Identical drives: one vibrates, other doesn't?

Reus

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 1, 2009
Messages
438
Hello

I recently purchased 2 WD 640GB AALS drives and have them running RAID O. While checking some things in my computer the other day, I noticed some vibration coming from the hard drive cage. I put my finger on each one, and noticed that I could feel a lot more vibration coming from one than the other. I even went as far as taking them out of the case and holding them in my hand, while powered on, to eliminate the case mounting as a source of the vibration.

So, is this normal to have differences like this among identical drives? Anything to be concerned about? The noise doesn't bother me, and I REALLY do not want the hassle of an RMA and subsequent OS re-install if this is no big deal. Thanks. :)
 
1) Run the OEM diagnostics on them.

2) Run some benchmarks on them. The drive with vibrations will prolly be slower as the vibrations may be causing read or write errors that have to be corrected.

Don
 
There are certain to be variations with identical models just due to manufacturing and whatnot. If the vibrations seem excessive (subjective judgment I guess) I would RMA just to be on the safer side personally. They really should not have much vibration to them.
 
Thanks for the replies! After much thought, I have decided to RMA the drive. Benchmarks and general performance seem fine, but the vibration is excessive in comparison with the other drive, which has virtually none.
 
Back
Top