IDE or SATA - Which is faster

mokkapoop

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
1,155
If I was to go get a new HD today, would I get a SATA or IDE? I dont have SATA onboard, but an get an adapter. Otherwise, I can stick with IDE.

In the long run, if both drives were 7200rpm, which would be faster?
 
If your board doesn't support SATA, then skip the hassle and go ahead with IDE. I'll make a guess that if both drives are 7200RPM, then they'll both run the same speed. SATA to me just has the convenience of no jumpers to mess with and less airflow restriction in the case.
 
Thats not right though. SATA is much faster than IDE even if both are 7200RPM.

I really noticed the difference when I switched to SATA and you can really see it in load times and when browsing through large folders/pictures, etc.

SATA is newer, faster, and the better of the two even if both are at 7200RPM.
 
From my experience there is almost no difference. I have some 7200.10's in both ide and sata, same size and cahce. Using hd tach the sata is only .8 mb/s faster, not much of a difference.
 
You might as well get used to SATA, it will totally replace PATA, just like AGP is being phased out over the course of several years. The newer mobos are already down to only one IDE connection and I'm certain that one connector will be missing within the next year on cutting edge boards. AGP and PATA HDDs will be alongside Socket A setups pretty soon. Original question, all factors equal the SATA will be faster.:)
 
To answer your question, SATA and its architecture are technically faster than IDE. As for advice, get the SATA drive for future upgradeability. For now, buy the adapter and live with it running at IDE speeds. If you get a new board with SATA, then you won't have to buy a new drive.

I actually do the opposite on my second rig (run IDE drives with a SATA adapter) and it works just fine.
 
SATA is SO much easier to deal with than IDE, its worth the 20 for the controller.

Now I just need an SATA DVD burner (have 2 HD's and a DVD-ROM)
 
avg transfer rate, access time: drive model/specs
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
36.6MB/s, 13.2ms: WD 80GB 7200, 8MB, PATA100
43.9MB/s, 13.6ms: WD 160GB 7200, 8MB, PATA100
50.5MB/s, 14.5ms: Maxtor 200GB 7200, 8MB, SATA150
52.7MB/s, 14.3ms: WD 160GB, 7200, 8MB, SATA300
52.5MB/s, 13.6ms: WD 250GB, 7200, 16MB, SATA300
65.1MB/s, 13.7ms: Seagate 320GB, 7200, 16MB, SATA300
77.5MB/s, 8.7ms: WD 150GB, 10000, 16MB, SATA150

If you do alot of drive-to-drive access (move files from one folder to another, rip music cd's, rip dvd's, archive/zip/rar files, video encoding, audio encoding, video editing, play games, etc), then you'll notice a difference. If you just browse the web, view webmail, blog, and write essays, then no, you probably won't notice much difference. However, the difference is there, and it is noticeable.

//edit: benchmarks ran from HDTune 2.5, on a P965 Express platform (E6400 @ 3.2Ghz, 2GBNQ, DS3, Ninja+B)
 
I upgraded from a Seagate 7200.7 8MB 160GB IDE drive to a Seagate 7200.10 16MB 320GB SATA drive and the difference is amazing!

I thought I could just use the IDE hard drive with my new C2D system but my computer wasn't very fast for everyday applications. I was disappointed at the C2D because I thought it would be faster than that. So I got a new SATA drive and my computer went flying. Everything is faster and I now know that it wasn't my C2D's fault, it was my IDE hard drive.

Yes, I am aware that I am comparing a .7 to a .10.
 
avg transfer rate, access time: drive model/specs
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
36.6MB/s, 13.2ms: WD 80GB 7200, 8MB, PATA100
43.9MB/s, 13.6ms: WD 160GB 7200, 8MB, PATA100
50.5MB/s, 14.5ms: Maxtor 200GB 7200, 8MB, SATA150
52.7MB/s, 14.3ms: WD 160GB, 7200, 8MB, SATA300
52.5MB/s, 13.6ms: WD 250GB, 7200, 16MB, SATA300
65.1MB/s, 13.7ms: Seagate 320GB, 7200, 16MB, SATA300
77.5MB/s, 8.7ms: WD 150GB, 10000, 16MB, SATA150

If you do alot of drive-to-drive access (move files from one folder to another, rip music cd's, rip dvd's, archive/zip/rar files, video encoding, audio encoding, video editing, play games, etc), then you'll notice a difference. If you just browse the web, view webmail, blog, and write essays, then no, you probably won't notice much difference. However, the difference is there, and it is noticeable.

//edit: benchmarks ran from HDTune 2.5, on a P965 Express platform (E6400 @ 3.2Ghz, 2GBNQ, DS3, Ninja+B)

Only two of those benchmarks are for the same drive. I would get more information before reaching a conclusion personally.

On another note you can get IDE to SATA adapters in bulk for about $4 each. The Seagate 750GB drive can be had for around $200 for the IDE version if you look around. I've got a 3Ware 9500 SATA RAID controller, so I just bought one 750GB IDE Drive for $200 and put a $4 adapter on it, instead of buying the $300 SATA version of the same drive. NCQ offers no advantage for RAID setups anyway. Eventually I hope to have four of these 750GB drives running in RAID 5 :)

2.25TB of redundant storage all inside the same computer case as my raptor 150 RAID 0 setup - lots of $$$$. The beauty of not having to deal with a seperate file server... priceless.
 
I agree even if there no performance difference sata is way more sexy. So much better seeing a a small wire then a cable.
Im using a raptor harddrive and using the sata just makes it so much more pretty.

Use sata if you can.

Im just curious why theres isnt so many sata cd roms? why arnt they all sata?
 
[CaM]Spoon;1030669911 said:
I agree even if there no performance difference sata is way more sexy. So much better seeing a a small wire then a cable.
Im using a raptor harddrive and using the sata just makes it so much more pretty.

Use sata if you can.

Im just curious why theres isnt so many sata cd roms? why arnt they all sata?

For an extra $4 you can make any CD-ROM SATA. The first "SATA" plextor drives on the market actually just had one of these slapped on the back of it.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822998001

The primary reason IMHO that so few CDROMs are SATA is engineering investment. CDROMs are not high-end devices and there isn't much profit to be made there. Consumers choose to purchase the cheapest drives they can find. They way to make the cheapest drive is to use already developed blueprints, not spend money developing something new that a large portion of the market won't be able to use.
 
Back
Top