i got my 6800gt, but....

Devilpup

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Sep 4, 2002
Messages
2,047
i noticed a few things during this last upgrade round, so i'll illustrate.

system 1 - shuttle sn41g2, axp 2500+, 1gb corsair ddr, r9800pro
system 2 - shuttle sn85g4, a64 3400+, 1gb corsair ddr, r9800pro
system 3 - shuttle sn85g4, a64 3400+, 1gb corsair ddr, 6800gt

ok now when benchmarking using 3dm2k1 i got
sys 1 ~ 14000
sys 2 ~ 20000
sys 3 ~ 22000

so when running older type games it seems like a 9800pro is good enough and a cpu upgrade will do well.

when benching 3dm 2k3 i got
sys 1 ~ 5100
sys 2 ~ 5300
sys 3 ~ 10400

so when running the newer games it seems like they are not cpu bound but gpu bound instead.

playing morrowind, making a run through balmora @ 1600 x 1200 w/ 4xaa & 16xaf i got
sys 1 ~ 15-25
sys 2 ~ 30-40
sys 3 ~ 40-50

so playing morrowind, the gpu and cpu upgrades seemed to work out around the same.

so it would seem like if you're playing slightly older games then using a 9800pro will remain a good investment. if you're playing newer games then a gpu upgrade will do much better than a cpu upgrade, so even running a slower cpu you'll be fine in getting a new card.

overall i'm glad i upgraded everything, now i can quit adding things to my wish lists for a while.
 
Devilpup said:
so it would seem like if you're playing slightly older games then using a 9800pro will remain a good investment.

New vidcard = Better for your new games and old games
Old Vidcard = Better for your old games

This is like a universal constant

edit: Watch someone come along and argue with this just for the sake of argument :rolleyes: if theres one annoying thing about these forums its that! :p
 
Techx said:
New vidcard = Better for your new games and old games
Old Vidcard = Better for your old games

This is like a universal constant

edit: Watch someone come along and argue with this just for the sake of argument :rolleyes: if theres one annoying thing about these forums its that! :p

actually nothing says $400 like quake 1 on a 6800gt!
 
Actually, how does Quake 1 run on the 6800GT? It would be interesting to see how high the FPS skyrockets there.

Not only that, but play it with that graphics patch (that gives it particles/shadows/blah.)
 
Maulenstein said:
Actually, how does Quake 1 run on the 6800GT? It would be interesting to see how high the FPS skyrockets there.

Not only that, but play it with that graphics patch (that gives it particles/shadows/blah.)


dunno but i ran a quake 2 timedemo maxed out on my x800pro. and got over 400fps in the the crusher demo with aa/af maximized.
 
3dmark 2k1 and Morrowind are both primarily CPU dependent and that is why you didn't see any huge gains. Morrowinds performance is up to the CPU and RAM.

Try some more benchmarks in actual games that are GPU limited instead.
 
what i meant was that if you already have a 9800pro or better and don't play the latest high-end games then it's really not worth spending the extra $400 right now to upgrade vid cards. upgrading the cpu/mem/platform is still a good investment because it benefits more than just games, and in the case that you have a 9800pro (or better) and play slightly older games then you'll get a good boost.

and my CoD framerates @ 1600x1200 w/ 4xaa and 16xaf are about the same as they were with the 9800pro, so i don't know what more to say there. i never tried far cry on the ati card so CoD was probably the most advanced game i tried. Max Payne 2, Morrowind, CoD, Raven Shield, all played fine using the a64 3400+ & 9800pro combo at that resolution & aa/af.

point being that unless you're a benchmark junkie, or somehow have a bootleg copy of D3, then if you have a 9800pro you're probably fine gaming wise.

the other point is that a 6800GT will run just fine oc'd to 421/1140 (haven't tried higher) in a shuttle w/ 240w psu also running: a64 3400+, 1gb (2 x 512) ddr, audigy 2, dvdrw, 2 x 250gb hdd. this is in addition to powering an external usb card reader.

my opinion, like it or not, is that if you're not playing the latest games @ high-res then a cpu upgrade is more beneficial than a gpu upgrade if you already have a 9800pro.
 
Back
Top