I am getting very angry. Please, help.

Could a CPU cause any problem with RAM? I wouldn't think so, since (correct me if I'm wrong) the motherboard is the one who, during POST, tests the RAM to see if it's good.

Originally posted by lopoetve
Right. That job happens to be as a software engineer for the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR). I'm recoding Fortran 77 models of Actinic Flux and Photospectroscipy for a project that will be flying on a NASA B-57 this summer, and for a project that is currently in operation on the polar ice-cap in Greenland (http://summit.unh.edu/ , our guy there is Barry Lefer).

PWNED! I don't even understand half that terminology. :D
 
I just remembered an incident with an Athlon 700 and a Tekram board I had... Thanks for reminding me, lorcani.

In this case, a bad board killed the CPU. The dead CPU then killed the RAM in a new replacement board, resulting in a VERY frustrating set of seemingly random problems.

I'd RMA the whole set. It took us 3 computers to find the issue then, and that was by sheer luck. Especially since the RAM would take 2-3 days to die, and the CPU would ~sorta~ work for that time (BSOD during windows install, etc, but sometimes it would go fine). When we replaced the CPU and the RAM, and kept the second mobo (the one we got from RMA), it all started working fine. But we went through three sets of RAM in the meantime, and even bought a third motherboard.
 
Yeah, I've heard of things like that happening. I'd follow Iopoetve's suggestion and just RMA everything back. Then, you can eliminate any possible problems with a whole new set of the hardware.
 
Originally posted by Zardoz
In my experience, Intel can have problems just as AMD, or anybody else for that matter. Your comment "Intel for stability" does not help in anyway as he can still have problems even if he did switch. AMD cpus and chipset have been proven thru the years, and a comment like this does not stand for anything but hogwash.

I was stating for Intel CPU's, Intel motherboards are the most stable, not Intel is more stable than AMD. I'm an AMD guy, I mean look at my rig. I was telling him that an Intel motherboard is rock solid stable for intel cpu's.
 
Hmm I never knew there was compatibality issues with 222 special and max3,

I bought about 5 months ago max3 and mushkin 3500 222 special and It could barely install windows, I got so pissed off I rma everything and bought what was in my SIG and everything worked good. This made me afraid to go with Intel again.
 
Originally posted by emorphien
You're right, he murdered that word. :)

I'm a programmer, not an english major. I know I murdered it. I didn't care enough :p

The point was made either way, though ;)
 
Originally posted by emorphien
Good lord would you read the thread so you don't perpetuate the stupid fights.

He said amongst Pentium 4 motherboards, Intel were the most stable, which is generally true. Will you have trouble with others? Probably not, my Abit is fine, but Intels are rock solid. Just don't plan any overclocking with them.


Who is fighting here? I thought this was a discussion, but as for "Intel manufacture motherboards" being the most stable among other non Intel manufacture (but using Intel chipsets) I would agree. but this is not what it's about. It's about Intel boards being more stable then AMD boards, and not Intel manufacture ones, but in general. The general comment "Intel for stability" does not come off to well when just left with that. In general I would have to disagree.
 
Originally posted by Lime
I was stating for Intel CPU's, Intel motherboards are the most stable, not Intel is more stable than AMD. I'm an AMD guy, I mean look at my rig. I was telling him that an Intel motherboard is rock solid stable for intel cpu's.

In that case I would agree, you have no argument here...
 
Does AMD manufacturer motherboards for their chips like Intel does? It would make sense, but I've never seen or heard of anyone using them.
 
Originally posted by lorcani
Does AMD manufacturer motherboards for their chips like Intel does? It would make sense, but I've never seen or heard of anyone using them.

Don't think so. They leave it to third parties.
 
Originally posted by 4keatimj
Don't think so. They leave it to third parties.

AMD should make them. IIRC, Intel has a huge portion of the market with their boards. Then again, Intel created all the chipsets they use on their boards, while the AMD crowd is mostly split with nForce and VIA.
 
AMD ~used~ to. They made 3 of note:

1. AMD 750 Irongate. Didn't like Geforce cards. First chipset for the Athlon. BAD.
2. AMD 760. First DDR chipset. Fastest for a LONG time (till the KT266A). Great chipset.
3. AMD 761. ONLY AthlonMP chipset :)


Each had a reference board, but they weren't anything of note.
 
Originally posted by HitMan-sC
Phoenix: I've tested all of my memory in my AMD machine. All except the one Corsair stick was stable in my AMD machine, but they failed Memtest in the IC7, although the other Corsair stick ran it just fine. The power supply, video card, sound card, TV card, hard drives and optical drives have all been tested. I'm almost certain it's not the processor. I've posted on the Abit and Mushkin forums and followed plenty of advice before I RMA'd. I upped the voltage to 2.8v, as I was instructed to on the forums, and tried running Memtest. I've solved a few other problems I had with the board. It now appears that Abit has some problems with particular Mushkin and Corsair RAM. I've called Abit numerous times. I had other problems with my wireless networking equipment, which I RMA'd after spending hours on the phone with netgear. It has been a month since I first ordered the parts. I believe I have a right to be just a tad bit frustrated and impatient, so don't tell me I overreacted and blew up for no reason. Good day, sir.
Well, it helps us when we have more complete info, if you choose to leave out steps that you performed in your post, don't blame me for pointing that out. I'm not Miss Cleo and this isn't the Psychic friends network. OK, so you didn't overreact, you just didn't give us the whole picture. It's not much difference to me, I don't really care, just trying to help, even if it's just to say calm down...

Back to your issue, RAM problems are caused by RAM->board->power supply->CPU in order of likelyness to caues issues. There are known issues with that board and specific RAM, as you are now aware. If you did test all that RAM in another, working system then my dollar is on the board or powersupply killing the ram. I'd bet mobo over PS.
 
The power supply tester I bought verifies that all power going to the motherboard is clean. Just in case, I RMA'd the motherboard and the RAM and I've decided to go with the Asus P4C800-E, but I don't know which RAM. In case it IS the processor, I just realized I have a spare P4 I salvaged from a Dell with a bad power supply. It's an old Williamette, but I'm pretty sure it's still good.
 
Originally posted by lopoetve
2. AMD 760. First DDR chipset. Fastest for a LONG time (till the KT266A). Great chipset.

2. AMD 760. First DDR chipset. Fastest for a LONG time (till the KT266A). Great chipset.

Incorrect, it was far from "fastest", but it was OK, and it had its problems as well.
 
Originally posted by Cows Milk Thrown @ U
2. AMD 760. First DDR chipset. Fastest for a LONG time (till the KT266A). Great chipset.

Incorrect, it was far from "fastest", but it was OK, and it had its problems as well.

Your correct, in fact that was when ddr was just a marketing gimick the chips back then did not take full advantage of the extra bandwidth
 
Originally posted by Cows Milk Thrown @ U
2. AMD 760. First DDR chipset. Fastest for a LONG time (till the KT266A). Great chipset.

Incorrect, it was far from "fastest", but it was OK, and it had its problems as well.

Wrong. It was the fastest DDR chipset for AMD untill Via came out with the KT266A and SIS actually started shipping the SIS 735. The other alternatives at the time, the ALi Magick and the KT266, were slower by a noticable margin.

From Anandtech: http://www.anandtech.com/chipsets/showdoc.html?i=1451&p=2

As we found out in our latest Socket-A Chipset Comparison, the AMD 760 chipset is actually a very impressive chipset. AMD has come a long way since the days of the AMD 640 (which was actually the VIA VP2 in disguise) to the point where they are a very capable chipset designer even though they still refuse to take the next step to become a manufacturer as well.

Luckily, from a performance and feature set standpoint there aren't any problems with the AMD 760 chipset. If you'll remember the 760's predecessor, the AMD 750 chipset, not only did it not offer support for PC133 SDRAM but it also had numerous AGP performance issues under Windows NT. The 750 did not support AGP 4X, however we all know the usefulness of that over AGP 2X in real world situations.


Comparo with 266A
http://www.anandtech.com/chipsets/showdoc.html?i=1528&p=5
http://www.anandtech.com/chipsets/showdoc.html?i=1528&p=6
http://www.anandtech.com/chipsets/showdoc.html?i=1528&p=7
http://www.anandtech.com/chipsets/showdoc.html?i=1528&p=10
http://www.anandtech.com/chipsets/showdoc.html?i=1528&p=9

The original KT266:
http://www.anandtech.com/chipsets/showdoc.html?i=1451&p=6

I don't think I need to show you the rest of the results (hit the next button on the review), but the KT266 and the ALi Magick boards got OWNED.

The only problem with the 760 was the price of the boards. It took a 6 layer PCB, so it cost more. It was also low volume.

You all need to redo your research. The 760 was a GREAT chipset that had NO major problems other than cost and limited supply. It was the fastest at the time, and stayed that way for a good long (almost 6 months) time.

From the perspective of the true enthusiast, the AMD 760 is still and will probably continue to be the highest performing Socket-A chipset platform for a decent amount of time. You shouldn't be too worried about a lack of support for the chipset, especially since the 760MP is just around the corner and will also require much of the same driver support that the current 760 does meaning that there is very little chance of AMD pulling support on the product.
http://www.anandtech.com/chipsets/showdoc.html?i=1451&p=17

The KT266 had issues fixed later, but there were still performance problems till the A revision.
http://www.anandtech.com/chipsets/showdoc.html?i=1455&p=13

So, what Chipsets did you think were better for AMD DDR early on, anyway? My point stands. At the beginning of the DDR revolution, the 760 was the fastest chipset available, and was for a good while.

Have a nice day...
 
Originally posted by jacuzz1
Your correct, in fact that was when ddr was just a marketing gimick the chips back then did not take full advantage of the extra bandwidth

But they DID get a boost, and you both are still wrong.
 
Back
Top