The old Mac Pro was 2p and could be loaded with two X5670 Xeons that were each 6c12t...So no you would not be comparing "12 core to 12 core" you would be comparing a 1p 6c12t machine to a 2p 12c24t machine.
I'm not the one who compared it, anand is.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The old Mac Pro was 2p and could be loaded with two X5670 Xeons that were each 6c12t...So no you would not be comparing "12 core to 12 core" you would be comparing a 1p 6c12t machine to a 2p 12c24t machine.
http://www.extremetech.com/computin...s-2000-cheaper-than-the-equivalent-windows-pcI am not sure what you are smoking, but to get that $2700 CPU, you pay Apple an EXTRA $3500(base model). So you aren't getting anything for free.
From Apple.com:
2.7GHz 12-core with 30MB of L3 cache [Add $3,500.00]
So a Minimum price of for the "free" system is $6500 with that CPU.
For a CPU that Intel lists at under $2700.
Even worse you don't get credit for the original CPU. There is nothing Free here.
Dude, just drop it. You have absolutely no clue what you're talking about. The CPU alone costs $2700 if you purchase it by itself. Apple is practically giving you the rest of the parts for free, not to mention their support.
I was referring to the high end model, which I didnt state when I replied. If you put all the parts together as if you are building a windows machine, its well over 10k, while GPUs cost closer to 3500.That link does not make your case of Apple selling you a $2700 cpu and giving the rest for free.
That PSU is tiny for those GPUs, highly binned I's guess.
My reply was mainly to his argument that you can build a windows machine equivalent to what the mac offer for less. Well there are all the parts laid out, it costs more.
A lot of people who build their own computers have a pretty unrealistic idea of the PSU's output versus the harware they're installing. Video card manufacturers aren't helping the situation by recommending much higher wattage outputs than necessary to avoid becoming liable for the failure of non-video card components. The result of that and reinforcement from hardware review sites is that people have a very skewed perception of consumption and output. Then again, there's a whole PSU industry built around overengineered and overspecced supplies and it helps move money around and employ a bunch of people (also there's bragging rights and pointless specifications lists in signature blocks) so whatevah.
But yeah, power supply in Mac is perfectly fine for the stuff in it. Like any other OEM, they're just smarter about components selection than the average modder/home PC builder.
But with the PC you could get a pair of R9-290s and save $6000, and have equivalent(better) performance, and come in at half the price.
Furthermore, because there are no Mac apps that require special workstation cards, the "workstation" GPU designation on a Mac is largely meaningless and arbitrary. It is just enables some to justify the obscene over-pricing.
My point was that argument only works if you really buy into the bogus "workstation" GPU pricing argument.
This is where you jumped in and claimed you were buying $2700 CPU and get the rest for free.
Now you are back to making that same bogus GPU argument. The pair GPUs on the high end config are claimed to be worth $7000. This is what really inflates the "equivalent" PC pricing.
But with the PC you could get a pair of R9-290s and save $6000, and have equivalent(better) performance, and come in at half the price.
Furthermore, because there are no Mac apps that require special workstation cards, the "workstation" GPU designation on a Mac is largely meaningless and arbitrary. It is just enables some to justify the obscene over-pricing.
I dont know much about workstation cards, but I do know they are not made for gaming. R9 cards are made specifically with gaming in mind and so are the drivers.My point was that argument only works if you really buy into the bogus "workstation" GPU pricing argument.
This is where you jumped in and claimed you were buying $2700 CPU and get the rest for free.
Now you are back to making that same bogus GPU argument. The pair GPUs on the high end config are claimed to be worth $7000. This is what really inflates the "equivalent" PC pricing.
But with the PC you could get a pair of R9-290s and save $6000, and have equivalent(better) performance, and come in at half the price.
Furthermore, because there are no Mac apps that require special workstation cards, the "workstation" GPU designation on a Mac is largely meaningless and arbitrary. It is just enables some to justify the obscene over-pricing.
So you want a workstation to use gaming cards... sure they are cheaper and faster, but having to run your software that cost more than the Mac in software rendering mode because of unsupported GPU and piss poor gaming drivers... kind of defeats this
"Perfectly fine"?
Aren't Thunderbolt storage drives bus-powered as a "feature"? This machine at stock full load with no accessories already uses 95% of it's power supply rating. All the external HDDs sold on store.apple.com I see are bus powered. Given that you have no choice for more storage than to buy external drives, and given that 7200RPM drives typically draw what 4-10W each it is a moronically setup Catch 22. "Perfectly fine" is laughable unless you don't plan on using any bus-powered accessories, which is all Apple sells.
Name one piece of Mac Software that requires "workstation" GPUs to run HW rendering.
Also, hit up AutoCADs website, you won't find them recommending any consumer level cards. They flat out will not support them.
Not that you're going to be convinced otherwise...
http://www.reddit.com/r/techsupport/comments/zs1ct/can_someone_explain_the_real_difference_between/
So you are saying the Autodesk flat out refused to support the Mac software they were selling, on Macs?
That is of course. Total nonsense.
I'm not sure if you're trolling or are really this ignorant. Autocad won't support consumer level cards on Mac, Windows, or Unix. It doesn't matter what platform you're working on.
hes trolling, again
I'm not sure if you're trolling or are really this ignorant. Autocad won't support consumer level cards on Mac, Windows, or Unix. It doesn't matter what platform you're working on.
Even assuming that your estimate of 95% capacity is correct (I think it's sort of an off-the-cuff, and highly suspect number) that leaves 22 watts for external drives and your keyboard and mousey. Assuming an external drive actually needs 10 watts, you could easily add two and still not have any problems, even at the assumed 95% at full load thing.
I know it goes against a lot of PC enthusiast ideology to accept that 450 watts is enough, but it really is more than the Mac Pro needs or can use. They test this stuff because, like every other OEM, the moment the computer needs customer support or service for something broken, they start to lose money on the sale of the unit.
FYI, I have a desktop PC running a middle of the road video card on an off brand 300 watt PSU that came with the $35 dollar case. It's been working fine for over a year like that. At work, I have stuffed Dell Optiplex 360s with external graphics cards and have no problems with their stock 255 watt power supplies as long as you stay within the 75 watt limit of the PCI-E slot. They work for years that way without any power supply problems. So yeah, PSU ratings from forum users here are usually a bit more than necessary.
Macs didn't even have workstation GPUs until the new Pro. So if they didn't support standard GPUs in Macs, then they wouldn't support Macs.
Per Anandtech, at full load on CPU and 2xGPUs the system pulls ~437W, and the PSU per iFixit is rated for 450 (32.2A @ 12.1V output). So I was being off the cuff yes and it is actually worse, 437/450=97.1% rated PSU capacity without any expansion devices. At 463W load (overload technically), Anand saw performance throttling kick in cutting performance.
So yes, the box is underpowered especially given the expectation you are to use bus powered expension.
I have to stress that I havent been able to get this to happen in any normal workload, only whats effectively a power virus for the GPUs and something quite unrealistic for the CPUs. Either way it shows us the upper limit of what the thermal core can do.
but having to run your software that cost more than the Mac in software rendering mode because of unsupported GPU and piss poor gaming drivers... kind of defeats this
Mac Autocad doesn't even come with software rendering. So there is no need for a workstation card, it works and is supported with any GPU that is deemed acceptable at install time:
http://usa.autodesk.com/adsk/servlet/index?siteID=123112&id=16470588
"Because AutoCAD for Mac does not have its own software renderer, it relies more heavily on the graphics hardware than the Windows version of AutoCAD"
9. Why is hardware designed for desktop or gaming applications not Certified or Recommended?
Some desktop or gaming-level hardware may work with the 3D display features in certain Autodesk software, but these products are not supported by Autodesk or the hardware vendor for use with 3D applications.
http://usa.autodesk.com/adsk/servlet/index?siteID=123112&id=16318759
The article you're quoting states multiple times this isn't anything close to typical usage.
From http://www.anandtech.com/show/7603/mac-pro-review-late-2013/14
It's an unrealistic, invented situation and it clearly demonstrates the PSU can handle more than it's rated 450 watt capacity. Throttling isn't really even related since that was due to thermal rather than power output limits.
I'm not sure why this is so hard for you to understand, directly from their FAQ:
What is so hard to understand in the statement, 'these products are not supported'?
Running a system at full load is an "invented situation". Got it.
Because that is on the PC side. They have separate requirements for Macs and they are different:
http://usa.autodesk.com/adsk/servlet/ps/dl/item?siteID=123112&id=15802859&linkID=15839490
No mention of workstation cards, like there is on the PC side.