HTPC Antivirus recommendations

LittleKing

n00b
Joined
Jun 20, 2004
Messages
39
I tried searching but didn't find an answer, so I apologize if this has been asked before.

I received all my HTPC parts, installed vista, installed updates, and have been enjoying all the aspects of getting it setup to use, but I'm trying to determine which anti virus program to use on the machine. I've been using the Avast free edition for our main PCs, but wanted to know if there is a general thought on a good antivirus program for HTPC. The HTPC won't experience a lot of web use.
 
honestly, i know some people will disagree, but I have been able to avoid virus infections with just using good judgment and web based email. I don't run any on mine, but the only sites I go to are hardware sites for driver updates, windows update, and sage forums.
 
I agree with IDversusEGO. If its not going to be touching the web alot then you probably don't need an anti-virus. If its behind a router/hardware firewall, its even better.

However, I will suggest NOD32 Anti-virus if you still want to get one. You have to pay for it, but its an EXCELLENT program thats extremely quiet and fast. Perfect for an HTPC.
 
I use Symantec Corporate on mine. You can pretty much control every aspect of it so you won't get random background crap that causes you lag.
 
I can understand the logic behind the idea of no av. However, I have to disagree a bit, because while my HTPC may not be online, other computers will be. The HTPC will have open shares and with other in the household online a virus can easily spread from their PC to the HTPC.
 
I have none of mine, but there all used for TV/Music/Movies/TVShows only, so none of them ever get used for webbrowsing (other than inside of VMC). Windows firewall/defender will do a good enough job, i cant see any reason to get anything else installed.
 
I can understand the logic behind the idea of no av. However, I have to disagree a bit, because while my HTPC may not be online, other computers will be. The HTPC will have open shares and with other in the household online a virus can easily spread from their PC to the HTPC.

I dont run AV on any of mine. I use the same logic for all of my PCs. but I tend to pay for my software and pron, not open emails from strangers, and only go to trusted established sites.
 
I use Avast..free and updates like crazy..never an issue with any of my systems. I also have the Avast Windows Home Server Edition and it manages all of my PC's within the WHS Console...love it!
 
I use AVG free on all my computers, works great!

AVG is good if you have enough horsepower to push past its horrible overhead. If you are running even a "moderate" machine, it tends to start showing up. It is even worse if you are the type of person to shut down yoru PC when not in use.
 
running Symantec on my mine, doesn't seem to affect performance at all. i personally wouldn't run a pc with out av on it, and i still follow common sense when surfing
 
I don't have any antivirus software on my HTPC. I had AVG on there for a while and it worked fine, but ultimately I realized that since the system stands by itself and only accesses the internet for updated schedules (SageTV) or windows updates that it didn't serve any purpose.

I occasionally play a game on it but even then there's no need for a virus scanner. If I was doing regular web browsing/e-mail I'd probably put AVG back on it; as it stands it's just another program that wouldn't be used.

If shared directories are a concern, you can always just share them and make them read-only.
 
I dont run AV on any of mine. I use the same logic for all of my PCs. but I tend to pay for my software and pron, not open emails from strangers, and only go to trusted established sites.
Hope those 'trusted established sites' don't get hacked, and that someone doesn't find the next big internet worm that will nail you even if you're not downloading from dodgy sites.

I've sworn by NOD32 for a while now, and while I can count on one hand all the times I've had it pop up over a detected virus over the last couple years, I know better than to think "it can't happen to me." More worryingly, I don't want any home machine to become a gateway or prospective bridge to my actually important work PCs.

When the negg has NOD32 for $20 again, I'd say buy it. I've had misses and false-positives with the freebies.
 
I use Avast free home edition on all my systems. It seems to keep my systems clean and seems pretty easy on the system usage as well...and since it's free, the price is right. Been using it for about 3 years now.
 
Only problem with clamwin is you have to manually scan the files you want to check, there isnt any automatic virus checking of every file that gets accessed, like most virus killers do. So in someways its pointless as by the time its found a virus (you have done the manual scan) then its already caused havoc or wrecked your files etc. Of course this is still better than no antivirus at all, if you schedule it to check every so often.

I know they were creating an on-access scanner, but not aware that its out yet........if it is ignore this post :)
 
I use Symantec Corporate on mine. You can pretty much control every aspect of it so you won't get random background crap that causes you lag.

I'm guessing you haven't messed with 11 then yet.

Anyway I agree with the others that say that it is networked so it should have protection. Personaly I like eset and kaspersky. I know better then to think it can't happen to me. Every windows machine runs av and every linux machine has dection in place to try to help avoid hijacks or worms.
 
Haven't had any problems with Symantec Corp 11. I have had it on my test rig for the past few months and it's fine. Can't even tell it's running.
 
Haven't had any problems with Symantec Corp 11. I have had it on my test rig for the past few months and it's fine. Can't even tell it's running.

Corporate Edition is one thing (It has its' problems too), but Norton Anti-Virus in general (for the desktop & consumer market) is a piece of flaming shit and absolutely not worth the money.
 
I use Symantec Corporate on mine. You can pretty much control every aspect of it so you won't get random background crap that causes you lag.


just be aware it doesnt work very well...so long as you are happy with that, go for it...LOL

seriously, our entire company dropped them (thats a LOT of money Symantec lost) on all our PC's and laptops because it simply lets things through (you wont know they got through unless you scan with something else).....just like Windows Defender...it never shows anything found...even though there might be somethign there...., even when updated fully, things that other programs like AVG Free would stop......not to mention Symantec's software is heavy on the system also
 
Been virus free for several years. I'm not worried about it. It's so light on the system I don't even notice it's there, and it takes up very little memory. It has caught viruses trying to be loaded through websites and in other things downloaded from the web, and it properly took care of them based on the rule set I defined. Viruses are somewhat of a joke now anyway.. I'd venture to say 99.5% of them are just nuisance programs.

I used AVG at one of my part time jobs in the past, had it running on 25 computers. If you want to talk about something that hogs system resources, especially upon startup, there's one for you. It also let through viruses/spyware that caused explorer to stop functioning and require a re-image of the system.
 
I use AVG free on some systems and Avast on others. Avast is much easier on system resources. I loaded Avast on my HTPC and can't tell it's there, even during playback. I haven't installed anything on the new Windows Home Server build yet, but I will soon.
 
Corporate Edition is one thing (It has its' problems too), but Norton Anti-Virus in general (for the desktop & consumer market) is a piece of flaming shit and absolutely not worth the money.

Endpoint protection 11 is pretty strong on the resources. On a newer machine it isn't that big of a deal. On an older machine with 512 ram or less it can really show its their. One of my clients went to it on their notebooks and had to upgrade the memory in all of them to a gig to get them to run right after the install.
 
The new AVG 8 is horrible. It would keep my CPU above 50% when idle. I switched to Avira. It's free and isn't a resource hog.
 
The new AVG 8 is horrible. It would keep my CPU above 50% when idle. I switched to Avira. It's free and isn't a resource hog.

I am running the new AVG 8 on several low end dual core machines as well as an old laptop with a P4 in it. When not scanning, CPU usage in task manager is minimal, like 4-8%, so I'm not sure what you were experiencing.
 
CPU usage in task manager is minimal, like 4-8%, so I'm not sure what you were experiencing.

Is that total CPU usage when not scanning, or just from the antivirus? If its just from the antivirus that is horrendous, its between 8-16% of a core (on dual core cpus), whilst effectively doing nothing.
 
I've got AVG Free 8 on my girlfriend's machine and it idles between 0% and 1% CPU usage. So it doesn't seem to be too bad. I haven't checked it while its' scanning but I've scheduled it to scan at a time when the machine isn't in use.
 
I don't use any on my main pc which is about 90% + internet use. The only virus I have gotten in over ten years of using a pc came from a floppy disk someone gave me. Don't visit questionable sites, and you have little to worry about
 
the other day I was listening to a SecurityNow podcast (which claims to be the most listen to security related podcast in the world) hosted by Leo Laporte and Steve Gibson (of Spinrite/GRC fame) and either one or both of them claimed to never use antivirus. Both said just to be careful where you go. I put in at least 20 hours a week on the web also. I do use a router though
 
I'm running Vista x64 on a e6300 and even after I closed AVG in the taskbar, it still had left some processes lingering in the background keeping my comp always above 50%. I wish I didn't update to 8 since I never had a problem with AVG 7.5.
 
Back
Top