How to get 160Mb/s with RAID0?

Seraphic

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 5, 2007
Messages
2,258
I was looking to buy four of these "Seagate Barracuda 7200.11 ST3500320AS 500GB 7200 RPM 32MB Cache SATA-300" hard-drives and set them in a raid 0 using an on-board raid-0 controller. However, some new reviews were just posted and they seem to only get around a 100MB/s with four drives? Does that seem right? I thought it be a lot more then that with four drives. Also, this is for uncompressed HD video work.

Pros: All 4 came with firmware SD15 from Thailand, no problems, average 105MB/sec as singles, about 109.8MB/sec in RAID5 using a Sil 3124 controller. They probably would run better if I had a better controller but they do work nicely as is.

Pros: I benchmarked 4 of these controlled by a sil3124 controller, in various RAID structures. The RAID0 set benchmarked at around 109.8 MB/sec, RAID5 came in about 65MB/sec. I caused the RAID5 set to fail a member by shutting down improperly, and it rebuilt in 45 minutes. It is a good idea when building the original RAID set to check the sil3124 RAID Manager software has actually completed the build before using the set. Using the set before it is built is sure way to keep getting failed RAID sets. Other than user error, these drives are working very well, and there is no other product offering 32MB cache for this price PLUS! a 5 year warranty!!!!! Name one source that does better, if you can, you better buy it, or you are probably not being truthful.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822148288
http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductReview.aspx?Item=N82E16822148288

What I need at least:

1280x720p/59.94pfps = 106.8 MB per second
1920x1080/59.94ifps = 120 MB per second
1920x1080/59.94pfps = About 160+ MB per second

I called Seagate and they said the sustained write speed for one drive should be around 110MB/s. With four drives in raid0, you should expect a about 30% boost for each drive. So 110 + (3 more drives in raid0) 90% = 209MBs sustained write speed. Does that sound right?
 
No one can answer your question. The numbers the drive mfg gives are usually best case scenarios and they don't take into account the large files you need to stream. Also its likely that no one knows if your on-board raid controller can sustain 160mb/s. You will have to buy some drives and test out your theory. If it doesn't work then you need to find the bottleneck and purchase the hardware required.
 
The motherboard is not yet released. It is called the Gigabyte X48-DQ6. Not sure what controller it uses. I think it is called the iTE IT8718 or ICH9R Southbridge? This is the first time I'll will be using a raid so I'm learning as go.
 
if you use 2 drives with a good controller instead off 4 with the onboard, it will still probably be better
 
the ICH9R is your main raid controller. it manages the 6 orange SATA ports on your gigabyte board. the other 2 (assuming they've kept the extra 2 ports on this next DQ6 of theirs) will be on another controller. that iTE thing might be it, though on their other boards it's a marvel controller IIRC (the iTE could be something else entirely, or they could be the same thing for all i know... haven't gotten intimate with every last chip on my own gigabyte, which is a DS3 anyway).

anyway, that means you can't RAID all 8 ports except in the OS, which is a bad move. since you don't need more than 6 drives, it might not be a problem.

not sure what to tell you about how to fix your problem. SSDs would be a sure-fire way to get the trasnfer rates you need, but they're way expensive and probably don't have nearly the capacity you're looking for--i haven't seen them above 128GB per drive, and those'll run you a couple grand each.

edit: SSD = solid state disk, like a big flash drive.
 
Yeah, I've been hearing about the SSD drives, but as you said, they cost is up there. I don't have this system built yet as I'm still waiting for the Q9450 to be released as well for the X48 motherboards to be released. I also did not buy the hard drives yet.

Was just trying to get an idea on why kind of speed I would be able to get with those four drives and the on-board controller. Good raid cards seem to cost around $300, but I rather just use the on-board controller if i can.

And yes, the six cards are the one controller. The two are a on a different controller. I plan to use four 500GB drives for now though, as when I called gigabyte, they said the ICH9R will only support a max of 2TB in raid.
 
ah, i my bad... and here i thought you were one lucky guy to have your hands on a chip/board that isn't released yet.

probably better to get a dedicated controller, but unless you need the system up and running as soon as the components are available, it couldn't hurt to try it off the board first.

if you get a PCIx1 card, do your research. lots claim to be hardware raid are very much aren't, though they might still be better than raid on your southbridge (which i've heard mixed things about). have you thought about a small capacity, fast array for your active file, and a second slower but large capcity array for permanent storage? out of curiosity, what's your budget like?
 
I guess I will try the on-board controller fist and see what kind of speeds I get. Hope it will be at least around 125MB/s for a start. But I would like to get around 175MB/s.

Over the years I've accumulated several USB drives, too many in fact. Three 500gb, one 120gb, one 200gb, one 250gb, so I plan to use these for permanent storage. So the main four drive raid0 array will be used for Windows XP Pro, a few games, and uncompressed HD video capture/editing. I need the write speed as possible and the near 2GB disk space will be helpful so I can store a few videos at once and edit at the same time. Uncompressed HD video can be about a 1GB per minute.

I've already spent a lot, but it isn't a big deal as this system will have to last me for a good four years or so. My last pc was a AMD 64 4000+ and 120GB hard-drive with an ATI AGP 9700 =D.

I have everything but the Q9450 CPU (already paid for but not released/shipped), the motherboard, memory, hard-drives, and video card. Would like to spend under $1,500 or so more for these last items.

Four of those hard-drives come to $476

Memory comes to $155
http://www.ncixus.com/products/index.php?sku=28306

Gigabyte X48-DQ6 should be around 300 or so (I hope)

and video card is $185 (might get two for crossfire)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...ards-_-Sapphire+Technology+Limited-_-14102719

I will be looking around the web for the best prices, but with those prices and with two video cards, that comes to about $1,300. That leaves me one PCI express 1x slot free. However, I was looking to use that for the Auzentech HDMI X-Tension.
 
With a decent controller card, you should be seeing much higher results than that. When I had 6 drives in RAID 5, I never had the read speed drop below 200mb/s, and the average was 315mb/s. You should easily be able to attain that kind of speed with 4 drives in RAID 0 as you won't have the overhead that RAID 5 does.
 
Keep in mind whn you see some HD Tune test that a lot of people don't properly setup thei raids and thus you have much lower performance. Yes I know its crazy, how hard is it to setup raid), but you'd be suprised :)

I personally have 500GB 7200.11 and on average it does 80GB however keep in mind that 100MB+ is on the begging of the disk platter as you start filling your drive the performance drops since teh spindles have to move a greater distance so my recomendation is to be 100% safe get 3 7200.11 and never use a marvell raid :) use if possible PCIE hardware raid card or intel matrix raid controller!
 
You can get 300gb 15k sas drives now.
It is cheaper to buy a bunch of SATA drives and a nice controller card than it is a pair of 300gb SAS drives (not to mention the controller card for them). Only real reason to get SAS drives is if you need 15000rpm drives.
 
Back
Top