Information Overload - Console Gaming Display Confusion

pcguru83

Weaksauce
Joined
Nov 1, 2006
Messages
93
I need some help here guys. I've searched, and read, and researched, and I'm at the point now where I'm just getting frustrated. Here's the deal:

I'm not a PC gamer. I've always been a console gamer, and being a recent Mac switcher, I'm clinging to my console gaming now more than ever. :) Obviously all the next-gen gaming systems basically require some form of high-definition display. Therein lies my problem.

We can't get reliable HD service at our house, and won't be able to for the next 1-2 years (long story). Because of this, I just can't justify the purchase of an HDTV right now, and quite frankly, I can't afford to do so at the moment.

First of all, here's my current setup:
-20" Apple Cinema Display (newest revision; best display I've ever seen)
-Mac Mini
-Xbox 360
-PS3 (I borrowed this from a friend)

Size is NOT important to me. I'm perfectly happying gaming at my desk on a 20" monitor. In fact, I'd be very hesitant to go much bigger than this for reasons of both size and money. After my initial research, I bought a 20" Samsung 206BW last night at Circuit City, but I'm beginning to doubt my purchase. This is intended to replace my Cinema Display. Let me explain what I've done with it so far.

I first tried hooking up the PS3 via a DVI-->HDMI cable. Turned the PS3 on, and nothing was displayed. The monitor flashed "Optimum resolution is 1680 x 1050, 60 Hz". My friend had his PS3 running at 1080i, so I'm thinking if I could have got into the PS3 to change the display settings to 720p, it would have displayed just fine, but I can't confirm this. So I struck out with the PS3.

I then moved onto the Xbox 360, which is the one I was really concerned about. I connected it via the 360 VGA cable and worked perfectly. I first changed the resolution to 1280 x 720, but the image was cropped on the left side and there was a black bar on the right. I then changed it to 1280 x 768, and the image looked great. No cropping or distortion that I could see.

I fired up a game using this setting (DiRT), and to my untrained eye, it looked fantastic. All parts of the screen were perfectly visible and there was no distortion that I could spot.

I suppose my question is this--Did I get the monitor most appropriate for my needs? I can potentially see myself getting a PS3 down the road, so the fact that it wouldn't dispaly anything is slightly troublesome. Also, I don't really understand what the monitor and 360 are doing. I'm fully aware that the monitor is a 16:10 AR, where as the 360 displays a 16:9 AR. Why was I not seeing any distortion?

The most I can rationalize spending at this point is $350. Unless there is just some overwhelmingly compelling reason to go with a 24", I just can't see spending the extra money at this point, especially since I was perfectly happy with my 20" ACD. I should note, I work with a 30" ACD at work every day, so I've experienced the joy of larger monitors. That being said, I'm still happy with the 20" size for home use. :)

This feels like a very disjointed post, and for that I apologize. If anyone can offer any advice, it would definitely be appreciated. Thanks guys!
 
Back
Top