I don't know which to get! (another ATi vs. nVidia thread)

Bop

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Oct 1, 2003
Messages
3,428
I'm really stuck deciding between Crossfire X1900XTXs with an ASUS A8R32-MVP Deluxe and SLi eVGA 7900GTX superclocked cards with an MSI K8N Diamond Plus.

The 7900GTX is slightly faster, but how much faster is it with optimizations off?(I ALWAYS turn the optimizations off, my 7800GTXs shimmering was apparent on my 22" NEC CRT)

The X1900XTX has HDR+AA and HQ AF with overall better IQ. These cards appear to have a lower minimum framerate than the 7900s however. I just can't stand it when my framerate dips below 35fps.

I've been going through many reviews looking at every detail and I still can't make up my mind! I don't want to buy $1400 worth of hardware and regret it.
 
Personaly I would go with the X1900XTX.
I cant tell you for sure what type of hits the 7900GTX takes when turning Opts off but from every thing I have seen it wont be a tiny 1% like ATis HQAF.
 
I forgot to add this, with the X1900XTX do I have to buy just two X1900XTXs or do I need one of them to be a master card?
 
You need a master card for crossfire, but I would still get a X1900XT as it is a much more feature rich solution with superior IQ.
 
One of them has to be the Master card. I will also go with the X1900XTX. IMO, the features just sound better. Remember this is my opnion not yours, and not trying to start a flamefest here.
 
I'll be going with the x1900XTX. Same speed, better IQ, better feature set, It doesn't need optimizations to keep up, and imo better drivers.
 
There releasing a new mobo for crossfire that dont need a master card look into that as well
 
Suposedly by the Cat 6.5 (May) ATi will enable Dongless Crossfire for all their boards. Something to that tune, I know that the cat 6.5s have something special.
 
Shinryu said:
There releasing a new mobo for crossfire that dont need a master card look into that as well

Anyone know the name of this mobo?

I'm a bit dissapointed with ATi's OpenGL performance, I hope they improve it in time for Prey.

They did fix the 60hz issue with crossfire right?
 
60hz Issue is fixed.
The new mobo is the RD580 in stores ATM I believe.
Trust me with Cross Fire or SLi Open GL performance wont be an issue.
 
Ok, I am pretty much sold on ATi at this point :)

How well does the XTX OC on air? I know they run hot so I'm not getting my hopes up.

I've been looking at the A8R32-MVP reviews and I can't see anywhere that says no crossfire edition card is needed. Are you absolutely shure? I don't want to end up buying two XTX cards and end up having to return one :p
 
Back
Top