i need input on an external tv tuner.

I'm also considering acquiring an external tuner. How is the general quality of the external USB-based tuners as opposed to internal ones? In the past some of them got poor reviews and I was wondering if this has improved any.
 
Stay far far away from USB TV Tuners, I've tried three of them - Hauppauge WinTV II, Sabrent USBTV, and Adaptec GameBridge. All have issues with audio/video sync (some lose sync immediately, some after a couple hours of running). They also introduce significant lag so they're useless for game consoles. I would definitely get an internal tuner, and if thats not an option, a standalone tuner.

*EDIT* The one that ashe posted might be OK since it has hardware encoding, but it also costs quite a bit more than comparable internal tuners. Stay away from the cheap USB ones.
 
Lag was one of main concerns, thanks for the confirmation.
 
My sig rig runs XP Media Center and Vista Ultimate 32bit which has Media Center included. I've got three Hauppauge WinTV-USB2 tuners and they've worked pretty much flawlessly for the year and a half I've had them.

If you want to watch and record analog TV, the Hauppuage WinTV-USB2 will should work great for you.
 
We'd tried a KWORLD tuner before, and returned it ASAP. It was...rather crap. Using a Pinnacle tuner, now, on my wife's laptop. Works pretty well okay, keeps A/V sync until you do a few hibernation cycles with the device plugged in. THEN it may fall out of sync in an hour-long program, needing a reboot to clear up.

Only REALLY annoying thing is that the Pinnacle tuner doesn't have an EPG for the US! European countries only! To get program listings in the US, it minimizes and opens an IE window linked to TitanTV.com.
 
Lag was one of main concerns, thanks for the confirmation.

Not sure where lag comes in to play. If you're using them to watch and record TV through some type of HTPC software live Windows Media Center, they record to hard drive first, even in live mode, so that you can play back and pause, so there's the lag.

What purpose were you looking to use the tuners for other than TV?
 
What purpose were you looking to use the tuners for other than TV?
Nothing, not even recording. Simply watching live TV. Keep in mind that I'm nearly always above 50% CPU utilization on a multiprocessor system and pushing close to 100% frequently. My computer is under heavy load most of the time. Furthermore, I use Dscaler exclusively. If you are at all familiar with this app, you have a better idea why the introduction of even a slight amount of additional delay in the system, would be quite noticeable in this environment. I occasionally experience lag with an internal tuner as it is.
 
Not sure where lag comes in to play. If you're using them to watch and record TV through some type of HTPC software live Windows Media Center, they record to hard drive first, even in live mode, so that you can play back and pause, so there's the lag.

What purpose were you looking to use the tuners for other than TV?

They could be used to play console games on the computer display.

I've tried various internal/external tuners and they all introduce lag (internal tuners are tolerable in that regard but still not as fast as a real TV). I finally just bought a monitor that has component inputs and a "real" HDTV tuner (set-top box), pretty happy about it.
 
Then I guess you're not looking for some type of DVR. Really, if you're that concerned about CPU utilization, a good monitor with PIP and an external TV source would be the best bet. No overhead at all with that solution.

I hardly ever watch live TV, most everything I watch it recorded. I read up on DScaler. You use it for capturing external analog sources I presume?
 
Then I guess you're not looking for some type of DVR. Really, if you're that concerned about CPU utilization, a good monitor with PIP and an external TV source would be the best bet. No overhead at all with that solution.

I hardly ever watch live TV, most everything I watch it recorded. I read up on DScaler. You use it for capturing external analog sources I presume?
Actually, I use VDub for that, but Dscaler can accomplish it also with somewhat less alacrity. I am looking at your recommendation in the first paragraph as an alternative solution. Thanks for the suggestion.
 
Back
Top