I need a new computer for college. Yay.

Tonybologna23

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 29, 2002
Messages
214
P4 2.4b is what I have now. I will be going to college in a month and want to fully upgrade my computer with all new everything. So really its not an upgrade, it is just a new computer.

I have about $400 to spend on the CPU and Motherboard and have recently been out of the loop processor wise. What will keep my satisfied for another 2-4 years? I am a light gamer but when I do play I like to play the most high end games. I also plan to stick this system in a Sonata and try to run it on as few fans as possible.

Right now, as I see it, my options are:
P4 2.8c + (and save some $$)
Prescott whatever (I know nothing about new intel chips)
A64 3xxx (I know nothing about AMD)

I am an intel fan right now - have always had a bias against AMD that is based on pretty much nothing. What should I buy for my next system?

note: I am looking to purchase everything by mid-August at the latest.
 
I am also going to college soon an have built a computer to last me hopefully 2-4 years. I went with an AMD 64 3400+ and and a MSI K8N Neo Plat which combined is about $425. I also went with 1 GB of OCZ EL PC -3200, BFG 6800 GT OC, and one 80 GB SATA and one 160 GB SATA. If you want to save a little the AMD 64 3200+ is also a good processor. Hope this helps.
 
here's what I recomend you get(you are building this, right?)

It should keep you satisfied for a while.....

MSI 915 lga775 motherboard w/ pci express, DDR(not 2)
1024mb crucial pc3200 DDR memory
radeon x600XT pci-e
Pentium 4 530 3.0GHz prescott
160gb SATA hdd(they run under $100)
any turtle beach sound card(they're cheaper then audigy) santa cruz is a good one
rest of the stuff is trivial. if you need an RW drive, get one, if you don't, get something else.
 
Tonybologna23 said:
I am an intel fan right now - have always had a bias against AMD that is based on pretty much nothing. What should I buy for my next system?

lol, you should be thanking God for AMD, if it wasnt for their wonderful products we would all be using 500 mhz computers and systems priced at $3500+. Now you can build a great system from 800-2000. Anyone remember the good ol' days where buying a intel 33mhz system with 8 MB ram and 1MB of video ram was the best that money could buy!? :eek: Dont forget windows 3.1 and MSDOS.... i miss DOS! Dont forget the logo "IBM compatable" lol Anyways the days of Intel and IBM monopoly are over and we all welcomed competition :D GO AMD!!

Also, the 754 will be priced lower because it is phased out. 939 is best if you can afford it. You will have some sort of upgrade path and you can even upgrade to a FX processor if you come into alot of money. If you could get 100 more bucks then you could get a 3500+ w/ asus motherboard
 
AMD A64 3000+ or 3200+ Socket 754, for the best performance/price ratio...
 
If you are really planning on keeping this thing more than 2 years, which seems rather unlikely to me unless you are really willing to drop some dough, then what you should really be considering is what operating system will be out. Chances are 64 bit OSs will hit in 2 years max. So you should probably only look at CPUs that will support them (AMD).

That way, you can upgrade to the 64 bit OS and maximize the comp's potential for a while longer.
 
Any chance in the FX dropping price anytime soon? I could see myself purchasing if all i had to do was wait another month. UCLA doesnt start till end of september.
 
Tonybologna23 said:
Anyone remember the good ol' days where buying a intel 33mhz system with 8 MB ram and 1MB of video ram was the best that money could buy!?

Ha those were the days! 1 gig hard drives were $2800, 1 megabyte RAM was $40-$80 depending on which excuse the Asian factories were using for production shortages that month, and before Windows 3.1, there was 3.0, which was so bugridden and slow (and way overpowering for the time's computers) you would go for coffee before you booted up and it'd (hopefully) be done by the time you got back....

I'm waiting a little longer to see how it plays out, if things don't improve with Intel soon enough on the performance/heat issues, I might even jump to AMD this round and get the fastest of whats available in the next few months to hold me over for the next couple of cores. Also, I'd like to see what Intel's response to the Athlon 64 is, and how prevalent 64-bit Windows and apps become.

Remember folks, the first 32-bit processor, the 80386, was released in 1985.....almost 20 YEARS ago!! Hard to believe the 32-bit world we are in now was started so long ago, especially with all the evolution since then like GHz clock speeds, DDR, and near-terabyte hard drives. It took years for 32-bit apps and OSs to catch on after the 386, and while I'm sure it won't take as long this time, I'm not worrying about 64-bits for my next CPU. But the FX-53 is lookin sweet...maybe, just maybe...
 
darktiger said:
AMD A64 3000+ or 3200+ Socket 754, for the best performance/price ratio...

Didn't he say this:

I am an intel fan right now - have always had a bias against AMD that is based on pretty much nothing.
 
jen4950 said:
Didn't he say this:

And what that means is that I am willing to go AMD if I can be convinced....and since my biased against AMD is based on nothing more than the fact that I have had intel for the last 6 years, it should be easy to do.
 
Well it all depends on your situation

If you want a small space heater for the winter, then i would get a prescott

If you, like it has already been said in this thread, want the best performance for your dollar then i would probably get an A64 3200+
 
i vote for the 3200+ (and it over the 3000+ it's cash for cache :))
it's more future-proof, i know nothing is future-proof, but if you want to be some-what more prepared then, i would say go for the 3200+. Even if its cache doesn't have a large impact now, i'm sure it will when new OS's w/ more overhead (i.e., like Langhorn) come out.
 
Alright after consulting many people...its seems like the thing to do is a semi upgrade and just get a P4 "c" and hold onto it until pci express becomes more refined and newer intel chips (possible 64 bit) come around.

So now its step two: ive decided to go this middle route, I want to get a 2.4c, motherboard, 1gb of dual channel - what "budget" (i use this loosely) components should I get. I am mainly tlaking about motherboard, but also RAM. I was thinking an ABIT IC series. thoughts?

I can get the cpu for $160, so If i can get the motherboard and RAM for under ~$340, that would be awesome.
 
What's the point of getting a 2.4C when you have a 2.4B? Sure, there's the FSB difference, but your current processor is pretty much up to snuff with stuff out right now, it's just not 'extreme' or bleeding edge. If you want to make it last, you can even OC the 2.4B - they have been known to hit 3000+ Mhz.

Is your current comp not satisfying you?
 
BillLeeLee said:
What's the point of getting a 2.4C when you have a 2.4B? Sure, there's the FSB difference, but your current processor is pretty much up to snuff with stuff out right now, it's just not 'extreme' or bleeding edge. If you want to make it last, you can even OC the 2.4B - they have been known to hit 3000+ Mhz.

Is your current comp not satisfying you?

it does staisfy me and prolly will for another few months, but i want to use my existing system as a file server for home when i go away to college. basically i need a new system. (no old systems laying around)
 
Why not dump the money you have for a new system into a high interest account for 6 months and re-evaluate then? The system you have now will be fine for college (Depending on the university, most students might not even HAVE computers). All you really need it for is word processing and maybe programming if you are in cs, and a 2.4 Ghz machine will be fine. It will also be fine for gaming, as you dont have much room to go for a faster processor. Id seriosly consider not upgrading just because you are going to college and wait until you NEED to upgrade. You might be able to make a few bucks in interest off your computer funds and buy a case of beer to celebrate your new computer ;)
 
Tonybologna23 said:
it does staisfy me and prolly will for another few months, but i want to use my existing system as a file server for home when i go away to college. basically i need a new system. (no old systems laying around)

there is no point "upgrading" to a 2.4C from what you already have
If you want a true increase in performance then get a P4EE or an A64

If the only reason you are upgrading is to use your old one as a file server, then that is also pointless
Depending on what exactly your "file server" is going to.. well.. serve, you don't really need a 2.4 P4 in it
If you want a server then build a server, it will be a lot cheaper
 
AMD T-type said:
there is no point "upgrading" to a 2.4C from what you already have
If you want a true increase in performance then get a P4EE or an A64

If the only reason you are upgrading is to use your old one as a file server, then that is also pointless
Depending on what exactly your "file server" is going to.. well.. serve, you don't really need a 2.4 P4 in it
If you want a server then build a server, it will be a lot cheaper

One thing I forgot to mention was that I was given some nice SATA hd's that I want to put in the system i take to collge but that would require upgrading the motherboard or doing some pci thing.

What if i buy a board for $100 that supports 400mhz/533mhz/800mhz, stick my existing 2.4b in it, then use my old board and buy the cheapest p4 I can find and use that for the file server?

edit: The cheapest p4 i can find is still only 30 bucks cheaper than a 2.4c
edit2: vvvvv I forgot about the celeron :)
 
That would work, you could drop a celeron in there and a small stick of ram and be good to go.
 
darktiger said:
AMD A64 3000+ or 3200+ Socket 754, for the best performance/price ratio...

jen4950 said:
Didn't he say this: I am an intel fan right now - have always had a bias against AMD that is based on pretty much nothing


Doesnt change the fact that he is right. A64 3000+ and 754 is best price/performance.
 
I built myself a computer for college for 1000 bux, and find that it is still more than adequate. I have the 2.4, which i think is fine, but here's what i have:

Abis IS7 motherboard. I would reccomend just about nay 865 motherboard from Abit or Asus, as they have good quality and have the PAT enabled. PAT is a performance enhancing technology that intel designed for the 875's, but these company's found a way to get it on the 865's which are a good bit cheaper.

Processer: IMO the 2.8 has the best price performance ratio.

Ram: 1 gig of PC3500. By going with 3500 you give youself some oc'ing potential and will easily be able to keep the cas low.

Radeon 9700 - I know its a last-gen graphics card, but its still damn fast and more than adequate IMO.

--------------
Now, personally, if you have a 2.4 already and are on a limited budget, i would keep the setup you have and just upgrade the graphics card, ram, HD, Monitor, and IO devices. You're not going to get far with a new computer on 400 bux. I would either upgrade my current rig, or save up for a year and get a new computer next year. Right now, IMO 64bit is not where it should be, unless you're a linux person in which case you're in good standing. Well, thats my $2e-2.
 
Back
Top