I am SOOO Confused Need Help

Arkanian

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Feb 8, 2004
Messages
1,898
I am SOOO Confused Need Help
Ok so here is the deal I am purchasing some new equipment on March 13th. Orginally Here is what I was going to purchase:

Athlon 64 3200+
Asus KV-8 Deluxe
Corsair XMS 3200 (2x512)
Antec True 480

Now I have been thinking of changing it too:

Pentium 4 3.2
Asus P4C800-E Deluxe
OCZ PC4000 (2x256)
Zalman Copper CPU Cooler
Antec True 480

I know that with the P4 i Can overclock to at least 250FSB with a 1:1 divider. The Athlon 64 can't overclock worth a flip. The Pentium 4 chipset is more mature than the Athlon 64 but.. The Athlon 64 does edge out the P4 just a little in gaming. Will I be able to tell the difference between to 2? What do you guys think. Oh BTW I am using all of my componets in my sig.
 
if ur going to overclock the pentium 4, go ahead buy it, but buy one with HT or Extrmeme edition one, they ALMOST match up to the 64bit processor. if i am wrong plz correct me
 
Originally posted by xdviper
if ur going to overclock the pentium 4, go ahead buy it, but buy one with HT or Extrmeme edition one, they ALMOST match up to the 64bit processor. if i am wrong plz correct me

64 bit processor is a waste of money, it'll be at least a year to year and a half before full-scale 64 bit support is out. the windows 64bit beta showed a 10-50% DECREASE in gaming performance.

all p4 C's have HT, so thats fine. the EE is a grand, so if you wanna spend that much on just a processor, go for it.

I'd just recommend a p4 like 3.0C or maybe a step higher.
 
Just OC a P4 3.0Ghz/3.2Ghz C.. You won't really notice that much of a difference...
 
Rofl

3.0c hitting 250 fsb... on what air.... gl
water-maybe
prommie2-yes

But if you have the money for a prommie2, you see the 3dmark 01 of a amd 3200+ at like 3.1 ghz- over 30K

A64's are a way to go and defently, with the 1 gig of ram.... itll tear up the p4. The a64 3200+ is a great proc. I dont know much about them sides the VIA chipset is better than the nforce3.

Also though if your getting 512 on the intel so you can get a 9800pro, but the a64 your getting a 9600Pro

Then get the intel, but IMO 1 gig of ram is what you need

EDIT: read sig: 9800Pro

w3rd save your money and wait for prescott to introduce and prove itslef... your sys is fine
 
I would suggest getting the Intel system with 1 gig of ram and overclock it.
 
I still wanna see how on air you can put a 3.2C with a 250 mhz fsb

Id say get a 2.8c and youd have a much better chance and youd have enough money for 1 gig of ram maybe
 
Originally posted by Cloud15x
Rofl

3.0c hitting 250 fsb... on what air.... gl
water-maybe
prommie2-yes

But if you have the money for a prommie2, you see the 3dmark 01 of a amd 3200+ at like 3.1 ghz- over 30K

A64's are a way to go and defently, with the 1 gig of ram.... itll tear up the p4. The a64 3200+ is a great proc. I dont know much about them sides the VIA chipset is better than the nforce3.

Also though if your getting 512 on the intel so you can get a 9800pro, but the a64 your getting a 9600Pro

Then get the intel, but IMO 1 gig of ram is what you need

EDIT: read sig: 9800Pro

w3rd save your money and wait for prescott to introduce and prove itslef... your sys is fine

How is that not feasible for a FSB overclock?

As you do, I have a P4 2.4c and on stock cooling, I have been running completely stable at 250, even 260 ran stable for a good while.

Personally, I'd agree and opt for the Pentium 4's. You honestly won't notice much of a difference in performance between the Athlon64. Plus, it's quite a lot cheaper since it's a more mature chipset and technology.

Dark Assassin
 
thanks guys for all you inputs. I probably get the Pentium 4 but alot can change here in 1 month. Cost wise the difference between the 2 is like 20 dollars favoring the Athlon 64. Man this is a HARD decision. Yeah teh P4 is more mature considering the chipset. Also, the Athlon 64 does beat it in gaming but not by much. The ONLY game where the Athlon blows out the P4 is UT2003. The botmatch benchmark I'll get like 80 fps with the P4 vs like 90-100 with the Athlon. Yeah I probably get the P4. Just don't know because I am like reading all these benchmarks because I want the P4 to convince me that I should go with the P4.
 
Im just saying 4ghz on air is a little insain.... i dont thing 3.2c's will hit that on air less that 50C

as for mine... im running at 3.2 which besides the fsb is intels fastest proc speed

edit: as for now my sig is wrong... 263 fsb
 
Without benchmarks, I doubt you'd ever be able to tell any difference between the 2 stock for stock.

If you want to OC, go with the Intel.
 
Ok I am 100% sure about going P4. The only place where Athlon shines is in games and is only slightly better than P4. I wont notice the difference playing games. Oh also when you turn the settings up to MAX the fps between the P4 and Athlon are the same because it is more GPU intensive. Oh also for the people questioning the 250 overclock. 250*16=3.7 gig. with DDR400 I can run a 5:4 divder with FSB at 250. The only problewms I forsee is maybe heat. I mean I can back off until 3.5 gig and probably run it 24/7. I have seen many people in my dorm hall running this confige on stock coolers with stock thernal pad. granted at full load it reaches 60 degress Celsius but isn't that bad.
 
Originally posted by themustafa
64 bit processor is a waste of money, it'll be at least a year to year and a half before full-scale 64 bit support is out. the windows 64bit beta showed a 10-50% DECREASE in gaming performance.

all p4 C's have HT, so thats fine. the EE is a grand, so if you wanna spend that much on just a processor, go for it.

I'd just recommend a p4 like 3.0C or maybe a step higher.

Who cares if it has 64bit support or not? It performs great in 32bit code NOW.

And, btw, performance dropped in the BETA OS because there were no solid, shipping quality drivers for anything. BETA = BETA performance.
 
You could go either way however bear in mind the addition costs surronund the aA64 includeing the neceessity of ECC memory and a chipset that suffers from some memory compatibility problems.

I will say this you will have alot less headaches with setup and configuration with the Intel platform. You could be up and running within an hour of your components arriving.

The A64 will be a crapshoot mobo to mobo as far as your choice of memory.

http://www6.tomshardware.com/motherboard/20040112/index.html
 
i dunno which way i would go, considering both CPU manufactures are going to a different socket this year....therefor future growth for his system might be limited by that.....


i vote P4 though!
 
P4 EE at 3.4 for 200 bucks in about 6 months will be a fitting end to this socket. I will take full advantage then move to Prescott once the 4ghz this time next year becomes affordable and snce all the bugs of pciE would be worked out by then , a next generation video card should make a nice gift under the tree next DEc
 
Originally posted by jacuzz1
P4 EE at 3.4 for 200 bucks in about 6 months will be a fitting end to this socket. I will take full advantage then move to Prescott once the 4ghz this time next year becomes affordable and snce all the bugs of pciE would be worked out by then , a next generation video card should make a nice gift under the tree next DEc

man.. i really think its gonna take a LOT longer for that chip to go down to $200...
 
Originally posted by jacuzz1
You could go either way however bear in mind the addition costs surronund the aA64 includeing the neceessity of ECC memory and a chipset that suffers from some memory compatibility problems.

I will say this you will have alot less headaches with setup and configuration with the Intel platform. You could be up and running within an hour of your components arriving.

The A64 will be a crapshoot mobo to mobo as far as your choice of memory.

http://www6.tomshardware.com/motherboard/20040112/index.html

and the a64 does not use ecc.

furthermore... dont read tomshardware..
 
Back
Top