iFixit Mac Pro Teardown

Just glossed over Anandtech's review and the thing is a little inferno POS and is going to have a short life from heat stroke. Under load the CPU and GPU are near 100C. And, I thought my Xeon and Nvidia @ ~80C are bad. I'd rather have better cooling and a non-disposable computer at the expense size.
 
Just glossed over Anandtech's review and the thing is a little inferno POS and is going to have a short life from heat stroke. Under load the CPU and GPU are near 100C. And, I thought my Xeon and Nvidia @ ~80C are bad. I'd rather have better cooling and a non-disposable computer at the expense size.

Right, this one?

The new Mac Pro’s thermal core works extremely well in practice. The single, shared heatsink and large fan keep the system cool and quiet. Real world workloads that I threw at the machine weren’t enough to throttle any of the processors (CPU or GPU). Despite its compact proportions, the Mac Pro’s cooling solution is appropriately sized for the silicon it serves.
 
You don't spend all that money to let it run idle. That temp for any duration means short life. No need to apologize for a shortcoming.

"The GPUs peaked at 97C, which is pretty much as high as a 28nm Tahiti should ever go. The CPU hit a similar temperature, with most cores hovering around 95C."
 
That seems to sum up most Mac usage but maybe include Facebook and Angry Birds.
 
OF course, you spend all that money to let it run furmark and prime95, right?

No. You spend that kind of money to render animation, which can come up with a similar workload using both CPU and GPU at same time based on the software used.
 
You don't spend all that money to let it run idle. That temp for any duration means short life. No need to apologize for a shortcoming.

"The GPUs peaked at 97C, which is pretty much as high as a 28nm Tahiti should ever go. The CPU hit a similar temperature, with most cores hovering around 95C."

I had a feeling this thing would get hot. It has a shared heatsink between 3 large heat sources. That heatsink may be big but it has terrible fin density and thus a really small amount of surface area to dissipate heat with.

If I were designing it and had to stick with that form factor, I would have redesigned that heatsink in some sort of radial fin pattern with 3 times as many fins and use heatpipes to distribute the heat evenly amongst all the additional surface area for efficient dissipation. I would also have made the whole thing slightly taller to accommodate an additional intake fan on the bottom to force air through the fins.
 
I had a feeling this thing would get hot. It has a shared heatsink between 3 large heat sources. That heatsink may be big but it has terrible fin density and thus a really small amount of surface area to dissipate heat with.

If I were designing it and had to stick with that form factor, I would have redesigned that heatsink in some sort of radial fin pattern with 3 times as many fins and use heatpipes to distribute the heat evenly amongst all the additional surface area for efficient dissipation. I would also have made the whole thing slightly taller to accommodate an additional intake fan on the bottom to force air through the fins.

No there are 4 large heat sources. You're forgetting the PSU. Per Anand, this system pretty much maxes out the 450W it has inside of it at full load.

http://www.anandtech.com/show/7603/mac-pro-review-late-2013/14
 
No there are 4 large heat sources. You're forgetting the PSU. Per Anand, this system pretty much maxes out the 450W it has inside of it at full load.

http://www.anandtech.com/show/7603/mac-pro-review-late-2013/14
I'm not forgetting about the PSU. If you look at the teardown in the original link, there are only 3 large heat sources attached to the massive heatsink at center. The PSU actually sits behind the CPU daughter card and in front of the I/O panel and thus gets its own separate stream of air separate from the other 3.

Pic for reference. The triangular heatsink in center is the main shared heatsink. The section above it with hexoganal mesh is the PSU compartment:

pkPrnKKQnGhDI1Ho.medium


I'm referring to the shared heatsink, which has 3 of the 4 large heatsources attached to it: The CPU, GPU#1, and GPU #2.
 
Reminds me of the deficiency of 9800GX2 and its shared heatsink for two GPUs that lead to instability and short life. 437W max load on a 450W power supply and no redundant power? No redundant fan? Designed like a toy.
 
No. You spend that kind of money to render animation, which can come up with a similar workload using both CPU and GPU at same time based on the software used.

No, it can't.

Anand ran Cinebench also, you didn't read the review did you?
 
Not sure why there's so much hate. If anything the layout and form factor are unique and compact. You (all) may not like it, but it's so compact and powerful not even with the M1 can you have two powerhouse GPUs in a single, SFF.

The temps were not too shabby -- if you disregard the FurMark and Prime95 burn test, which can and does get a CPU (4770k lol) GPU toasty (those R 290/290x cards) if you decide to run that nonsense.


Like anything, if I were buying, I'd wait and see.
 
Why would someone doing professional video editing or animation need the small form factor which simply adds to cost and makes the product difficult to source repair parts for? ATX standards exist for a reason and there is no need for a proprietary form factor for this device's purpose. I can't see Apple selling many of these workstations.
 
Seriously?

And none of those will be used in a creative studio.
This is not a casual desktop PC to loop your Heaven Benchmark on.

Lol, spot on with that reply.

You're really kidding yourself, even if you're an apple hater that can't admit it, if you don't think this computer isn't insanely powerful for what it is. A hell of a feat getting all that packed in that space with no heat issues.

Hate on the design all you want but I dare you to find an off the shelf PC with those specs at that size (you cannot argue DIY PCs because only people with the time and drive to make one will ever have one). He'll, even off the shelf PC cases that small can't pack all that power.

I just wish it were cheaper.
 
Why would someone doing professional video editing or animation need ....

Have you ever worked with these people?

Some are normal humans, but many are Apple acolytes to the Nth degree, and won't work with anything else.

Pixar was founded and run by Steve Jobs, you really think they use Dells? :p
 
I love the design concept, of the single fan flow through design, and hope to see this in PCs without the absurd Apple/Workstation GPU tax.

I really don't care if you want to lay the blame for the absurd pricing with Apple, or the pointless Workstation GPUs (still Apple really), but you could get equivalent GPU power machine for MUCH less money without the largely meaningless "workstation" designation.
 
Just glossed over Anandtech's review and the thing is a little inferno POS and is going to have a short life from heat stroke. Under load the CPU and GPU are near 100C. And, I thought my Xeon and Nvidia @ ~80C are bad. I'd rather have better cooling and a non-disposable computer at the expense size.

Hah 80C, reminds me of my xfx 7950gt fanless card. IIRC it pushed 70C idle.
 
If I needed this system I would pay to have a custom enclosure made that is see through. I think APPLE should offer it as an option at least. The way each component is positioned and designed, it makes it look bad ass when the black cover is removed. It would resemble the old school macs that were made of color back in the day.
 
When comparing a 12 core system to an iMac and a system from 2009, no it isn't very much.

Also the old tower could be had with 12 cores as well. I wonder if the new machine would be any faster at all if comparing 12 core to 12 core.
 
Why do people compare it to the old model when the old model is no longer being sold and also 4 times bigger? If you have the older system then keep the older system. If you need a new system this is what you would be buying.
 
When comparing a 12 core system to an iMac and a system from 2009, no it isn't very much.

Also the old tower could be had with 12 cores as well. I wonder if the new machine would be any faster at all if comparing 12 core to 12 core.

The old Mac Pro was 2p and could be loaded with two X5670 Xeons that were each 6c12t...So no you would not be comparing "12 core to 12 core" you would be comparing a 1p 6c12t machine to a 2p 12c24t machine.
 
The old Mac Pro was 2p and could be loaded with two X5670 Xeons that were each 6c12t...So no you would not be comparing "12 core to 12 core" you would be comparing a 1p 6c12t machine to a 2p 12c24t machine.

The new Mac Pro under test (in the benchmark I was referring to) has a 12c/24t Xeon variant of this:
http://ark.intel.com/products/75283/Intel-Xeon-Processor-E5-2697-v2-30M-Cache-2_70-GHz?q=2697

So an old Dual socket 6c/12t (12c/24t total) would be a better comparison, than an old dual socket 4c/8t machine.
 
This is cheaper then any comparable PC of the same specs.

Only if you are gullible enough to believe that "workstaiton" GPUs are worth multiple times the price of when the label the exact same GPU as a general purpose/gaming GPU.

I would never fall for the "workstation" GPU scam.
 
Only if you are gullible enough to believe that "workstaiton" GPUs are worth multiple times the price of when the label the exact same GPU as a general purpose/gaming GPU.

I would never fall for the "workstation" GPU scam.
Dude, just drop it. You have absolutely no clue what you're talking about. The CPU alone costs $2700 if you purchase it by itself. Apple is practically giving you the rest of the parts for free, not to mention their support.
 
Only if you are gullible enough to believe that "workstaiton" GPUs are worth multiple times the price of when the label the exact same GPU as a general purpose/gaming GPU.

I would never fall for the "workstation" GPU scam.

Glad you're not designing anything of significance.

How confident you'll be in boarding an airplane that was rendered on a DIY PC parts from Newegg? :rolleyes:
 
Dude, just drop it. You have absolutely no clue what you're talking about. The CPU alone costs $2700 if you purchase it by itself. Apple is practically giving you the rest of the parts for free, not to mention their support.

I am not sure what you are smoking, but to get that $2700 CPU, you pay Apple an EXTRA $3500(base model). So you aren't getting anything for free.

From Apple.com:
2.7GHz 12-core with 30MB of L3 cache [Add $3,500.00]
So a Minimum price of for the "free" system is $6500 with that CPU.

For a CPU that Intel lists at under $2700.

Even worse you don't get credit for the original CPU. There is nothing Free here.
 
Dude, just drop it. You have absolutely no clue what you're talking about. The CPU alone costs $2700 if you purchase it by itself. Apple is practically giving you the rest of the parts for free, not to mention their support.

the most amusing part is that most of the people complaining have pretty low end parts in their rigs. :D
 
the most amusing part is that most of the people complaining have pretty low end parts in their rigs. :D

This is typical. After over a decade on tech forums I'm convinced that most vocal negative types aren't really that technically informed, they're just cheap :rolleyes:
 
Holy shit if that's your gripe why didn't you just post that first so we could have ignored you and moved on!

Holy Shit, why don't you actually read what I was responding to, where he claimed that after paying for the CPU: "Apple is practically giving you the rest of the parts for free..."

He seemed be assuming that you got the $2700 CPU in the $3000 Pro.

Clearly not the case. You pay $3500 + whatever the Base CPU is worth to get a CPU that Intel lists for under $2700, but I guess that is just normal for Apple.
 
Back
Top