I know that both are good boards, but I'm looking for opinions on which one to get based on your own experiences, so please give me your opinion and why you like either board better.
imin the prosesss of trying to get a max 3 rma'd lol it has a volatage sability problem in the memory dimms i got the rma'd board and it wasnt modified...... also it didnt have the bracket that holds the heatsink to the top of the cpu...... pretty sloopy quality controll.. i just got off the phone with abit its going to be another 7 to 14 days (already been 13 days and i crossed shipped) read the threads about the max 3 there are other issues that theyarnt even trying to fix........ i wont buy abit again.....sighhh and such a pretty box
Well, if you look on any manufacturers wesite that has a public forum you will find problems with even the best hardware.
I bought an IC7-Max3 in December as part of a big upgrade and my experience has been stellar so far. I've also got an old ABIT BF6-II that's still going strong with a PIII-850.
That said, I don't think you can go wrong with either ABIT or Asus, they're both top tier manufacturers and they both have a reputation for quality and performance.
Well I personally own the original non-e Asus board, and my buddy owns the MAX3.
I can't see much difference in each other than the OTES system on the MAX3 helps OCing a bit. The MAX3 also has active NB cooling which is my one gripe with the Asus board. It was easily fixed though.
Based on looks the MAX3 looks much better IMO but that is personal preference.
If you are new to Overclocking the preset OC settings in the Asus BIOS are nice.
If you are going to go for the IC7-Max 3, be careful with choosing memory to go with it. I didn't read Abit's forums, and I ran into a whole bunch of trouble with some Mushkin 2-2-2 special. It would give me a BSOD at Windows XP install, and fail memtest. Naturally, I RMA'd, but the next pair failed memtest also and would cause random reboots, despite being able to install windows. I check the forums, and it's a somewhat common problem between the two. I'm sure it will be a great board as soon as I can get it running again.
I upgraded to the computer in my sig last november from an old 1 ghz T-bird setup. Anyhow, I had an Asus with my AMD, and this time around I decided to try Abit. Both of the motherboards worked flawlessly for me, the Asus lasting me 3 solid years, and still running for my brother. I have not had any problems with the MAX3, and it doesn't limit my OCing at all.