are even louder than my 280 GTX cards so watercooling is the only way to go. Also, I wouldn’t mind bumping my performance even higher with some moderate overclocks for both the CPU and GPU.
Background
Here’s a little bit about me that may help weed out the snarky replies that suggest I read up on the “intro to watercooling” write-ups either here or on other sites. As I said in the beginning of the post this isn’t my first attempt at watercooling. My first w/c setup ran a loop that contained an older lapped AMD FX-57 processor as well as a DD full coverage waterblock for an ATI 1900xtx. I used an old single 9w laing ddc pump and two BIX 120.1 radiators inside of an antec P180 case to keep everything cool. Just like now my main reason was to rid myself of the noise created by my graphics card. So by no means am I a noob at watercooling but still my setup was tame in comparison to some of the systems I have seen in these forums and is why I am reaching out to you all before laying down my Hard earned cash.
System Specs
Current:
Cosmos S case
Gigabyte X58-UD5 Motherboard
I7 940 processor with a TRUE 120
12 GB DDR3 RAM
Twin BFG 280 GTX cards in SLI
Azuentech 7.1 Forte audio card
Therlatake Toughpower 1200w PSU
Proposed Components:
Two 480 GTX gpus – undecided on which brand to go with just yet
Two full coverage GPU blocks for these cards. Watercool Heatkillers are preferred based on current lineup’s performance. However, as of this posting Watercool hasn’t released a block for the 400 series. I am sure they will but if not DD would be my second choice based on past experience with the company.
Heatkiller dual link for parallel flow: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...e=product_info&cPath=59_411&products_id=25225
Watercool Heatkiller CPU waterblock: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...oduct_info&cPath=59_498_495&products_id=25218
EK-FB Kit for Motherboard chipset and Mosfets: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...oduct_info&cPath=59_241_589&products_id=25580
XSPC dual loop reservoir: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...oduct_info&cPath=59_318_665&products_id=25767
Two 12w laing ddc pumps: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...ge=product_info&cPath=59_201&products_id=2539
1 Feser 360mm Radiator: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...t_info&cPath=59_457_667_669&products_id=23558
3 Feaser 120mm Radiators: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...t_info&cPath=59_457_667_669&products_id=23556
2 Zalman 6 channel fan controllers: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...=zalman_fan_controller-_-11-999-171-_-Product
12 GentleTyphoon 15 fans: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...re=gentletyphoon_120mm-_-35-185-092-_-Product
Loop Design
The system will have two loops. One for the CPU/Chipset/Mosfets and the other for the GPUs.
Loop 1 (red/blue): Pump -> 120mm Rad - > 120mm Rad -> Chipset -> 120mm Rad -> CPU -> Mosfet
Loop2 (orange/green): Pump -> 360mm Rad -> GPUs (parallel flow)
Fans in push/pull without shrouds
All tubing will be 3/8 ID.
Areas of Concern
Restriction - I am not 100% sure the 12w laing ddc pumps will have enough power to handle 3 separate radiators and 4 waterblocks. Martin’s calculator would suggest that I will be fine. I know the ddc pumps are strong, my previous 9w version handled two rads and two waterblocks fine but I would feel better if others with similar setups or more restrictive setups had any opinions to share.
Overkill – Originally I wanted to have just two radiators in loop 1 but after reading in various forums about the i7 being a beast to watercool I figured an extra radiator might provide me with better temps and better overclocking success. However would the extra cost, complexity and restriction be worth the performance gains?
Positioning - Does pump/reservoir height within the system make a difference? Most systems have the pumps at the bottom of the case, obviously to be below the reservoir. But with the XSPC reservoir I have the option to place it anywhere minus the top two 5.25 bays in the Cosmos S case. What effect, if any does pump position have on the system?
Airflow – I will only have the side stock 54 cfm 200mm fan blowing air into the system. I would rather not blow hot air into the system. So the question is what impact will this have to the overall performance of the system?
Parallel vs. Series flow for GPUs - I can see the concern for parallel flow in a watercooling setup. I am fine running the two gpu's in series if necessary but I think the dual link looks pretty cool and makes tube management that much easier. Has anyone had any negative experiences with the dual link adapters for the heatkillers?
I am about to trek down the watercooling path again and would like to run my proposed system by everyone to make sure I am not making any huge mistakes. I have broken down this post to facilitate easier reading. I am sure most of you will probably find it easier to read this way.
Purpose
The purpose here is twofold. The main reason is to reduce the noise created by my rig. Some of you lucky bastards get to have your own gaming den to escape from the wife and kids. I on the other hand get a corner in our living room. Granted most of the time when I game the kids are asleep and the wife can simply turn the TV up. However, I have had friends comment on my system noise over Ventrilo. So what’s the secondary purpose? Well, if I am going to do anything to my rig that costs me money I better see some results in game! Not really a rock solid justification for buying two new graphics cards but hey that’s my story and I’m sticking to it. I plan on going with the 480 GTX cards for the upgrade. The cards are even louder than my 280 GTX cards so watercooling is the only way to go. Also, I wouldn’t mind bumping my performance even higher with some moderate overclocks for both the CPU and GPU.
Background
Here’s a little bit about me that may help weed out the snarky replies that suggest I read up on the “intro to watercooling” write-ups either here or on other sites. As I said in the beginning of the post this isn’t my first attempt at watercooling. My first w/c setup ran a loop that contained an older lapped AMD FX-57 processor as well as a DD full coverage waterblock for an ATI 1900xtx. I used an old single 9w laing ddc pump and two BIX 120.1 radiators inside of an antec P180 case to keep everything cool. Just like now my main reason was to rid myself of the noise created by my graphics card. So by no means am I a noob at watercooling but still my setup was tame in comparison to some of the systems I have seen in these forums and is why I am reaching out to you all before laying down my Hard earned cash.
System Specs
Current:
Cosmos S case
Gigabyte X58-UD5 Motherboard
I7 940 processor with a TRUE 120
12 GB DDR3 RAM
Twin BFG 280 GTX cards in SLI
Azuentech 7.1 Forte audio card
Therlatake Toughpower 1200w PSU
Proposed Components:
Two 480 GTX gpus – undecided on which brand to go with just yet
Two full coverage GPU blocks for these cards. Watercool Heatkillers are preferred based on current lineup’s performance. However, as of this posting Watercool hasn’t released a block for the 400 series. I am sure they will but if not DD would be my second choice based on past experience with the company.
Heatkiller dual link for parallel flow: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...e=product_info&cPath=59_411&products_id=25225
Watercool Heatkiller CPU waterblock: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...oduct_info&cPath=59_498_495&products_id=25218
EK-FB Kit for Motherboard chipset and Mosfets: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...oduct_info&cPath=59_241_589&products_id=25580
XSPC dual loop reservoir: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...oduct_info&cPath=59_318_665&products_id=25767
Two 12w laing ddc pumps: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...ge=product_info&cPath=59_201&products_id=2539
1 Feser 360mm Radiator: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...t_info&cPath=59_457_667_669&products_id=23558
3 Feaser 120mm Radiators: http://www.performance-pcs.com/cata...t_info&cPath=59_457_667_669&products_id=23556
2 Zalman 6 channel fan controllers: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...=zalman_fan_controller-_-11-999-171-_-Product
12 GentleTyphoon 15 fans: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...re=gentletyphoon_120mm-_-35-185-092-_-Product
Loop Design
The system will have two loops. One for the CPU/Chipset/Mosfets and the other for the GPUs.
Loop 1 (red/blue): Pump -> 120mm Rad - > 120mm Rad -> Chipset -> 120mm Rad -> CPU -> Mosfet
Loop2 (orange/green): Pump -> 360mm Rad -> GPUs (parallel flow)
Fans in push/pull without shrouds
All tubing will be 3/8 ID.
Areas of Concern
Restriction - I am not 100% sure the 12w laing ddc pumps will have enough power to handle 3 separate radiators and 4 waterblocks. Martin’s calculator would suggest that I will be fine. I know the ddc pumps are strong, my previous 9w version handled two rads and two waterblocks fine but I would feel better if others with similar setups or more restrictive setups had any opinions to share.
Overkill – Originally I wanted to have just two radiators in loop 1 but after reading in various forums about the i7 being a beast to watercool I figured an extra radiator might provide me with better temps and better overclocking success. However would the extra cost, complexity and restriction be worth the performance gains?
Positioning - Does pump/reservoir height within the system make a difference? Most systems have the pumps at the bottom of the case, obviously to be below the reservoir. But with the XSPC reservoir I have the option to place it anywhere minus the top two 5.25 bays in the Cosmos S case. What effect, if any does pump position have on the system?
Airflow – I will only have the side stock 54 cfm 200mm fan blowing air into the system. I would rather not blow hot air into the system. So the question is what impact will this have to the overall performance of the system?
Parallel vs. Series flow for GPUs - I can see the concern for parallel flow in a watercooling setup. I am fine running the two gpu's in series if necessary but I think the dual link looks pretty cool and makes tube management that much easier. Has anyone had any negative experiences with the dual link adapters for the heatkillers?
Last edited: