HP Proliant Microserver VS i3-2100+Server Board?

iroc409

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 17, 2006
Messages
1,387
I am hoping in the not-too-distant future to upgrade my file server. The main driver is ultimately to just have ECC. I have more than enough horsepower now, but my system in an AMD desktop board/CPU.

I am planning on either OI, Solaris 11, or FreeBSD running ZFS with 4 internal drives and one external USB for backups. I already have a case and power supply, but will have to purchase new ECC RAM (same for both).

It looks like an i3-2100 and a lower end server-class motherboard is going to be $300-350. The HP Microserver is about $300, last I checked.

Which would be a better choice?


EDIT: I just realized another possible choice, if such an animal exists, would be to get a server-class motherboard for my existing AMD Regor 250 CPU. Is there such a thing, preferably with DDR3 ECC?
 
Last edited:
If I already had a case and power supply I would probably do the supermicro + i3-2100 (or 2100t if you want to go low power).

The microserver is a killer value, but part of that value is the case, hard drive slots, etc. If you don't need/value those then I suspect the i3-2100 is going to be a better long term solution. Power wise - depending on your power supply effeciency, it's really not going to be that different - the SB processors are amazing efficient.

Also you should be able to pick up the microserver for around 200-250 if you wait for one of the sales/specials - so keep that in mind.
 
the microserver motherboards withs with intel i3 2100 O_O it doesnt have to be xeon wow very temp now
 
If I already had a case and power supply I would probably do the supermicro + i3-2100 (or 2100t if you want to go low power).

The microserver is a killer value, but part of that value is the case, hard drive slots, etc. If you don't need/value those then I suspect the i3-2100 is going to be a better long term solution. Power wise - depending on your power supply effeciency, it's really not going to be that different - the SB processors are amazing efficient.

Also you should be able to pick up the microserver for around 200-250 if you wait for one of the sales/specials - so keep that in mind.

Hmmm.. thanks for the ideas. Didn't know you could get the Microserver that cheap. I do really like the case, and the compactness since it takes up a lot less room. If I could find a decent mini ITX board for my firewall, my whole network setup would shrink a lot.

But, like you say the i3 is probably a better long-term solution. It could probably also handle more like encryption and dedupe (if it would benefit me).

I did find Tyan makes a socket AM3 server board, looks like I can get my hands on one for about $200. It would be faster than a Microserver, but not sure it's worth putting that kind of money into an old chip.
 
remember that am3 processors can be mounted on am2/am2+ boards (generally) and should work as long as the board can handle the power draw. That said, you would be limited to DDR2 RAM, but you could take a look at the Supermicro H8SMA-2 or H8SMi-2, a vendor on e-bay had a whole bunch of them for ~30 dollars if i recall correctly. The Supermicro compatibility table just lists supported configurations, i currently have a standard AM2 athlon running on one of the H8SMi-2 boards.

Edit: the board i bought is eBay item # 400251001001, only problem i have with mine is an annoying ringing sound whenever the system is powered off; but since it is a server it should not be powered off very often.
 
Last edited:
Which motherboard/chipset allows the i3 to support ECC? I've seen mention of this before but never anything conclusive. I'm very interested in the i3 as a cheaper alternative to going E3 xeon.
 
remember that am3 processors can be mounted on am2/am2+ boards (generally) and should work as long as the board can handle the power draw. That said, you would be limited to DDR2 RAM, but you could take a look at the Supermicro H8SMA-2 or H8SMi-2, a vendor on e-bay had a whole bunch of them for ~30 dollars if i recall correctly. The Supermicro compatibility table just lists supported configurations, i currently have a standard AM2 athlon running on one of the H8SMi-2 boards.

Edit: the board i bought is eBay item # 400251001001, only problem i have with mine is an annoying ringing sound whenever the system is powered off; but since it is a server it should not be powered off very often.

Wow, thanks for the suggestion. The system is currently running DDR2 on a Biostar desktop board.

The more I think about it, the more I like that idea. DDR2 ECC is kind of expensive, but I could probably have that H8sMi-2 and 8GB RAM for about $100 (used RAM off eBay). That saves quite a bit of money, and would probably be just fine. Any downsides to this approach? The Intel rig would be brand new and shiny (or the HP) and use less power. But, for the cost difference, it would take a long time to repay the electricity.
 
keep an eye an eye out there, i lucked out and got 4x2GB modules of unbuffered ECC DDR2-800 (Kingston even, i like kingston) for $20 per module. use your existing ram until you find a good deal.
 
Oh... duh. It takes non-ECC, too. :) Thanks for the help, I think I will end up trying one of those out.
 
Back
Top