I have 2 Core2Duos. What do I do now?

stain.

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Sep 17, 2006
Messages
1,045
I have an e6600 and an e6420 in my posession. I only have 1 PC, and I don't have the funds to build another one at the moment. I WOULD like to sell either chip and get something more usefull like a better PSU or GPU. Possibly funds for an Xbox360.

What would you do if you were in my shoes?

**facts**
e6600 has been OC'd and used for about a year.
6420 hasn't been OC'd and was used for 3 months or less.

Now I don't really care which one I'd keep, but they both are rock solid at the stock speeds. I've had the e6600 up to 3.51ghz stable.
 
one word "PCMARK2005" theres your answer

both cpus should last a fair few years yet.... I dont think 3mths vs 12mths is really an issue

why did you buy the e6420???
 
Selotape them both together and overclock the e6420 to e6600 speeds and you have yourself a q6600 :p

Seriosly as the above poster said just use some benchmarking software to make your decision. Choose the one with the most points per mhz.
 
Average lifespan is 10 years for a CPU, so, 3 months, 12 months, even overclocked... barely scratching the surface, dude.

The E6600 is a more powerful processor by a noticeable margin, across the board. Obviously it's the one to keep. Simple.
 
Average lifespan is 10 years for a CPU, so, 3 months, 12 months, even overclocked... barely scratching the surface, dude.

The E6600 is a more powerful processor by a noticeable margin, across the board. Obviously it's the one to keep. Simple.

I'm running an E6420 so I've obviously got something of a vested interest here, but other than the different multipliers -- 8x on the E6420 vs. 9x on the E6600 I believe... it's the exact same chip. That hardly qualifies as "far more powerful" considering most enthusiast level motherboard can pull high enough FSB that cooling and vcore become the limiting factor with either chip -- assuming the RAM can keep up, of course.
 
... That hardly qualifies as "far more powerful" ...

Sorry, perhaps you simply missed what I said, so I'll quote myself:

The E6600 is a more powerful processor by a noticeable margin, across the board. Obviously it's the one to keep. Simple.

I increased the font size and bolded the text so as not to be misquoted or taken out of context a second time. I didn't say "far more powerful," I said "more powerful," big difference there, bub.

The E6600 vs the E6420 gives about a 6-10% difference in favor of the E6600 across the board at stock speeds. Sure you can overclock like mad with both of 'em and proper cooling, but even so, at the basic stock speeds, the E6600 is the better processor. Anyone that says otherwise has a few screws loose.
 
First up, I wasn't accusatory or nasty in my post, I was asking a question and expected it to be answered in a similar way. No need to get bent out of shape.

Secondly, nobody gives about stock speed around here, and you know it.
 
Well they both have 4Mb of L2, so they're basically equal chips.

only difference:
e6600 has up to 9x multi available
e6420 has up to 8x multi available

The best answer is to try them both out and see which one overclocks better.

But if already know the e6600 does 3.5Ghz, thats a pretty damn impressive overclock that I doubt the e6420 will beat.

You could just drop in the e6420 first and see what type of overclock you get. If you're close to 3.5Ghz, then you'll be there with a faster FSB, so you're doing just as well at say like 3.4Ghz (8x425Mhz). Also you'd need the mobo up to 440 FSB to hit 3.5Ghz with the e6420 (kind of high FSB and hard on the mobo).

Or you can look at it as the e6600 is more valuable if you sell it. So sell it and just hope the e6420 does at least 3.2+Ghz for 8x400+.
 
Back
Top