I don't think I understand computers anymore.

finalgt

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Aug 3, 2002
Messages
5,506
So I was tinkering around with my AN-M2, clearing the CMOS settings because of the CPU Safe Mode bug in the BIOS, when, without thinking, I removed the CMOS battery - without unplugging the PSU first. Well, shit. There goes $80, I thought. I turned the power off, put the battery back in, and tried booting the system - nothing. Pretty much what I figured. Hoping against hope, I removed the CPU and the RAM, all expansion cards, and tried building the system up. Pressed the power button...no joy. Alright, so I have a motherboard to RMA to the Egg.

However, I started to think that maybe it was the PSU that got shorted, because I was still getting a Power indicator LED on the motherboard, it just wasn't turning on. So, I unplugged the PSU from the motherboard and shorted out the motherboard power signal pins (4 & 5, for those who don't know the trick) to see if the PSU would turn on, and lo and behold, it did. Okay, so I just have a fried motherboard. For the hell of it, I removed the pin short, plugged the PSU back into the motherboard, and pressed the power button, expecting nothing. ...instead, I get a normal system bootup routine with no errors on POST, and I sit here typing this on aforementioned machine. How the hell could this have possibly have fixed my problem?
 
I've had power outages that required me to clear CMOS or remove a stick of RAM. Now I have a backup UPS so I don't worry about that.

But, it did happen once that I just let my backup computer off for a long while then it booted up successfully. Maybe the PSU needs to be fully drained sometimes.

I'm not sure either.
 
My guess?

It was either a coincidence or you inadvertently knocked something loose when you were pulling the battery...

But, like I said that's just a guess....and on a side note.. I have removed the cmos battery with the psu plugged in more than once and never had a problem.... maybe I'm just lucky, but I haven't had any problems....
 
there were gremlins in your computer and they decided to give you a good scare by messing with your hardware:D :D
 
I've never heard this "Unplug PSU before pulling out CMOS battery" thing before, but I'm glad I read this for future reference. Now I don't have to make the fatal accident if it ever comes to this situation.
 
I believe as long as your PSU is plugged in and the hard power switch on the PSU is on, it is still providing power to the CMOS. If you buggered up your CMOS by pulling the battery before disconnecting the PSU, then leaving the PSU connected afterward would just help it retain whatever buggy config data it had. You have to completely separate all power sources from the motherboard to really clear the CMOS in most cases.
 
Why would you EVER remove the CMOS battery? Most motherboards have a jumper designed to reset the CMOS, and the CMOS battery will last longer than your motherboard.
 
because simply resetting the bios with a jumper does not always work; occasionally removing the CMOS batt and letting the board sit a few minutes will force a true reset.

it's like resetting the BIOS defaults after a flash. sure, generally it is entirely unnecessary - but in some instances it can save a lot of headaches.
 
I believe as long as your PSU is plugged in and the hard power switch on the PSU is on, it is still providing power to the CMOS. If you buggered up your CMOS by pulling the battery before disconnecting the PSU, then leaving the PSU connected afterward would just help it retain whatever buggy config data it had. You have to completely separate all power sources from the motherboard to really clear the CMOS in most cases.

Definitely.
 
Why would you EVER remove the CMOS battery? Most motherboards have a jumper designed to reset the CMOS, and the CMOS battery will last longer than your motherboard.

Because I cant be bothered to find the jumper.
 
Back
Top