I cant decide CPU vs GPU

pain.angel

Gawd
Joined
May 6, 2005
Messages
525
Alright it comes down to this, tax time is coming. I have a pretty old rig, 2 years + now, and it has served me well but its starting to suck. I get to pick one of these options to upgrade and I'm not sure which to choose.

My Current Rig:
P4 3.4ghz Prescott 550
Albatron 915P Pro Mobo
2x512 DDR 400 Corsair Value
EVGA 7600GT
400w XCLIO PSU

(Obviously more junk in there but these are the parts up for replacement)

I want to run everything at my lcd's natvie res of 1680x1050. So in this hand I'm thinking 8800GTS and a PSU:

eVGA 640-P2-N821-AR GeForce 8800GTS 640MB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814130071

(Fortron Source) FSP700-80GLC ATX12V/ EPS12V 700W SLi
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16817104023 FSP Group


THE OTHER OPTION:
In the other hand I need a new cpu (which requires mobo, cpu, and ram):

E6400 (This will be the 6420 if it comes out in time)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16819115004

ASUS P5N-E SLI LGA 775 NVIDIA nForce 650i
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16813131142

G.SKILL 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820231087



The most important things to consider are I want to play at 1680x1050 in my games (CSS, Supreme Commander, whatever else I pickup this year) and get decent frame rates and playability. The Core2 Board has to be upgradable to a quad in the future. One of the main things Im wondering is wether or not the 8800GTS is gonig to be bottlenecked to death by the 3.4ghz Prescott or not.
 
ur cpu will bottleneck if u just buy the GTS, and u wont need such a monster PSU for it either... :)

the best options imo would be a 500W psu,8800GTS, E6300 with a mobo decent for overclocking (asus p5b or p5b-e plus maybe?), and some RAM
 
i would say get the cpu stuff and the PSU aswell. later when the r600 comes out in a month or two (whenever it is) you can save up for that and not have wasted money on a "too small" PSU.
 
At the resolution you're playing at? Definately the 8800GTS, no questions asked.

Will the Prescott bottleneck it? Yes in some cases, but your 7600GT just doesn't cut it at that resolution.

Upgrade your processor later, as needed, but it's not that big of a deal.

Edit: Supreme commander will be bottlenecked by the CPU, and CSS is as well... Those are just about the most CPU intensive games out there. You will definatley want to go with a dual/quad core Core2 once SupCom comes out.
 
CPU and GPU are one in the same. If one is underperforming then the other pays for it.
 
the cpu is bottlenecking right now. on my amd 64 3200+ stock clocks, 7600gt, 512mb corsair ram, biostar tforce 939 matx, i can run cs s at 1280x1040 all highs around 60 fps, no lower then 40 unless lots of smoke and explosions.
 
I'd wait on the GPU. The mainstream 8X00 parts are on the horizon. You really can't go wrong with a Core 2 at this point.
 
Your CPU isn't great, but the video card will gain you the most performance for your dollar in games right now.
 
At the resolution you're playing at? Definately the 8800GTS, no questions asked.

Will the Prescott bottleneck it? Yes in some cases, but your 7600GT just doesn't cut it at that resolution.

Upgrade your processor later, as needed, but it's not that big of a deal.

Edit: Supreme commander will be bottlenecked by the CPU, and CSS is as well... Those are just about the most CPU intensive games out there. You will definatley want to go with a dual/quad core Core2 once SupCom comes out.

Your CPU isn't great, but the video card will gain you the most performance for your dollar in games right now.

This is what I'm looking for, mostly an increase in fps for now. I'd really like to just skip a 2 core and go for the 4 core if I can get decent frame rates until the mainstream quad cores become available. Wanting to skip to quad core is also the reason I opted for the hefty PSU.

I'd like to pass on waiting for a lower end 8 series as well and push for the higher end for a little better performance so I can carry it over to the new cpu if I go for the GPU. I bought this 7600gt a few months ago and now its not cutting it so I'd like to avoid that happening again.

Also, to the first reply, buying all of it is not an option. I need to say under $1000, as far under as possible, this has to be run by the significant other yet and that can be touch and go.
 
go with cpu upgrade wait for the R600 to come out and we should see some price drops for the 8800GTX
 
This is what I'm looking for, mostly an increase in fps for now. I'd really like to just skip a 2 core and go for the 4 core if I can get decent frame rates until the mainstream quad cores become available. Wanting to skip to quad core is also the reason I opted for the hefty PSU.

I'd like to pass on waiting for a lower end 8 series as well and push for the higher end for a little better performance so I can carry it over to the new cpu if I go for the GPU. I bought this 7600gt a few months ago and now its not cutting it so I'd like to avoid that happening again.

Also, to the first reply, buying all of it is not an option. I need to say under $1000, as far under as possible, this has to be run by the significant other yet and that can be touch and go.

I guess the other question is:

What kind of settings are you running/expecting to run? If you like to run 4xAA/8xAF or something similar, your first choice (8800GTS/GTX + nice PSU) is going to be the best option. If you don't run AA or AF right now, and are unsatisfied with your FPS, then it might not be the video card (SupCom and large CSS games are more dependant on CPU power then most other games today).
 
I guess the other question is:

What kind of settings are you running/expecting to run? If you like to run 4xAA/8xAF or something similar, your first choice (8800GTS/GTX + nice PSU) is going to be the best option. If you don't run AA or AF right now, and are unsatisfied with your FPS, then it might not be the video card (SupCom and large CSS games are more dependant on CPU power then most other games today).

Typically I run AA off since the resolution is high enouph i dont notice *much* aliasing. I do like to run atleast 4x AF though.
I think I might be able to squeeze in a Core2Duo if I drop the vid card to a 7950GT and drop the power supply. However, will my 400w XCLIO psu be up to the task of powering the system and will I be able to run lets say medium settings at 1680x1050. I dont need balls to the wall IQ just decent frame rates. Should also mention I have no plans to upgrade to Vista any time soon so DX10 support is not a consideration.
 
Back
Top