how to diagnose RAID troubles?

Aesalon

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 12, 2000
Messages
207
ok. new shuttle SN27P2, am2 4000+, 7900gt, 2x320GB western digital drives in RAID.

computer locks up, everything just stops working and gets stuck. programs/windows individually start freezing up until after half a minute, no windows work. only the mouse moves. it's almost as if the hard drives were unplugged. I'm thinking it's my RAID setup as the computer runs a CHKDSK everytime this happens on the following boot.

basically, how do I diagnose a RAID problem short of taking apart the array and reinstalling everything all over again?
 
Look in the WindowsXP event viewer and goto the system section. If you've a problem with raid you should see some error messages relating to raid. This happened with my nforce3 raid, so maybe difference controllers behave differently i.e. you may or may not get the same messages or none at all.

However, I'd say your problem is nothing to do with raid but memory troubles. Find and burn yourself a memtest86++ cd and run it for a few hours or more and see if any errors are produced.

Quite often memory errors in windows will appear as if it's the hard drives screwing up, but it's usually the memory that's the cause.
 
yikes, I pulled up event viewer and got TONS of errors/warnings.

Error at source: nvraid

The driver detected a controller error on .

For more information, see Help and Support Center at http://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/events.asp.

then a warning at source: disk

An error was detected on device \Device\Harddisk0\D during a paging operation.

For more information, see Help and Support Center at http://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/events.asp.

ok, so it is the RAID array. I can try different drivers perhaps... don't know what would cause this to happen. oddly enough, this started after I installed my wireless NIC. most of the crashes happened when I was downloading up to 700-800kbps. I could try using the onboard NIC, see if that somehow fixes the problem. any other suggestions other than updating or trying older drivers?
 
Right, in this case I'd say one of your disks has developed bad sectors.

However, I only think this if the problem didn't occur initially but is only now starting to occur. If that isn't the case and we're talking new drives in a new setup and it's done this from the start, then I'd say it's a software issue.

Google up nvraid problems and nforce chipsets and you'll be amazed at how much crap there is out there. One of the problems that stood out when I went through this a while back was this feature of nvidia ide drivers that does command queing or something. I've forgotten what it was called exactly but a solution was to turn it off via some reg tweak.

In my case it turned out to be a bad sector on one of the disks. So I sectioned off that part of the disk and all is well again. The cause was over heating of the hard drives because I'd used foam to hold them in my case rather than letting touch the metal and use the case as a rudimentary heatsink (I think hard drives are designed to rely on this factor for cooling).
 
actually, I came across this link:

http://www.hardocp.com/news.html?news=MjAwNTMsLCxobmV3cywsLDE=

Crashing NVIDIA WHQL Drivers

Hopefully not many of you will fall victim to this due to the new series 5 NVIDIA nForce motherboard product just now getting to market, but is something to be aware of. We have tested two nForce 570 SLI chipset motherboards here recently that do not take well to the latest v91.31 WHQL video card drivers when using the latest v9.16 WHQL chipset drivers from NVIDIA. In fact, using these v91.31 drivers with the nForce 570 resulted in crashed operating systems and corrupted hard drives. It seems that the problem may not stop there either. One source in Taiwan mentioned that the problem might extend to the Intel 955X chipset as well.

nVidia Forceware v91.31 has compatible problem with nForce 570 SLI and Intel 955X chipset. Please downgrade to nVidia Forceware V84.21 or try the latest v91.33beta.

The v91.33 Beta video card drivers are available directly from NVIDIA.

From our internal testing, it seems as if the v91.33 beta drivers do in fact fix the severe crashing issue.

I think that might've been the issue and the crashes seem to have stopped. now I get a 0x000000F4 blue screen instead. I'll be checking for bad sectors though. kind of a bitch on a 600gb raid array but I gotta check.
 
That relates to the graphics card drivers and not the chipset drivers. Nvraid event errors are pretty serious. I'm surprised your windows install is still functioning. It's gunna be a matter of time before it falls apart completely.

A full scandisk won't reveal much btw. It won't fix anything either. In my case, I even did a full format on the affected partition and had it write off the bad sectors, but even then the problems still occured because the surface of a failing hard drive doesn't consistently fail; it's erratic.

If you can, back everything up and do a full format of your windows partition and then afterwards run a chkdsk on the same partition and it'll tell you if any sectors have been written off as bad. If there are any, then you have a physicalling failing hard drive. A lengthy procedure, but you'll know for sure if you have an actual hardware issue.
 
Back
Top