i7 920 to what???? Advice please.

mutant

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 27, 2006
Messages
181
So I have an i7 920 excellent bang for buck over clocked to 3.5 GHz system with 12GB RAM. I am in a field that uses up all available cores 100% without any problem. This system still works ok but I could definitely do with more processing power.

I am planning to relegate the system for secondary duty and build a new up-to-date system with at least 32GB of RAM. My original plan was to move to 8 core single CPU system about now but the way Intel is dragging it's feet it looks like it would be another year before 8 core desktop CPUs come out????

Using multiple Xeons is out of my price range and not what I would consider bang for the buck.

So I am looking at the 6 core CPU but not sure if I should wait for 8 core gear or just get the 6 core version? Is LGA 2011 currently the way to go for power users looking for bang for the buck? What is current equivalent of the HOLY i7 920?

i7 4930K maybe?
 
Its the only option without paying stupid money.

I went from a 920 to a i5 3570 and for general use and gaming its a noticeable improvement. Bloomfield to Ivy is a good step up.
 
Why not the L5639 everyone else have been buying up on eBay. I got one from my i7-950 as it was bottle necking my GPUs in BF4. They go for around $80 and you can use the same motherboard usually.
 
Why not the L5639 everyone else have been buying up on eBay. I got one from my i7-950 as it was bottle necking my GPUs in BF4. They go for around $80 and you can use the same motherboard usually.

This is exactly what I did. Simple OC to 3.4GHz, working great at my minecraft/mumble server. Fair bit more responsive than my 920.
 
L5639 I did not know about this specific chip, 6 core 12 thread, at lowest speed of 2400 on 6 of those cores, nice.

i7-920 to 2500k/2600k or above will be an improvement, not in cores but rather performance boost, though you did mention more cores, so any of the x79 based -E variants might be the way to go for you. There is the option if you have specific motherboard to allow it I know some in the 9xx series could dual cpu. Sandy Bridge-E/Ivy Bridge-E seems the best bet overall at least from my research(for the -E high end anyways) for more cores, some can be terrifically expensive, so 3930/4930 or possibly some Xeon models for the amount of cores, and in the Xeon case, dual cpu lovin.
 
Just to clarify the i7 920 PC will stay as it is. I have another PC case which will get the new hardware ie. new MOBO, new CPU, new RAM, new PSU.

The L5639 is bit old no? I mean L5639 Dual CPU setup= 2 x 6 core @ 2.13GHZ = 25.56 GHz vs i7 4930K 1x 6core @ 3.9GHz? = 23.4GHz. So assuming clock for clock they are similar then L5639 has a slight edge but lot of the stuff I do also requires sometimes fast single thread performance.

So I am used to i7 920 @ 3.5 GHz speed and stepping to L5639 2.13GHz for single thread use is bit of a downgrade.
 
Personally I wouldnt upgrade from a 920 unless your never gonna overclock it, I actually did just upgrade my i7920, but to one of the same X58 HEXACORE Xeons...
 
Just to clarify the i7 920 PC will stay as it is. I have another PC case which will get the new hardware ie. new MOBO, new CPU, new RAM, new PSU.

The L5639 is bit old no? I mean L5639 Dual CPU setup= 2 x 6 core @ 2.13GHZ = 25.56 GHz vs i7 4930K 1x 6core @ 3.9GHz? = 23.4GHz. So assuming clock for clock they are similar then L5639 has a slight edge but lot of the stuff I do also requires sometimes fast single thread performance.

So I am used to i7 920 @ 3.5 GHz speed and stepping to L5639 2.13GHz for single thread use is bit of a downgrade.

yeah but the 4930k is like 600 and you can pick up a x5660 or L5639 for about 200 and 100 respectively, and overclock them to 4ghz + and save a ton of money..
 
yeah but the 4930k is like 600 and you can pick up a x5660 or L5639 for about 200 and 100 respectively, and overclock them to 4ghz + and save a ton of money..

Not in Europe. Unless you mean second hand? All I am finding on local ebay etc equivalent is whole systems with them inside it for upwards of 2-3k. Plus with second hand you don't know what you getting.

Local prices for new.....

Intel Core i7 4930K BOX, 3.4GHz, LGA 2011, 6C/12T -> 579

Intel Xeon X5660
, Socket 1366, 2.8GHz, 12MB, 6C/12T -> 1200
Intel Xeon E5-2620v2 BOX, 2.1GHz, LGA 2011, 6C/12T -> 414
Intel Xeon E5645, Socket 1366, 2.40GHz, 12MB, 6C/12T- > 558
INTEL Xeon X5660 "Gulftown",Socket 1366, 2.80GHz, 6C/12T- ->1180
 
Not in Europe. Unless you mean second hand? All I am finding on local ebay etc equivalent is whole systems with them inside it for upwards of 2-3k. Plus with second hand you don't know what you getting.

Local prices for new.....

Intel Core i7 4930K BOX, 3.4GHz, LGA 2011, 6C/12T -> 579

Intel Xeon X5660
, Socket 1366, 2.8GHz, 12MB, 6C/12T -> 1200
Intel Xeon E5-2620v2 BOX, 2.1GHz, LGA 2011, 6C/12T -> 414
Intel Xeon E5645, Socket 1366, 2.40GHz, 12MB, 6C/12T- > 558
INTEL Xeon X5660 "Gulftown",Socket 1366, 2.80GHz, 6C/12T- ->1180

There are plenty of reputable ebuys to buy a 2nd hand chip cheap, but I understand europe and if you want it brand new.
 
That isn't how you get cpu clock speed. Doesn't matter how many cores or threads it has. It is still one speed period.


The L5639 is a great chip. But if you are going to upgrade then you need to go ahead and get new socket and get caught up. Even a 2600k would be a great upgrade. But you also have a 2500k, a 2700k and a 3770k. I would probably just get 3770k and overclock it a little and call it a day.

Just to clarify the i7 920 PC will stay as it is. I have another PC case which will get the new hardware ie. new MOBO, new CPU, new RAM, new PSU.

The L5639 is bit old no? I mean L5639 Dual CPU setup= 2 x 6 core @ 2.13GHZ = 25.56 GHz vs i7 4930K 1x 6core @ 3.9GHz? = 23.4GHz. So assuming clock for clock they are similar then L5639 has a slight edge but lot of the stuff I do also requires sometimes fast single thread performance.

So I am used to i7 920 @ 3.5 GHz speed and stepping to L5639 2.13GHz for single thread use is bit of a downgrade.
 
The L5639 is bit old no? I mean L5639 Dual CPU setup= 2 x 6 core @ 2.13GHZ = 25.56 GHz vs i7 4930K 1x 6core @ 3.9GHz? = 23.4GHz. So assuming clock for clock they are similar then L5639 has a slight edge but lot of the stuff I do also requires sometimes fast single thread performance.

Remember it would be extremely rare on a desktop system to ever use 24 threads. As a programmer at times I could use that many if I try hard enough but most users it would be never.
 
Last edited:
if you TRULY need lots of cores, why not go for something like 8-core Xeon e5-2680? 3.1ghz all core turbo 8 core 16 thread and they work in most X79 boards. you won't be able to OC, but sounds like you want reliability with whatever you are doing, and OC doesn't always provide that.

there are also e5 v2's with even more cores.

good luck with your search.
 
Remember it would be extremely rare on a desktop system to ever use 24 threads. As a programmer at times I could use that many if I try hard enough but most users it would be never.

I am 3d artist so while rendering maxing out all cores is very easy :D

if you TRULY need lots of cores, why not go for something like 8-core Xeon e5-2680?

For the price of that I could get 2-3 i7 4930Ks and set render nodes. Man if money was pouring in I would get 2x Xeon 8 cores CPUs but.......

Ok I think you all have given me enough food for thought. Will chew over it and see what to get after Christmas.

Thanks for all the help and time ;) Really appreciate it
 
For the price of that I could get 2-3 i7 4930Ks and set render nodes. Man if money was pouring in I would get 2x Xeon 8 cores CPUs but.......


in the states an 8-core 2680 costs less on ebay than a 4930k at retail.

I know things are more scarce/expensive in Europe though, hope you find something that works out better for you :)
 
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Dell-Powere...291948?pt=COMP_EN_Servers&hash=item417a27a1ec

its technically 4 computers but afaik you can do a little render farm, and for more $$$ you can get more ram, I think the guy sells them with up to 192GB of ram for like $1300 or something.

Or you could get a 4770k + mobo

general warning with those c6100's, don't mess with the BIOS. lots of those were cloud servers with custom BIOS and will lose functionality if you flash to the BIOS dell provides on their website.
 
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I went from i7 930 to 4770K and didnt like it so I returned that and got a 4930K been really happy with it so far. DDR3 ram went WAYY up since the last time I bought it for my X58 system. I bought 24GB 6x4GB sticks back then for $150. 8x8GB for 64GB to fill up my X79 board will cost me $600 roughly.
 
I went from a i7 930 4.3GHz (HT Off) to a i7 4770K 4.6GHz (HT On) and it's quite a bit faster. Don't regret the upgrade one bit. Also uses a lot less power.
 
Ok guys so I have made the decision to go with i7 4930k. Over clock it to 4.3 or whatever is safe. Will pick the parts this/next week. Any reason I should wait till January or so? Intel won't shock me by releasing 8 core desktop version suddenly will they?

Can I ask some questions about the other parts I am planning to buy here or do I need a new thread for that?
 
Intel won't shock me by releasing 8 core desktop version suddenly will they?

No. The 8 core on the enthusiast platform will most likely be out in Q4 2014.
 
Ok guys so I have made the decision to go with i7 4930k. Over clock it to 4.3 or whatever is safe. Will pick the parts this/next week. Any reason I should wait till January or so? Intel won't shock me by releasing 8 core desktop version suddenly will they?

Can I ask some questions about the other parts I am planning to buy here or do I need a new thread for that?

I went from a i7 920 @ 4.00Ghz to a i7 4930k @ 4.7Ghz. The difference is noticeable, especially in applications that takes advantage of all the cores and threads.

i792040ghzCPUsinglecore_zps955d7392.png


Complete47ghz_zpsaf96ff54.png
 
Boggins thanks fro that. Which MOBO, PSU, CPU cooler are you using for your i7 4930k @ 4.7Ghz?

My current setup score :rolleyes:

6QF59va.jpg
 
Last edited:
Boggins thanks fro that. Which MOBO, PSU, CPU cooler are you using for your i7 4930k @ 4.7Ghz?

My current setup score :rolleyes:

6QF59va.jpg

Oh. I guess I haven't updated my sig yet.

My i7 4930k is on a ASUS Rampage IV Black Edition, Corsair AX1200 PSU, and cooled on a custom water loop using a EK Supremacy block.
 
Back
Top