I love Asus and hate MSI

Joined
Jan 15, 2005
Messages
7
But friends are telling me that the 64 bit MSI boards are ace. Since the K8V-X I got won't work AT ALL, I figure I might try a different brand. What's so nice about the 64 bit MSI boards? All the MSI's I've had in the past have been nothing but problematic. Or maybe it's just me...
 
Its just you, ive had 3 in the last 6months that all work flawlessly.
 
I haven't used ASUS since my P2B went up in smoke, never did figure out why. The replacement I purchased was MSI and it worked fine. I've been using them ever since with no problems. Thats 30-40 machines with ZERO MB failures. I don't buy cutting edge or bottom of the line boards and don't overclock (much) so I'm pretty dang happy with em! :cool:

As Always YMMV
 
I tend to shy away from asus due to problems long ago. Back in the P2 days? they had some issue with their AGP slot not supplying enough voltage to riva128 or tnt? cards. Was a long time ago, so a little fuzzy on the issue. Been strictly ABIT since then. Decided to buy a ASUS A8N recently, shipping it back for RMA today. Can't say I'm real happy with most of my ASUS purchases.
 
I use DFI, I had a problem a few months with my DDR controller catching fire but the RMA was painless and quick. Its the only problem I've had with this board.
Unlike the force to Beta driver use I keep hearing with Asus users.

A note on the DFI RMA is to keep your original receipt. I do that with all my equipment (just stample it to the manual), but DFI was the only company i remember needed a copy of my receipt to honor an RMA.
 
Just like anything else, I think every person has one or two brands they have had horrid luck with. Although this is the second time I've had to sit around and wait for newer BIOSes on an ASUS board, this is also the second time I was unwise enough to play early adapter with an ASUS board, so thus (mostly) don't blame them. I guess I did finally learn that ASUS IMO does have a tendency to push stuff out to be the first on the market, even if a bit wonky, it's worth it to wait a month or two for one or two other manufacturers to produce something, then pick a board.

Otherwise, don't mind ASUS, just don't think I'll play beta tester with them again. ;)

For me, my bad brand, the one I'd never buy is Chaintech. Know too many people, in person and online who's had bad Chaintech boards. Having said that, I know they have their fans too, and plenty of people like their stuff. But even if I won a Chaintech board, I'd sell it on eBay or see if whom I won it from would let me trade it for something else of equal value. I wouldn't even use it for a system build to sell, I'd be too afraid of passing a bad motherboard onto someone else. But again, that's just me, plenty of people seem to like Chaintech apparently.
 
The past five major builds I've done for myself and others have used MSI boards. Every one of those boards has been rock solid, and I've used S370, Socket A (both VIA and nVidia chipsets) and now Socket 939. My current K8N Neo 2 has been great, if you want to overclock you'll have to tweak around with the BIOS settings some, but it has been solid. I chose it because of its features and layout, and I haven't been disappointed.

If you're super-picky, read up on some of the posts in forums regarding this board. There are things to keep in mind (most of which happen with other nForce3 boards too, but not all), such as SATA ports 3/4 being locked but not ports 1/2 (most nForce3 boards are like this) and that the board undervolts Winchester CPU's a bit (mine ran stable undervolted; I did up the voltage when overclocking, and it is entirely possible to manually set the voltage the way you want). Also keep in mind that you'll probably only want to use two memory sockets for best stability, and choose your RAM accordingly.
 
oh dammit, meanieman i just read your post and realized how big of a moron I am. The firewire headers on my dfi lanparty nf2 ultra b caught on fire a couple of months ago and I never thought of trying to rma it. Instead I just threw it out thinking that it was a lost cause because it was probably my psu that caused the fire. I wish I had asked around before throwing it out :(.
 
I've never had any problems with 4 MSI boards. I've also never had any problems with any Asus baords... I've used a whole spectrum of them too from A7N8X series, A7V8X series, P4S800 series, P4P800 series, and P4C800 series.
 
Why not just get an Asus A8V if you're worried about it? I'm plenty happy with mine.

I'm also not a fan of MSI after I had two of their board die. I'm sure they're alright, but I just had bad luck with them.
 
I've owned probably 15 Asus boards myself at the very least. To name a few, the P2B, the P2L97, the P3C2000, the CUSL2-C, the CUBX, the CUBX-L, the P4B266, the P4B533-E Deluxe, the P4C800-Deluxe, the P4P800 Deluxe. All of which were great boards. Never ONCE did one die on me of needed to be RMA'ed or exchanged.

I've had tons of other boards too. Intel, Soyo, DFI, Azza, QDI, MTech, Abit, AOpen. I've had a few others that I can't remember, but the brand that never failed was always Asus. NEVER any problems.

The brand I've had the worst luck with is Abit. I've had problems with the BX6 Rev 2, (x2) the BH6, the BE6, the KT7-RAID and the KT7-A RAID. The only board I ever had from them that was solid was the BP6. It was a badass board.

After the KT7-A RAID I never went back. Too many issues.

I've been a professional computer tech at one place or another for over 8 years now and I have serviced thousands of PC's. , sometimes in IT, sometimes as a bench tech. Now I do both. I replace so many MSI's it isn't even funny. I also see alot of Gigabyte's and ECS boards that are total junk.

To give you an idea the Comp USA BTO computers have MSI boards in them because they are cheap. I replace a shit load of them. I have better luck with BTO's that were built around ECS boards. No joke. But I will say the bulk of the MSI's I have to replace are for the Pentium 4 platform. For some reason MSI makes a better A64 board than a P4 board. Alot of companies are the reverse. If you've got a board with an Intel chipset it's hard to screw that up. Somehow though MSI does.

I've had tons of bad luck with EpoX and Soyo is the worst. I'll NEVER own another Soyo and I feel sorry for anyone who does.

I think the A8N-SLi was rushed to market and therefore there are some issues with it. Not to mention driver issues concerning games and SLi itself. I think alot of people are having problems with the combination of the two. Early adopters often have to fight with crap like this. But I wouldn't say that Asus is a bad brand. If I ever go to an A64 it will be with an Asus board. I simply don't trust too many other manufacturers.
 
Owned all sorts of boards, and the only one I've had a problem with is my Epox 8kha+ - the board's caps musta went out, cause it was trying to draw waaaay too much power through the ATX connector, and it melted. Hawt. Every other board i've had has been a dream to work with (Except the stupid nForce2 IGP chipset, eff that) - Soyo, Asus, MSI, Biostar - they've all been rock solid, even this A8N-SLI Deluxe - worked just damn peachy out of the box on a 20pin ATX PSU - no problems at all. Was very surprised that I didn't have a single issue with this nForce 4 platform.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
I've been a professional computer tech at one place or another for over 8 years now and I have serviced thousands of PC's. , sometimes in IT, sometimes as a bench tech. Now I do both. I replace so many MSI's it isn't even funny. I also see alot of Gigabyte's and ECS boards that are total junk.
.

I lost a giga-byte after about 6 months. Never went back. It was their first dual bios board. The marketing hype on that stuff was a bunch of crap.
 
It scares me that a company thinks they need two BIOS chips. Because one can't be trusted? There have been BIOS recovery options on higher end boards and brands for YEARS before that dual BIOS BS.
 
MeanieMan said:
I lost a giga-byte after about 6 months. Never went back. It was their first dual bios board. The marketing hype on that stuff was a bunch of crap.

I had one of those. The stupid thing had a checksum error, and decided to copy the bios from one chip to the other. I think I restarted and the same thing happened, but this time it didn't restart anymore. Mind you this wasn't an overclocked system or anything. I exchanged it for an epox board and didn't have any problems.
 
Your going to get a bad board now and then with every brand. Sometimes its just the luck of the draw because the same board might crap out on you and work incredible for someone else.

MSI, ASUS, and Gigabyte are three of the top motherboard manufacturers in the world. All three companies put out rock solid boards. Gigabyte is one of the best for stability and features while MSI is usually at the top in the performance area. Right now the MSI K8N Neo2 Platinum is one of the best overclocking boards for the socket 939 platform.
 
well, i've had plenty of asus board and they have always been stable.. however out of the few msi boards me and my friend had they all died after a year or so. from my memory it was the VIA kt133 chipset, and all 3 of them we had died with the same problem, which many ppl also had on the MSI forum, so no more MSI for me.
 
I've only ever owned one MSI board (a K7T266 Pro), but the thing is absolutely bulletproof. The thing is just about ancient at this point (it's still running a 1.2 T-Bird OC'd to 1.33GHz) but I've had the thing running in one system or another for 4+ years now without any trouble. It did have a capacitor fall off early on, but that never had any effect on it.

I haven't used an Asus board in quite a while (last one I used had a K6-2 400 CPU) so I can't vouch for their recent offerings. Most of my boards have been Abit. I did have one KT7-RAID go bad (probably got done in by the cheap PSU) and I recently got a DOA AV8. Other than that, they've worked pretty well. They're picky about PSUs, but you shouldn't be using cheap PSUs anyway, right?
 
I have several systems sitting here with MSI boards, 1 I have never had a problem with and another I had to RMA, but it wasn't the motherboards fault it died. Had a faulty video card that decided to take out the motherboard with it. Other than that I have had nothing but good luck.

I did have a few bad experiences with Asus. This is what I have noticed about most brand of motherboards, and this is the same with just about anything else. You get what you pay for. Buy a $50 motherboard and you are going to get that $50 motherboard. Spend $200 or more and you will get a quality product.

Alot of my friends laugh at me for spending that kind of cash just on the motherboard, then again there is a reason I get better scores on benchmarks and overall preformance.
 
I just went from a asus a8v to a msi neo2 about 2 weeks ago. If u want stable and reliable go asus if u want max OC then get msi. This damn msi has had SO many stupid bugs that its not even funny. But i had to buy it to use TCCD ram at high fsb speeds! :p
 
For me it isn't the board dying that makes me have an opinion about the manufacturer, rather it is how the manufacturer handles the problem.
 
The A8N-SLI board I finally got to try this past weekend was DOA. The vendor only honors exchanges 15 days after the pruchase, so I missed it by a week. I submitted to ASUS for an RMA a few days ago, but I have yet to hear from them. I borrowed my firend's for now, since he does not have his cards, so I know it is definitely the board. Looks like they have a two week turn around on the RMA as well. Now that sucks.

I think all vendors have their issues at times. ASUS, MSI, etc are really no different. It's all about bad luck, sometimes.
 
Back
Top