HTPC vs. Upsampling DVD Player

BrianBoyko

n00b
Joined
May 8, 2008
Messages
11
Quick question: I've got my HTPC hooked up to my LCD 46" 1080p HDTV via DVI-->HDMI cable. Would buying an upsampling DVD player provide any better experience than simply playing the DVD on the HTPC?
 
umm..I am not an expert...and someone else correct me if I am wrong. I think the HTPC would be best. The image is going to be stretched, no matter how you look at it. The only thing questionable here is audio I suppose. I would use that money to buy a bluray LITE-ON drive from newegg, so that you CAN watch movies at their native resolution.
 
if you setup ffdshow correctly then it would be as good or better than most upsampling DVD drives.


check out AVS forum for proper FFdshow setup
 
cmon cubbies! 7-4 were climin back late!!!!

i would think an htpc could scale better, but as said most people don't setup the codecs and stuff...
 
I've looked online at the configuration I'd need to do for FFdshow. It's probably better, but upsampling DVD players are as little as $40. The way I figure it, if it takes more than 2 hours of work, I'd be better off buying the upsampling DVD player. :)
 
I've looked online at the configuration I'd need to do for FFdshow. It's probably better, but upsampling DVD players are as little as $40. The way I figure it, if it takes more than 2 hours of work, I'd be better off buying the upsampling DVD player. :)
 
I picked up a upscaling dvd player because it runs much cooler, is quieter and as a bonus it talks to my tv with HDMI-CEC so the tv remote controls & turns on/off the dvd player. I think the samsung i got was around $80.


That and my black levels/color space weren't quite right from my pc :)
 
I vote for the player. Over the years I've been to hell and back with every HTPC configuration imaginable and it's never worth it unless you *like* tweaking that crap all the time. Me? I just want to watch the freaking movie, not resolve software conflicts and driver update problems.

However, not all upscaling players are made the same. Prepare to spend from $200-500 for a good one, don't expect the world from a $99 budget player.
 
Why is this a concern? Does your TV have a craptacular built-in scaler?

A $40 "upscaling" DVD player isn't going to do anything for your movies unless your TV has absolute crap scaling capabilities. It certainly won't look better than an HTPC, even one without any configuration tweaks.
 
Back
Top