I need a 2 drive external (maybe even NAS)

Kil4Thril

2[H]4U
Joined
Sep 21, 2003
Messages
2,974
I want something that will hold at least a pair of 500gb drives to hold my digi cam movies/pictures, and then RAID 1 so there is an instant backup. If this can be done in a compact, decent looking NAS, all the better.

Also, if I MUST go to 4 drive capacity, then doing the same thing for my MP3's wouldn't bother me in any way. I can connect via eSATA, USB, or 1394, or straight to my router (DLink DGL 4300- if that matters at all).
 
RAID isn't backup. What you've described would be better running two separate disks so you're protected against accidental deletions or any other myriad of software/OS based problems that may manifest itself into lost data, such as corrupt file structure or whatever. Even though there's a bit more work to be done by hand by keeping backups of your backups on two different, physical and logical hard disks, you wouldn't have to worry about any kind of accidental deletion or whatnot.

Hell, if you keep it up to date enough to your satisfaction, even one of the drives failing wouldn't result in lost data, which is what RAID is for - protection against hard disk failure and uptime.
 
Ok, I thought I could do a kind of RAID (I know it ain't 0, that's spanned) that would basically mirror 2 drives. Is there any way to set this up so I get a couple storage drives AND a couple automatically mirrored backups? That's what I need anyway, so I want to do it correctly. If I lose the vids/pics of my son, the wife will have Guido break my kneecaps :D
 
You're thinking of RAID1 - Mirrored. RAID 0 (Stripe) offers no data redundancy while RAID 1 is pretty much a byte-for-byte real-time copy of the data on your logical drive.

Wikipedia has a great article on RAID, but please try to understand my previous post that RAID 1 might not be quite what you're looking for. If your pictures and data is that important to you, you should also realize the value of backing up your data through DVDs or a second external hard drive, rather than to work with RAID 1, though convenient, wouldn't protect you against RAID controller failure or accidental deletions or data corruption.
 
You're thinking of RAID1 - Mirrored. RAID 0 (Stripe) offers no data redundancy while RAID 1 is pretty much a byte-for-byte real-time copy of the data on your logical drive.

Wikipedia has a great article on RAID, but please try to understand my previous post that RAID 1 might not be quite what you're looking for. If your pictures and data is that important to you, you should also realize the value of backing up your data through DVDs or a second external hard drive, rather than to work with RAID 1, though convenient, wouldn't protect you against RAID controller failure or accidental deletions or data corruption.

Oh, I will still keep incremental backups on DVD. The RAID mirror will actually give me the redundant drives I'm seeking, though? Basically, if I remove a drive, I can place either one in a different machine and have instant access to all my stuff?
 
RAID1 will allow you to loose a HDD without loosing the data. Not sure about being able to pull the drive out and having access to it. I think that is based on how the drives are setup (software/hardware controller, etc...) I'm sure someone here can answer that though.

 
Oh, I will still keep incremental backups on DVD. The RAID mirror will actually give me the redundant drives I'm seeking, though? Basically, if I remove a drive, I can place either one in a different machine and have instant access to all my stuff?

I don't think you can just pull out a drive, plug it into another computer, and start using it. I'm pretty sure you need to have a similar RAID controller on the computer you put it in because you'll be using it as if one of the drives had failed.
 
Looks like I'll need to look at a simpler multi-disk enclosure and something more software-based.
 
Back
Top