How much does a motherboard affect performance

Blinkme323

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Feb 8, 2005
Messages
1,666
Hi guys, I am using a Dell P4 2.8/533 processor and Dell pc3200 memory in a refrubished MSI SIS 661 motherboard. I just got it a few days ago and put a 9700 pro. I would think that it would be a huge upgrade from my old Athlon 1800 with 512 pc2100 and a Radeon 9100.

However, it really isn't. I got 14100 in 3dmark01 compared to 7800 with my old setup. That looks all fine and good, but CSS recommends medium settings whereas it recommended high settings for my old system. I tried switching the cards and the 9700 pro worked amazingly in my old system. The ram and cpu were both good too.

The only thing I can think of is the motherboard. I do have a 230 watt power supply but it is very underrated and powered my other systems fine. I have a few days left to return the motherboard and am wondering if I should. The system was very unstable and got terrible scores before I re-reformatted and downclocked the ram to 133 from 200 to sync with the cpu. If I raise it at all, my system crashes constantly.

I am seriously considering selling the cpu-mobo combo on Ebay and getting an Athlon XP mobile setup but don't know if I want to go through with all of that. Are there any tests I can do that are just for the Mobo, cpu, and ram. If I do return the motherboard, which one should I buy. $50 is the tops I'll go and my case only supports 3 pci slots and one agp slot. Do you think my performance would be better with a new motherboard. Thanks for the help..
 
Why are you going intel if your gaming? I don't see the sense in that. Especially if your into CSS or HL2, then you would be alot better off with even a antiquated socket 754 system, the p4 just can't compete with a64 based rigs in source.

Also i'm sure your now playing your CSS/HL2 in directx 9 instead of 8, which is all your 9200 was capable of. That might be why your not "feeling" the performance increase so much.

As for using a sis based chipset motherboard its not the worst thing in the world, I'm sure youd get better performance with an intel chipset but it wouldn't make a huge difference in gaming if your not going to overclock it.
 
I got the processor and memory for free from work. I strongly prefer AMD's though. Do you think I could sell my setup and get a cheap XP-mobile setup or something. I don' t game too much though, so I might just keep this one. I tried DX8 and it was even worse. Doom 3 doesn't play too bad, but it played fine on my old system too. I don't notice any difference and in some cases it is worse. Would returning the motherboard and getting another one yield better performance, or should I just scrap the whole thing. Also, why can't I run my memory at 200 and my cpu at 133 without crashing. This mobo has no options for overclocking and I would like to fool around with a little bit, but that isn't a big concern. BTW, my bios reports temps of 60 degrees C. In Windows, software suggests 55 degrees C. I thought my AThlon ran hot at 50 degrees C. Maybe the temps are the problem?
 
p4s reduce their clock speeds automaticly when they get hot (clock throttling thermal management) so if your overheating that could be the problem.
 
What is a good app to test temps and what are normal temps? Someone suggested it is the power supply, I have a 400 watt Antec that I could try but it doesn't fit in my case. Also, why can't I run the memory at rated speeds. It is rock stable in 2 other systems.
 
Then its probably your PSU, change that puppy, mod your case if you have to. 230watts is not enough.
 
Chipset can (not does, but can) have a dramatic affect on performance.

These days most chipsets are at least decent, but back in the Pentium days, I had a P150 that was terribly slow in Quake/Diablo.. changing just the motherboard (and nothing else) doubled my framerate in Quake and made Diablo playable.

SiS could be your problem.. but I don't know that for a fact because it seems these days most chipset MFG's have their act together at least to some extent.

==>Lazn
 
i believe those SiS chipsets are single channel only...

dual channel and an overclockable mobo would probably help significantly.

theyre not exactly expensive either, i got an abit is7-e off the forums for 50 bucks.
 
ATi recommends something like 350 or 400w for that 9700Pro VGA. You are severely underpowering it. As for the CPU, that will run HL2 and CSS amazingly. I have the 2.8 Prescott with an Asus AX800 Pro and there isn't a single game I can't run at 1024x768 with max details, including Doom 3.


That mainboard is not a performance board, for one. I wouldn't use it personally. If you're not overclocking I would go with the Asus or DFI mainboards. Personal opinion of course, but they are the ones I have had the most luck with.


The SiS chipset blows. It's junk. That is half your problem there. Switch your mainboard and power supply and you should be a lot happier. Look for something with an Intel chipset on it. That VGA is starting to show it's age, but it will still work ok.
 
Back
Top