How should i expand my storage server?

dasboot

n00b
Joined
Mar 14, 2010
Messages
29
Ok my current workstation/storage server have these specs:
*Asus Rampage Formula
*Intel c2d E6750
*8800gts + HR-03 GT
*Dominator 2x2048mb pc8500
*1x80gb ssd intel x-25 g2
*4x1000gb

This rigg suits my needs in performance, but lacks in room of storage. With only 6 on board s-ata connectors and 5 harddrives and one dvd-rw it gives no more room for expansion.

I'm planing to get a itx/laptop as workstation and "re-build" this as a home server. But until i have cash for both this will be both server/workstation.

Will a "new" platform with am3 / core i5 + 10x onboard s-ata fill my needs of performance and storage? Or is a non raid 8port controller-card be a better choice?

I have looked at these two riggs:

AM3:
*Gigabyte GA-MA790FXT-UD5P
*AMD Athlon2 X4 605e 2,3Ghz, AM3 (tdp @ 45w)
+Low price
+Low tdp
-Very bad performance on 4x s-ata with gigabyte chipset, the barley reach ata 100 speeds

Core i5:
*Gigabyte GA-P55-UD6, P55, Socket-1156
*Intel Core™ i5 Quad Processor i5-750
+Over all preformance
+Gigabyte chipset s-ata (x4) preforms will compared to UD5P
-Higher price
-High tdp 95w compared to 45w for the am3 rigg.

My third choice and probably the best is to get a nice non-raid s-ata controller-card. But what should i get?

I'm planing to run 2x80gb intel x-25 g2 ssd @ raid 1 I will run it on my onboard chipset and have whs as OS.

The rigg will use my 4x1tb samsung F1 drives and expand with 1,5 or 2tb drives. Since i will run whs i have no need for raid cards with it's own intel xor cpu.

I live in sweden and the supply of good raid cards @ good price is very low. So e-bay will probably be my best choice to find a good card. So give me tips on good cards.

HighPoint RocketRAID 2680 8P SAS/SATA is one of my best choices here.. :(

//DasBoot
 
if money is an "issue" then the sensible solution would be to

add a "dumb" SATA HBA card, supermicro make cost effective solutions in both PCI and PCI-e
then you may more hard drives as required
if case space is an issue, then add a 3into4 hard drive caddy. this wouldn't be hot swap, but it would be cheap
if you don't have 3 spare 5.25inch drive bays, then consider a new case

if you don't have the SATA HBA card, and don't have the case space, and don't have the necessary 3into4 caddy
then another wacky idea is to buy something such as this
connects via USB or via eSATA (requires a port multiplier card)

IcyDock
PM Card
Adaptec
 
Last edited:
Gigabyte doesn't make any SATA/RAID controllers. They buy Silicon Image chips, and rebrand them as Gigabyte controller. Generally, Silicon Image is vastly inferior to a real chipset SATA controller.

You forgot to note what OS you're under. This a Windows 'server'?
 
The case is not an issue, i have a dremel and some 4 in 3 devices...;)
Supermicro AOC-SASLP-MV8 looks like a good solution, good price to.
Then i would also need two "Supermicro CBL-0188L Serial ATA / SAS cable - 4 x 7 pin" to get "2x4 s-ata"
Or will any sas kabel with SFF-8087 to 4x s-ata work?

I'm i right? This looks like to most cost effective solution for me.

Gigabyte doesn't make any SATA/RAID controllers. They buy Silicon Image chips, and rebrand them as Gigabyte controller. Generally, Silicon Image is vastly inferior to a real chipset SATA controller.

You forgot to note what OS you're under. This a Windows 'server'?
I'm running win7 now but i'm planing to go for whs
 
Last edited:
Back
Top