i7 Boards - Need opinions.

Cyane

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 1, 2008
Messages
143
Hi there,

Ok, so I've been looking at the Gigabyte EX58-UD5 and the MSI Eclipse (whichever model is both Crossfire and SLI Capable). Based on various reviews, the Gigabyte UD5 looks like an excellent board, but I've also read a lot of negative user reviews, many having DOAs and others having some sort of buzzing/screeching sound eminating from their boards. I haven't really found much on the MSI boards, so I can't really come up with a good comparison.

I welcome any suggestions, including other boards.

Cheers!
 
I hear the Asus P6T Deluxe V2 is a really good i7 board, right now I'm quite torn between the Asus P6T Deluxe V2 and the Gigabyte UD5.
 
How is the overclocking on that board? I would be concerned with the wimpy pahse compared to the other boards.
 
Avoid UD5 kinda hard to oc with it. It cause the tripple boot and resetting to default
(talking about my system) also many users reported that P6T mobos are great.
 
How's the Gigabyte UD5? Any major issues with that one? I've read mixed reviews about it from users, but excellent reviews from major review websites like Legitreviews and others. I'm still a bit torn though, every ASUS board I've had in the past several years has given me nothing but problems, so I'd like to try a different brand this time. A fellow worker mentioned a couple of the MSI boards and said they've gotten nice reviews as well. Any other thoughts?
 
Dude i know the other Asus mobos are not really great, but P6T is better mobo then UD5 i got more then 6/7 friends with that board almost non of them had a serious issues,even if Gigabyte is good brand no doubt but they are behind Asus, at least in high end part of the market. Dont trust official reviews!
 
I had issues with both of my UD5s and my P6T. Both were good boards, though.

The P6T went back because it wouldn't sleep properly, ran fairly hot, and wouldn't let me clock higher than about 3.6GHz. The UD5s both let me clock to around 3.9GHz (may have gone higher, but I couldn't put up with them long enough to find out), but both had absolutely an absolutely horrid capacitor whine with an additional unidentified whine duing heavy network load.

Neither will handle a 3 graphics card configuration with a standard case, so if you need that, I believe both EVGA boards do it. Not sure about any others.
 
Thanks MP. I was originally set on buying the UD5, but after hearing about the whine issues with heavy load and network load, it's got me to research something different. Heard anything about X58 MSI boards? I can't seem to find much on them, but reviews I've seen point to great overall.
 
I just bought the gigabyte ud4p, very similar to ud5 just missing 2 sata, second nic, and chipset heatsink, anyway i got it from microcenter and talking with the sales guy, he said they had a lot of P6t returns, 2 currently on clearance rack, they did sell the more of these, he hadn't had a gigabyte 1366 board returns, and hadn't sold a lot of msi yet, but he heard they were solid from the customers that bought them. He didn't think they were great for oc, but that was strictly his opinion not any sales facts.
 
I just bought the gigabyte ud4p, very similar to ud5 just missing 2 sata, second nic, and chipset heatsink, anyway i got it from microcenter and talking with the sales guy, he said they had a lot of P6t returns, 2 currently on clearance rack, they did sell the more of these, he hadn't had a gigabyte 1366 board returns, and hadn't sold a lot of msi yet, but he heard they were solid from the customers that bought them. He didn't think they were great for oc, but that was strictly his opinion not any sales facts.

I've actually heard it was the other way around, more UD5 returns than P6T boards, maybe its just different people have different experiences with them.
 
Practically every brand of x58 board has had its fair share of problems, I just went ahead and grabbed the P6T Deluxe V2
 
Thanks MP. I was originally set on buying the UD5, but after hearing about the whine issues with heavy load and network load, it's got me to research something different. Heard anything about X58 MSI boards? I can't seem to find much on them, but reviews I've seen point to great overall.

I wouldn't write it off entirely. I really did like the board, and had it not been so noisy I probably would have kept it. I don't know how widespread the problem really is. Those that don't have problems with it aren't as likely to say anything as those that do. It may be an isolated incident.

I ended up choosing the evga classified because it will allow me to use three graphics cards, and it's pretty much the only other board that sleeps properly. If you don't want to use three graphics cards, most anything will work. The classified worked out well for me, but I can't really recommend it for many people because of the steep price.

Good luck finding the one that suits you best. The classified is my fifth board in two months. :eek:
 
I did a build with the P6T deluxe and its been a smooth ride. Also if you don't mind the smaller size and don't need all the extra slots then the Rampage II Gene is worth looking at.
 
I should have stated that while microcenter had multiple returns on the p6t they had also sold out of them so there were definitely a lot more sold then the other brands, which would up the chances of returns, also could have been people deciding to go with the evga or such instead, since they were sold out too.
 
I have experience with both the P6T and the P6T deluxe. The P6T does not sleep properly, and it runs fairly hot, but it is good otherwise. The P6T deluxe has better heatsinks and an overall better power design. But in the end, I don't think there is a big difference between the two. They will both handle overclocks to the mid 3ghz if that is your goal. I personally won't buy a new board till the new 8 core I7s come out...

edit...looks like asus posted a bios firmware upgrade that address sleep issues on the p6t.
 
Last edited:
Avoid UD5 kinda hard to oc with it. It cause the tripple boot and resetting to default
(talking about my system) also many users reported that P6T mobos are great.

I have had 0 issues with this board and managed to hit 4GHz easily after just 3 hours of tweaking and testing. No reset to default and no triple boot.
 
I've had no issues with my P6-T Deluxe Rev 1. I was able to get my 920 @ 4Ghz in 15 minutes, tested 8 hours strong in prime. Been using it for months at that speed and never once had an issue. As for the sleep issues others are talking about I wouldn't know I'm trying to kill the earth and leave my pc on all day/night.
 
Related thread hijack: what about the MSI x58 Pro? (I'm waiting on one that I bought from someone else here, didn't find any obvious red flags on a cursory net search...)
 
You know with the P6T Deluxe boards, there is a potential problem, it's depoendant on where you plug your ram sticks. You have to be carefuyl to plug the sticks in the right slots or else the system won't post and won't tell you anything but a blank screen. This could be a good reason why some people encountering this could return their boards thinking it is fauylty, but it is not. I have the V2 board and this occurs also. I didn't know what to do when it happened to me and I called ASUS and they told me where to place the ram on the board (which slots of the 6) for 3 sticks. Anyway, it's one of those "I should have known" type problems.
 
Last edited:
This is an issue common to all X58 systems. If only using 3 of the slots, you have to consult your manual for which ones to populate.
 
Related thread hijack: what about the MSI x58 Pro? (I'm waiting on one that I bought from someone else here, didn't find any obvious red flags on a cursory net search...)

This board does not support SLI, only Crossfire. Same as MSI's X58 Platinum. Now while they do have a "new" X58 Platinum SLI... it's specs mention no SLI support (while there is still a Crossfire Logo prominently displayed!?!). Then again maybe their webmaster is preoccupied, maybe his wife is having a baby... (yeah that sounds like a good excuse! ;)).
 
I hear the Asus P6T Deluxe V2 is a really good i7 board, right now I'm quite torn between the Asus P6T Deluxe V2 and the Gigabyte UD5.

I agree i have both boards, personally i see the the gigabyte being better. But that being said they both are really decent motherboard. MSI isn't really a big brand in my head quality wise. They are better than some but i'd take an asus or a gigabyte any day over it.
 
I didnt like to read this... the UD5/Extreme was my top pick... guess will have to keep looking or get a DFI one....
 
I didnt like to read this... the UD5/Extreme was my top pick... guess will have to keep looking or get a DFI one....

I'm with you on that one doug, I had my mind set strongly on the UD5, but then a friend told me about having issues with it like the loud noises it apparently makes while under load and NIC load (that quite a few users have reported). I been looking for an equal alternative such as the MSI Eclipse, but the price makes me a bit hesitant @ $379 CAD.
 
I'm currently using the Asus P6T deluxe and its definitely a great motherboard. I haven't had any problems oc or anything so far with it.
 
Lots of suggestions here, looking for a board equivalent to the UD5 without a $400+ price tag, under $340 CAD. I've heard all the P6T boards and its variations are great from many people, but I'd like to avoid ASUS this time around.
 
Lots of suggestions here, looking for a board equivalent to the UD5 without a $400+ price tag, under $340 CAD. I've heard all the P6T boards and its variations are great from many people, but I'd like to avoid ASUS this time around.

I can relate to how you feel. I've had experiences in the past that soured me to the Asus brand name... But I really have looked all around, reviews, forums, "customer reviews" from NewEgg (which aren't really reliable... but still can provide some info), and even looking at different manufacturer sites to see what BIOS updates are available for different boards. In the end I guess it was Kyle's review of the P6T that tipped the scale in it's favor.

However, if the P6T doesn't work out, my next choice will be either the MSI X58 Platinum SLI, or the EVGA E758-TR. I feel confident that one of these boards will help me run somewhere near 3.6GHz on an i7 920 CPU, with Air Cooling.

And I say these things, not in order to tell you which board to chose, but to encourage you to do some investigation and make an informed decision of your own. But, Please, let me make one request of you! After you make your decision come back to this thread and let us know how your choice is working. Because, as you might have gathered from my comments above, I might need to go to "plan B" and would value your input in making the decision of what that might be... :)
 
Back
Top