Indie Developers Aren't Beggars

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
What are your thoughts on indie developers? Do you think they are all low-budget, desperate, hobbyists, scraping the bottom of the barrel for a buck wherever / whenever they can? Well, at least one indie developer doesn't want you to think that and here's why.

Indie means ‘independent’. It means you dont’ work for a publisher that controls your output. It means self-funded, with total control. It does NOT mean *cheap* or *low budget* or *desperate* or *hobbyist*. Granted, there are a lot of hobbyist indie devs, but that doesn’t mean some indies don’t employ a bunch of people, have nice offices, spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars on development, produce high quality content, and you know what…. I think it’s perfectly reasonable for a lot of those indie games to sell big numbers, and *shock horror* for the developers to make some decent money without being made to feel like they are worse than osama bin laden.
 
What? Indie developers does not mean they come from India? learn something everyday.

Seriously though, I am not sure what this guy is going on for...I never associated Indie with beggars or anything close.

Hell, I know a some friends that make indie movies... trust me when I say they are not beggers.
 
Yeah I thought indie developers were overall doing very well. Specifically because of steam.
 
Steam has really helped the indie market. Without a service like Steam I really wonder how indie gaming would turn out.
 
I forgot to add... I wish Steam would host great titles such as Cave Story and other indie games. More people would play them.
 
Wouldn't CDProjectRed (The Whitcher) be considered an indie dev? I believe they funded and published both Witcher games themselves.
 
Wouldn't CDProjectRed (The Whitcher) be considered an indie dev? I believe they funded and published both Witcher games themselves.

RED is the dev arm. CD Projekt is the publishing arm. They could probably be considered AAA developers now.
 
RED is the dev arm. CD Projekt is the publishing arm. They could probably be considered AAA developers now.

To add to that, CD Projekt is one of the largest publishers in eastern Europe.

Whatever subsidiary that they have is definitely not considered indie.
 
I do like indie games, I've got quite a few, but then you get the (a vast majority actually), ones that while "popular" for some reason, do look like they've been done by a 2 bit poor arsed couple of guys. Those 4 descriptions given in the quoted text is exactly what they look like.
 
Huh, this is news to me. While I admit to buying main stream programs usually, if I stumbled across a indie game that I though was interesting I've always been game to try. Guess I never really bothered to care WHO was making it.
 
Not to be a jerk but most of the stuff he has made falls into the low budget crappy looking.
http://www.positech.co.uk/kudos2/index.html

I understand what he is trying to accomplish but honestly I have seen very very few AAA indie games. I cannot even list one at the moment. While I would not classify them as garbage, I would pretty much always classify them as low budget with one of the following, short, shallow story, bad graphics. Now I dont use those in a negative manner but 99% of the time the game will fall under one of those.
 
Before steam they used to go by the shareware model. I've tried a good dozen that way, I agree now however they might as well use steam. Built in DRM is good for them.

I've never thought of them as being beggars.. Simple games sure, or lower graphics. But I've never thought of them as bad.
 
Indie ... does NOT mean *cheap* or *low budget* ... spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars on development...
That is cheap and low-budget.

Spending a hundred thousand dollars on development basically means hiring one employee.

Spending $20,000 on development probably means working out of your parents' basement and living on instant noodles.
 
I'm a little biased, since I'm an indie developer myself. My projects have been low to no budget games and applications, and I'm happy if I get any sales at all. I'm not in it for the money, but money is always nice. I wouldn't call indie game developers beggars. Gamblers is a better word.

Sometimes you work on a project for months and it's a flop. Sometimes it's a best seller. The big gamble for Indie developers is marketing. You can have a great game with no marketing, and it will never go anywhere. But, a mediocre game with good marketing can surpass it easily. In a way, it's no different from the corporate gaming market, just with more chances for failure. You wouldn't consider a local coffee shop to be a bunch of beggars, even though they are dwarfed by Starbucks.

One of my biggest surprises was an app I made called The Name Dropper, which is just an app for creating random names for databases, expectant mothers, screenwriters, etc. It took a week of work, and I didn't expect any sales at all. It made about $2000 in one year, which is pretty good for the amount of work that went into it. Brickout, which I put several months of work into, didn't end up making that much money overall, but it has provided enough steady income to pay for web hosting and domains for the past 6 years, with no sign of tailing off.
 
Can't speak for PC gaming, as I only play a few games. But on the mobile side, I can say that some of the best games on my iPhone are from independent developers, and not big software houses. An example of this is the combat helicopter sim "H-Elite" Beats alot of desktop sims i've played, devs are very responsive to customers, and updates are frequent (to add features, not fix bugs). Much better support than what you get with the big-name devs.

If anything, the indy devs actually strive to put out quality software moreso than the big-name devs. They care about their customers, because their customers are their income. Big-name devs tend to try and use brand recognition to get people to buy their stuff. Independent devs need to build that brand recognition; so they must work harder.
 
This guy must think he's pretty fucking special to be in the same league as osama bin laden.
 
Back
Top