i5 / i7 / Q upgrade help & suggestions

utopic

n00b
Joined
Oct 15, 2008
Messages
7
Hello.

After reading a lot of threads regarding differences, advantages and disadvanteges of the new intel processors, I must admit that I still can't make up my mind on what to do.

I'm looking for a gaming configuration and also, I'm not really into overclocking so I will be keeping everything a stock speeds.

Right now I have a Q6600, 2x1GB of ram DDR2 (of course), a BFG GTX295, and an Enermax 1050W PSU.

I was thinking about i7 920 + DFI LANParty UT X58-T3eH8 + 3xCorsair 1600MHz XMS3 DHX (8-8-8-24) - the most expensive component is the mainboard, and the reasoning for choosing that model is that I can more easily upgrade the ram and the cpu but the MB is something I'd hold on to... What should I do?

That was before. Now, after reading more, I've seen advices of upgrading to i5, upgrading to Q9550 or even waiting...
 
If you plan on using Xfire/SLI or if you want to be able to upgrade to Gulftown soon you should go with X58 and an i7 920.

For single-GPU gaming though, i5 750 seems to be the best value for someone upgrading from a Core 2 or similar system, especially if you have a Microcenter near you (sells i7 860 for $229 and i5 750 for $160). The aggressive turbo modes in the Lynnfield quads generally seems to push the i5 750 past the i7 920 at clock speeds in gaming.
 
If you plan on using Xfire/SLI or if you want to be able to upgrade to Gulftown soon you should go with X58 and an i7 920.

For single-GPU gaming though, i5 750 seems to be the best value for someone upgrading from a Core 2 or similar system, especially if you have a Microcenter near you (sells i7 860 for $229 and i5 750 for $160). The aggressive turbo modes in the Lynnfield quads generally seems to push the i5 750 past the i7 920 at clock speeds in gaming.

Foxhound hit it pretty much on the nose. There are some SLI/XFire boards available for the P55, but each channel maxes out at 8x, which as he stated, isn't that great for multi-GPU gaming.

Another advantage an X58 setup would have is utilization of triple channel memory.
 
I think they both made valid points. If you look at the deals thread tho you can get either a MSI GD80 (amazing board) for $180 or an Asus WS P55 for $200 and then pick up an i5 or i7 at microcenter for the previously stated price and have a killer gaming rig for just over $300 (just mobo and cpu). Also, i'd personally wait till the MSI Big Bang makes it's debut and see how good the Lucid Chip really is at scaling.
 
If your concern is gaming I would keep the quad or go to a Q9550, the jump to an i5 isn't worth it seeing as the i5 is slower then the i7 and the i7 actually gets beat in some benchmarks by a core 2 quad clocked at the same speed in gaming, I don't know why everyone forgets this.

Also overclock, I know you said you're not going to, but if you have enough computer knowledge to put together a pc you should be able to up a fsb. If you want to be completely 100% safe just don't up the voltage any and see how far you can get, without it freezing while running benchmarks.

If going sli/crossfire I would go with an i7.
 
for your input.

Given the fact that in the near future I might get a second video card (-> SLI) I'll go with 1366.

I'll let you know how it turns out.
 
@ the OP.

I'm running this board with an i7 920. Just be sure to update your bios (it's easy to do with a USB flash drive) and check the DFI club forums (or read the manual) so you know to populate the right dimm slots when you install this board. It's the heaviest motherboard I've ever owned (has thermalright cooling built right into it), and can handle a 4.0GHz OC 24/7 without any problems for me.
 
I would skip on the DFI board... search xtremesystems regarding their quality and customer service.
 
Back
Top