I cant decide between 2 video cards

Tough call. When both cards are overclocked though it's probably neck and neck.
 
It's killing me because I think they are fairly close as well. One has a higher Cpu clock and more memory. The other has a little faster memory clock?
 
It's killing me because I think they are fairly close as well. One has a higher Cpu clock and more memory. The other has a little faster memory clock?
the 8600gt is easily faster in most games. core speed doesnt mean a whole lot when you are comparing two completely different architectures. also 512mb on a slow midrange card wont help a damn thing.
 
I'd rather get an X1950pro or 7900gs if you're not using the cards for any special HD content..... these cards sucks @ gaming for their price tbh.
 
I don't think you should get any of those cards even if you do plan on using it for DX10 games in the future. Just get a fast DX9 card for gaming now or wait in till the second gen of DX10 cards come out. I remember seeing terrible performance for the 8800 GTX in DX10 so I just cancel my EVGA 8800 GTX order. It could be bad driver's for the card but it's also first gen DX10 card.
 
I don't think you should get any of those cards even if you do plan on using it for DX10 games in the future. Just get a fast DX9 card for gaming now or wait in till the second gen of DX10 cards come out. I remember seeing terrible performance for the 8800 GTX in DX10 so I just cancel my EVGA 8800 GTX order. It could be bad driver's for the card but it's also first gen DX10 card.

You're a moron. The card performs beautifully.. it's the GAME that has a bunch of extra features in DX10 only that slow framerates down (i.e. COH DX10). This means your comparing DX10 performance to DX9 performance is apples to oranges. Crysis and Bioshock and Lost Planet all perform at great framerates on GTX.

You also fail to remember that a high end DX10 card is also the fastest DX9 card...

God I hate people who spew misinformation.
 
You're a moron. The card performs beautifully.. it's the GAME that has a bunch of extra features in DX10 only that slow framerates down (i.e. COH DX10). This means your comparing DX10 performance to DX9 performance is apples to oranges. Crysis and Bioshock and Lost Planet all perform at great framerates on GTX.

You also fail to remember that a high end DX10 card is also the fastest DX9 card...

God I hate people who spew misinformation.

It's called new users. You were once a new user just as I.
 
Yea but did you spew stuff like that as fact or trying to be informative?

Per OP, its a toss honestly.

the 8600GT is better at gaming, keeping the lead on the 2600XT in terms of performance and eye candy

on the other hand the 2600XT for HD and content viewing is alot better too, for all around needs and functions I would say buy the 2600XT as it is still decent for gaming and gives you just about everything else.
 
I need a little help deciding between 2 video cards. I need to decide which one is better for games, applications, watching my musci videos and applications. Here's the two video cards specs. Please be very descriptive. Thanks for the help.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127286

and

http://www.newegg.com/product/product.asp?item=N82E16814127298

In games, the 8600 GT is better overall. In video decoding, the HD 2600 XT has the edge. In any other application, they are both essentially the same. Decide what you'll do more and pick the one that suits your needs. If it's gaming, get the 8600 GT, if it's video decoding, get the HD 2600 XT.
Also, if you end up choosing the HD 2600 XT, do NOT buy the 512 MB model. You're paying extra, for something that won't give you any noticeable increase in performance, as was already mentioned.
 
You're a moron.

that's a little harsh man!

though it's yet to be seen and i'm pretty optimistic, his speculation about craptacular performance has as much validity as our speculation about the 8800 being perfectly able to drive dx10 games at high resolutions.

however, since the op presented a choice of an 8600 or a 2600, how did this coversation even end up with the 8800 being recommended? :p

i don't think one would start a thread like this to hear again the merits of the high end video card segment, but there i go, thinkin again.


personally, i'm in agreement with a previous suggestion pointing towards a late-model nvidia 7-series or an ati x1950 of some kind, but given the original choice of cards i would choose the 8600gt.
 
You're a moron. The card performs beautifully.. it's the GAME that has a bunch of extra features in DX10 only that slow framerates down (i.e. COH DX10). This means your comparing DX10 performance to DX9 performance is apples to oranges. Crysis and Bioshock and Lost Planet all perform at great framerates on GTX.

You also fail to remember that a high end DX10 card is also the fastest DX9 card...

God I hate people who spew misinformation.

well, I still don't know about the "card performs beautifully" part. It's DX9 equivalent card is cheaper than it and runs just as fast, minus the DX10 support. And if you can get your hands on a 7900GS for 100 dollars, who's the moron? the guy who bought the faster card or they guy who settled on a slower card but has more tech? I'd take the raw speed since we don't have real DX10 games yet and all the DX9 patched to DX10 games are all buggy. Put some money down, but don't spend too much for now and save up for a high end later so you can run all the DX10 games you want a high settings when a lot of bugs have been worked out.

but that's just me. I was hoping that these DX10 cards would perform a little better than their equivalent DX9 cards in DX9//DX10 games, but they all seem to just use DX10 as a marketing tool right now.
 
Thankyou! I found the information given to be very useful. Especially the break down of what these two cards do best.
 
You're a moron. The card performs beautifully.. it's the GAME that has a bunch of extra features in DX10 only that slow framerates down (i.e. COH DX10). This means your comparing DX10 performance to DX9 performance is apples to oranges. Crysis and Bioshock and Lost Planet all perform at great framerates on GTX.

Where have you seen benchmarks with any card with Bioshock ?
I have been looking and have found nothing but vague previews.
 
In games, the 8600 GT is better overall. In video decoding, the HD 2600 XT has the edge. In any other application, they are both essentially the same. Decide what you'll do more and pick the one that suits your needs. If it's gaming, get the 8600 GT, if it's video decoding, get the HD 2600 XT.
Also, if you end up choosing the HD 2600 XT, do NOT buy the 512 MB model. You're paying extra, for something that won't give you any noticeable increase in performance, as was already mentioned.

I agree with this sage advice, as well as those who counsel the merits of a last-gen card like the X1950 Pro.
 
What can the 8600Gt be compared to on DX9?

Performance wise, something like a 7800 GTX 256, in most cases. But the 8600 GT, will be superior in shader intensive games and, of course, video decoding.
 
I also agree with Silus, his advice is sound. Another idea to throw out there ... pay $15 more and get an 8600GTS. There is an ECS 8600GTS down around $120 now if you can find it in stock anywhere. The 8600GTS is roughly 20% - 25% faster for gaming than the 8600GT, plus it is HDCP compliant and supports PurevideoHD. Since you are looking for an all around card and may want to do some things with high definition video in the future, these features may be important.
 
you cant find that card ECS card. Heck, I've even tried calling ECS about it and they wont return my calls about it.

Wanted it from newegg, settled for the $100 7900GS from Frys. Not going to pay a lot for a video card right now.
 
Back
Top