IDE Bandwidth for Intel BX mobo?

Rob94hawk

2[H]4U
Joined
Jul 20, 2002
Messages
2,222
I really need a new HD for my old BX mobo but I need to know 3 things:

1. What is the max MB/sec for the IDE interface?

2. By having 2 HD's will the slowest HD keep the transfer rate down to the slowest one?

3. Recommend a HD that will almost max out the IDE.

Thanx,Rob
 
I recommend going to the FS/FT and pick up a hard drive controller that does at least ATA100 for about 15 - 20 shipped. The onboard controllers on the old 440BX boards are ATA33.
 
I second that.. Infact, might be better just to upgrade that whole system for dirt cheap, and double the performance.. ;)
 
1) As already stated, the 440BX southbridge is ATA-33 (33MB/sec) only, which is a definite limitation on bursting, and even linear reads with a modern drive.

Most any current generation drive can max out an ATA-33 controller with just linear reads, random reads being much, much lower.

ATA33 controllers cannot support todays large drives, either.

2) Not unless you're transfering data between them or reading from them both simultaneosuly, then yes.
If you're acessing one and not the other, then no (assuming faster drive is master).

3) Any modern drive. Buy an ATA100 controller card.
 
Originally posted by Barnaby
I second that.. Infact, might be better just to upgrade that whole system for dirt cheap, and double the performance.. ;)

Not if I want to use it as an mp3/dvd server in my house later on. Or I was even thinking of learning linux on it as well.

I'm just getting tired of that loud ass slow drive.
 
Understood...that's what my old BX is doing right now.. but my board has an integrated U2W scsi controller, so I have a few more options when it comes for drives... :)
 
BX lives brother! Good on you for keeping your perfectly good older gear! I think your three original questions were well answered above. I would say forget about getting an ATA-100 controller though...it'll clog the PCI bus, take up resources, and you really don' t need it, even with today's faster drives.
For a good old [H]ard disk, I'm using an IBM DTTA-350430 on my old school rig. It has 4.2 GB of space, is ATA-33, and is super silent. eBay would be a good place to look for an older but good drive; or you could just go over to pricewatch.com and get the cheapest new HD there, like a 20GB 5400rpm Maxtor for $36.
 
I would say forget about getting an ATA-100 controller though...it'll clog the PCI bus, take up resources, and you really don' t need it, even with today's faster drives.
You weren't paying attention - ATA-33 does not support large drives and has a maximum transfer rate of 33MB/sec which is significantly below the outer zone transfer rates of any current model (80GB/platter) 7200rpm ATA drive I've seen.

For an mp3 server, none of this matters, but you do indeed "need it" if you want to use a >137GB drive (in fact you need an ATA133 or an ATA100 controller with 48 bit LBA) or use most any current 7.2k drive to near its potential in linear transfers.

Hell, my most recently acquired drive, the SP1614N, has an inner zone transfer rate of 33.4MB/sec and an outer zone rate of 57.5MB/sec, numbers which are definitely not class leading, but which are both significantly above the maximum observable throughput you'd get on any ATA-33 controller.
edited for clarity
 
Back
Top