How long till DX10 AGP's?

Turkish621

Gawd
Joined
Oct 8, 2002
Messages
691
So we are all expecting the new DX10 cards to hit soon, but how long do you think until someone makes one in the AGP flavor?
 
I can almost say with 100% certainty that there wont be any. Although truthfully we wont know, but AGP is dying and I think the DX10 era will truely mark the end of the AGP slot.
 
I guess that I would just be surprised to not see someone tap into the market. I think there are many people who would love to stretch out their computer life span as long as possible.
 
Turkish621 said:
I guess that I would just be surprised to not see someone tap into the market. I think there are many people who would love to stretch out their computer life span as long as possible.
I agree. Low-end DX10 cards will probably be released for AGP too, the market is just too large for the companies to not tap into.
 
They also said there wouldn't be any AGP for the 7 series either but there is. I bet they will release AGP Dx10 cards because #1 theres still a lot of people with AGP and thats still a market for them...especially since they can jack up the price like they have been doing. #2 They haven't reached the bandwidth limit of AGP yet so no reason to let it go now #3 Accelerated Graphics Port sounds cooler than PCI Express.
 
I think this question gets asked every generation. I am fairly certain that AGP dx10 will appear a few months after the release. How long ago did PCI cards become available? You can still get a fairly decent PCI gfx card.

Globe
 
In my opinion, they should kick AGP to the gutter with unwavering permanence. I apologize - but wasting resources to support those still living in antiquity makes very little sense to me.

Accelerated Graphics Port sounds cooler than PCI Express.
But AGP doesn't have a cool logo.
 
phide said:
In my opinion, they should kick AGP to the gutter with unwavering permanence. I apologize - but wasting resources to support those still living in antiquity makes very little sense to me.


But AGP doesn't have a cool logo.

maybe those people dont have the means to build a PCI-E setup
 
phide said:
In my opinion, they should kick AGP to the gutter with unwavering permanence. I apologize - but wasting resources to support those still living in antiquity makes very little sense to me.


But AGP doesn't have a cool logo.

Dude you just dont realize the majority of computers out there currently in use are AGP...PCI-E is a minority I dont care if its the new standard or not over 60% of computers out there have the good old AGP slot in them.

And there still hasnt been any games to draw enough data for AGP to be a bottleneck the only thing hurting AGP is the market and video card manufacturers leaving AGP behind.

I guarantee my machine would perform similar to a machine with the same components but with PCI-E instead of AGP.
 
pfunkman said:
Dude you just dont realize the majority of computers out there currently in use are AGP
Well, I don't believe it's a question of performance, nor is it a question of consumer adoption. The market proliferation of PCIe doesn't really interest me, be it 10% or 95%. What interests me is the onward march in advancement of graphics (and the foundation on which they operate) and motherboards that are being "bottlenecked" by the need to fulfill the should-be-obsolete AGP market.

If video card manufacturers and motherboard manufacturers no longer need to design and build a constant array of new products for a dying specification, less company resources are spent attempting to cater to these users. By mandatorily enforcing adoption of PCIe, manufacturers no longer need to spend these resources, leading to better advancement of technology and, possibly, better prices for those of us who want to live in the 21st century. I would have preferred that this had happened this last generation, but I didn't ever expect it.

This is DirectX 10. This is Shader Model 4.0. This is no time to be pandering to those with old toys: this stuff is for us Big Boys. If you want to play with some geometry shaders, you're going to have to pony up the dough (or you would were I king).
 
I would bet we will for sure see them. There is a HUGE market out there for AGP cards still. Your rig runs fine, as does my current AGP work rig. I run at 2.6Ghz with a 6600gt. If a/an AGP DX10 card came I would be all over it. If DX10 only came out in PCI-e..I would pass. I am not going to rebuild my rig just for a/an DX10 card. I am sure cards manuf. are thinking along those same lines... ;)
 
2Fresh said:
I would bet we will for sure see them. There is a HUGE market out there for AGP cards still. Your rig runs fine, as does my current AGP work rig. I run at 2.6Ghz with a 6600gt. If a/an AGP DX10 card came I would be all over it. If DX10 only came out in PCI-e..I would pass. I am not going to rebuild my rig just for a/an DX10 card. I am sure cards manuf. are thinking along those same lines... ;)

The AGP upgrade market is not as big as it once was. Back with the GeForce 6 series, and even into the 7 series, people held onto their old P4 and Athlon XP AGP systems because the performance was still there.

But by next year, when DX10 cards will be available in plenty, I expect the tables to turn. With the prevalance of dual-core systems, I expect gasmes to start taking advantage of them, and really widen the performance gulf. Also, now that DDR is no-longer used for new systems, I expect the price to rise, further hindering efforts of people to up[grade their old systems. Then, it will make sense for people to upgrade.
 
phide said:
Well, I don't believe it's a question of performance, nor is it a question of consumer adoption. The market proliferation of PCIe doesn't really interest me, be it 10% or 95%. What interests me is the onward march in advancement of graphics (and the foundation on which they operate) and motherboards that are being "bottlenecked" by the need to fulfill the should-be-obsolete AGP market.

If video card manufacturers and motherboard manufacturers no longer need to design and build a constant array of new products for a dying specification, less company resources are spent attempting to cater to these users. By mandatorily enforcing adoption of PCIe, manufacturers no longer need to spend these resources, leading to better advancement of technology and, possibly, better prices for those of us who want to live in the 21st century. I would have preferred that this had happened this last generation, but I didn't ever expect it.

This is DirectX 10. This is Shader Model 4.0. This is no time to be pandering to those with old toys: this stuff is for us Big Boys. If you want to play with some geometry shaders, you're going to have to pony up the dough (or you would were I king).


The resources that manufactuerers are apportioning to new tech AGP card developments are minimal. I really doubt they are stymieing the develoment of PCIe cards of the future. Look at the 7600GT for example. The card was released at least half a year ago for the PCI express crowd, summarily taking the crown as the mid-range king. A few months later, Leadtek takes the 7600GT GPU, attaches it to a different PCB, inserts a bridge chip, and creates a card that runs just as fast as its PCIe variant.

The benefits of PCIe over AGP are definitely there for the poweruser. But for the majority of us out here on typical incomes, we don't need a bus capable of handling Quad SLI cards. We simply want a card that will run as fast as our single card PCIe variants without having to overhaul our system.

Don't tell me that AGP can't handle the bandwidth that PCIe can provide. Like I said, I understand what the benefits of PCIe are. But there is nary an AGP card that can max out the potential of the AGP 8X bus. Why do you think side manufacturers like Gainward are able to use bridge chips to create a 7900GT AGP card that runs as fast as the 7900GT PCIe version?
 
my god agp users stop whining so much about how you cant upgrade!!! GUESS WHAT??? techonology changes!!! why on earth would you want to pay more for a card that is like the pci-e card when you can purchase other stuff and a card to hold you off until you save enough.
 
I dont think AGP users are whining... I dont think anyone here has said "OMG i'm like, sooooo mad that I can't upgrade," instead the've just realized that their Platform ISN'T outdated (not technically, at least) and there is still an upgrade path for them... .I just think it would be incredibly stupid of the Graphics market to ignore such a large user base.

As great as PCIe is, it's not even near a "requirement". AGP 4x is enough for most cards, let alone 8x and "12x."
 
Domini said:
my god agp users stop whining so much about how you cant upgrade!!! GUESS WHAT??? techonology changes!!! why on earth would you want to pay more for a card that is like the pci-e card when you can purchase other stuff and a card to hold you off until you save enough.

Who said anything about whining? Some of us are simply explicating our point of view. Poke holes in the argument if you wish, but please take your condescension elsewhere.
 
I seriously don't understand all these people that have been screaming AGP is dead since the release of PCIe. Sure you can't dual them up but do I really need that kind of power? Hell no. I'm a bit peeved that the AGP price is higher than the PCIe counter-part but I can deal with that. I run the system in my specs playing random games of my choosing and suffer absolutely no fps lag. I don't see a reason to build a whole new system when this one has barely reached the one year mark. The only thing that is making me consider is dual core. It sure as hell isn't PCIe.

How can you guys prattle on about how everyone should upgrade when what they have works just fine. I have yet to read a good point made FOR upgrading to PCIe. OK so the card costs ~$20 less. It costs a hell of a lot more than $20 to grab up a dual core cpu, a new mobo, new ram, etc. Where is my reason to upgrade? I see none.

Please don't dream of telling me to "stop whining!!111". I am not whining in the least. I'm just suprised that in a community of overclockers and tech junkies there is very few who know AGP has yet to be maxed out. The evidence is prevelant all over the place. If there was a dual AGP board it would perform just the same.

</rant>
 
i see no need for AGP DX10 cards

there will be IGP chipsets to appease those who "just want to run windows" with a DX10 feature set, and those that want to game seriously will have a PCIe system anyways

AGP is dead except for those with AGP systems which can barely "cut the mustard" in other aspects as it is like CPU, memory, etc......(p.s., i really would hate to try to game on a Ti4800 these days...maybe low detail settings on low resolution, not worth doing for a gamer)

basically, DX10 is only a requirement if one wants to do high end gaming, Vista will run with a DX9 card, no need for DX10 AGP for sure
 
Retne said:
I'm just suprised that in a community of overclockers and tech junkies there is very few who know AGP has yet to be maxed out. The evidence is prevelant all over the place.
I never said it maxed out, I said it was the Old Way, just as churning butter by hand is the Old Way. These are new times and PCIe is the new interface. It provides for us wonderful things and the plentiful headroom to advance gun-ho into the future, and manufacturers should stop holding the hands of AGP users through this rapid era of evolution. If they want to continue to offer them the scraps of low-end DX9 cards, great - but don't be angry if they should happen to get tired of waiting for you guys to catch up.
 
I love how you people talk on here, like PCI-E has done anything special for you. The only reason AGP is considered dead in the first place is because a mass of us have upgraded our rigs to PCI-E in the past without even seeing any performance improvements. Now it's just a matter of everyone saying "It's dead," because they bought the hype (or should I say bullshit) early on. SLI and Crossfire is a good performance improvement, but it seems that when a flagship of a new series released surpasses or just TOTALLY spanks the previous generation of cards in SLI.

SLI/Crossfire aside, what has PCI-E done for you that an AGP card couldn't?

Nothing, everyone upgraded to this PCI-E platform because of the FUD (fear, uncertainty, doubt) from manufacturers, journalists, and word of mouth speculation. I don't know how many people on here thought I was a dumbass for thinking and saying they wouldn't halt AGP production after the 6xxx series.

A number of people I've seen defend PCI-E are only defending it because they put $XXXX amount of dollars into an upgrade to their rig, ONLY to facilitate the coming of the PCI-E cards. If you don't run SLI, face it, PCI-E isn't doing much that AGP can't.

Now it would be redundant to buy a new computer and go with an AGP motherboard, because AGP pickin's are slim compared to the PCI-E variety and they have started phasing out high-end AGP cards, but for someone with a decent AGP system, they can still game as well on an AGP system as a PCI-E system. Why throw hard earned money away when you don't have to, OR don't need to.

AGP cards will still be around for a long while, and the post about how card mfg's should stop holding the AGP users hands is quite possibly the most idiotic drivel I've heard on the [H] block. The market for AGP is a HELL of a lot bigger than you think. There are easily over 100 million more AGP systems in the wild than PCI-E, regardless if you're talking low, mid, high range cards, these manufacturers would be shooting themselves in the foot by up and ending production on AGP in all forms.

This said, I do have a PCI-E system that I enjoy, but I'm not gonna shun AGP users because they want to save some money/get more out of their PERFECTLY GOOD computer.
 
phide said:
In my opinion, they should kick AGP to the gutter with unwavering permanence. I apologize - but wasting resources to support those still living in antiquity makes very little sense to me.


But AGP doesn't have a cool logo.
They're some agp setups that would likely give your comp a run for its money.
 
QuimZ said:
I love how you people talk on here, like PCI-E has done anything special for you. The only reason AGP is considered dead in the first place is because a mass of us have upgraded our rigs to PCI-E in the past without even seeing any performance improvements. Now it's just a matter of everyone saying "It's dead," because they bought the hype (or should I say bullshit) early on. SLI and Crossfire is a good performance improvement, but it seems that when a flagship of a new series released surpasses or just TOTALLY spanks the previous generation of cards in SLI.

SLI/Crossfire aside, what has PCI-E done for you that an AGP card couldn't?

Nothing, everyone upgraded to this PCI-E platform because of the FUD (fear, uncertainty, doubt) from manufacturers, journalists, and word of mouth speculation. I don't know how many people on here thought I was a dumbass for thinking and saying they wouldn't halt AGP production after the 6xxx series.

A number of people I've seen defend PCI-E are only defending it because they put $XXXX amount of dollars into an upgrade to their rig, ONLY to facilitate the coming of the PCI-E cards. If you don't run SLI, face it, PCI-E isn't doing much that AGP can't.

Now it would be redundant to buy a new computer and go with an AGP motherboard, because AGP pickin's are slim compared to the PCI-E variety and they have started phasing out high-end AGP cards, but for someone with a decent AGP system, they can still game as well on an AGP system as a PCI-E system. Why throw hard earned money away when you don't have to, OR don't need to.

AGP cards will still be around for a long while, and the post about how card mfg's should stop holding the AGP users hands is quite possibly the most idiotic drivel I've heard on the [H] block. The market for AGP is a HELL of a lot bigger than you think. There are easily over 100 million more AGP systems in the wild than PCI-E, regardless if you're talking low, mid, high range cards, these manufacturers would be shooting themselves in the foot by up and ending production on AGP in all forms.

This said, I do have a PCI-E system that I enjoy, but I'm not gonna shun AGP users because they want to save some money/get more out of their PERFECTLY GOOD computer.


but do they still make viable setups with AGP slots?

as in.....gamers want the fastest, so this would be a Conroe setup

is there a AGP Conroe board out?

if so, is there more than one?

PCIe has replaced AGP as the standard among gamers, time to deal with it and move on, 90% of systems running AGP are anemic in other aspects

nothing against AGP, but trying to keep AGP alive is like trying to keep socket 478 alive.....did changing from 478 to 775 make a dramatic change in performance? NO, can you build a socket 478 system that rivals a socket 775 system in performance today? NO

it's all about moving forward...AGP is definately not moving forward
 
Look at my previous post, I touched on how it makes sense to go PCI-E now for a complete upgrade/ new system.
 
Nvidia and ATi are a company, companies want to make profit, to make profit they need a consumer base, the desire of the consumer base dictates the product.

How many of your offices run a complete set of PCIe compatible systems or are they still AGP/PCI? How many of your offices would want to run Vista to be able to utilise the Business functions within?

Opinions are like assholes, everybody has one.
 
BlastRadius said:
Nvidia and ATi are a company, companies want to make profit, to make profit they need a consumer base, the desire of the consumer base dictates the product.

How many of your offices run a complete set of PCIe compatible systems or are they still AGP/PCI? How many of your offices would want to run Vista to be able to utilise the Business functions within?

Opinions are like assholes, everybody has one.

You nailed it. I also find it unlikely that there's going to be a AGP DX10, but if the consumer base dictates the need for one, they will make it. NVIDIA and ATI are in it for the money. That's an undeniable fact, that some try to dismiss i.e. !!!!!!s
 
I really hope we wont see a dx10 agp card.
 
Will we see low end DX10 cards in AGP? Yes!

Will DX10 be the end of AGP? No

What will be the end of AGP is when the 4, 8, and 16 core intel cpu's hit the market. With Vista pushing the envelope on what our old AGP systems can do, we will see an inevitable move to scrap our old systems. For those that don't scrap them there will be little market for DX10 cards. The individuals that keep their old systems will not be playing the latest and greatest games. They will be folding or basic computers for schools etc...

So although Vista and DX10 will be assistants in AGP death they will not be the cause. The cause will be Intel and AMD.

Sunin
 
While no one can say for certain, right now at least, there is no need for high to midrange AGP DX10 cards. Even though AGP has not reached it's bandwidth limit, the fact is it has been phased out in favor of uniformity. Remember when every high bandwidth card was PCI? It makes it easier on motherboard and add in card manufactures to produce products. Eventually PCIe 16x slots will become 32x slots, and becasue of the same architecture, everything will be backward compatible. Not all AGP cards work in every AGP slot. There is a reason to move, it wasn't just for fun.

But thats not even the real point. How long has it been since PCIe became the defacto standard? a year? maybe longer? We are now moving from dual core to quad, games will start to use those extra cores and there won't be any quad core socket 754, 939, or intel equivalent. Why would anyone release a high end AGP video card for a platform that cannot keep pace in future games? Why would video manufactures release high end cards, which cost from $400 and up, for people who cannot afford to piece together a new system, which realistically cost roughly the same.

At best I could see a mid-high end card similar to the 7800GS, but that probably won't happen untill the DX10 PCIe market is saturated. Why release a card with limited market share, when the main market is still booming?
 
phide said:
Well, I don't believe it's a question of performance, nor is it a question of consumer adoption. The market proliferation of PCIe doesn't really interest me, be it 10% or 95%. What interests me is the onward march in advancement of graphics (and the foundation on which they operate) and motherboards that are being "bottlenecked" by the need to fulfill the should-be-obsolete AGP market.

If video card manufacturers and motherboard manufacturers no longer need to design and build a constant array of new products for a dying specification, less company resources are spent attempting to cater to these users. By mandatorily enforcing adoption of PCIe, manufacturers no longer need to spend these resources, leading to better advancement of technology and, possibly, better prices for those of us who want to live in the 21st century. I would have preferred that this had happened this last generation, but I didn't ever expect it.

This is DirectX 10. This is Shader Model 4.0. This is no time to be pandering to those with old toys: this stuff is for us Big Boys. If you want to play with some geometry shaders, you're going to have to pony up the dough (or you would were I king).

So according to what your saying because its old tech they should just stop making them even though thier making large profits off the old tech to further thier production of the new stuff??? You act like they dont make money off of this...

By your thinking car manufacturers should just stop making parts for older cars so that when a part ogs bad your forced into the new line...Its crap just cause AGP is older dont mean they should abandon AGP entirely there are still plenty of life left in my machine and i plan on keeping it around for a long time to come.

And you saying "this stuff is for the big boys" Dude some "Big boys" have rent to pay and familys to provide for so how can everyone be expected to build a new rig because theres a better platform out...
 
pfunkman said:
Dude you just dont realize the majority of computers out there currently in use are AGP...PCI-E is a minority I dont care if its the new standard or not over 60% of computers out there have the good old AGP slot in them.

And there still hasnt been any games to draw enough data for AGP to be a bottleneck the only thing hurting AGP is the market and video card manufacturers leaving AGP behind.

I guarantee my machine would perform similar to a machine with the same components but with PCI-E instead of AGP.

Actually I'd be willing to bet that few have AGP or PCI-Express compared to the machines with integrated graphics that have PCI slots only. That is what 85% of all retail machines had for years, and many machines now have no PCI-Express slot either.
 
Nvidia wants to sell their new Nforce boards... ATI wants to sell Crossfire.. They want to sell their new cards to... thats the only reason AGP is being phased out. By switching to PCI-Express.. you're forced to buy a new Mobo and video card.
 
dagon11985 said:
They're some agp setups that would likely give your comp a run for its money.
Nossir. I don't believe that's possible.

pfunkman said:
So according to what your saying because its old tech they should just stop making them even though thier making large profits off the old tech to further thier production of the new stuff??? You act like they dont make money off of this...
Do you believe, if they stopped making AGP cards today, that consumers would just throw their arms up in the air and say "I guess I won't ever buy another video card." Nossir - if they want to upgrade, they move to PCIe eventually. AIBVs still make the money.

The AIBVs/manufacturers create these markets, not the consumers. If a sole AIBV offers a high-end card in AGP flavour, now the other AIBVs are missing out in this potential market, because the market still exists. If no AIBVs offer high-end cards in AGP, there is no market. The market is gone, and AGP, at the high-end of the spectrum, is truly obsolete. Nice and clean, huh?
 
I just read this entire thread with a computer that has an ATI Radeon 9800XT AGP for it's GPU (and no drop in frame rate LOL). Back in the day, this was the shiznit, and I remember paying $520 for this card (only to have newegg drop the price by $20 five days later). I'm currently building a new system (see the case mod section for 'Beast III'), and will be using PCI-E (quad SLI more than likely). I have yet to see anyone say anything about game software manufactureres (sp?) making their product backward compatible. Yea, to some extent, but any true gamer wants high reso's and uber fast frame rates! I know I do! And there will come a time when the AGP bus will saturate out and eventually die. I'm not going to speculate on when, but I would bet anyone looking to build a quality gaming system now isn't even considering AGP. My $.02

Steven Noland
 
Stevennoland said:
I just read this entire thread with a computer that has an ATI Radeon 9800XT AGP for it's GPU (and no drop in frame rate LOL). Back in the day, this was the shiznit, and I remember paying $520 for this card (only to have newegg drop the price by $20 five days later). I'm currently building a new system (see the case mod section for 'Beast III'), and will be using PCI-E (quad SLI more than likely). I have yet to see anyone say anything about game software manufactureres (sp?) making their product backward compatible. Yea, to some extent, but any true gamer wants high reso's and uber fast frame rates! I know I do! And there will come a time when the AGP bus will saturate out and eventually die. I'm not going to speculate on when, but I would bet anyone looking to build a quality gaming system now isn't even considering AGP. My $.02

Steven Noland

Agreed, but what this thread really boils down to is the installed AGP base, like myself, trying to nudge out every bit of performance to hold off the new build black hole that will see well over 2-3k of my hard earned dollars float effortless away when I upgrade to a 45nm Quad or Octal CPU next year. So for $300 I get another 5 or 10 fps that makes games like oblivion a little more enjoyable it is worth that cost to avoid the larger investment down the road, IMHO.

Sunin
 
nobody_here said:
PCIe has replaced AGP as the standard among gamers, time to deal with it and move on
No. PCIe has replaced AGP as the standard among people with way too much money to throw around and who like to spend $500 every three months on new computer parts. Sorry, but not all of us have that kind of dough flying around.

AGP is good enough for the VAST majority of consumers, even a large number of gamers. Being a gamer doesn't mean having the latest quad-SLI Conroe 4000000 system. If sticking with AGP means I can save $200, then I'll do that, because that's $200 more that I can spend on games (you know, those pieces of software gamers play?)

The standard may be "dying" among the hardcore hardware people, but believe me it's still going strong for the average "I only have $100 to upgrade my system" consumers.

Sunin said:
Agreed, but what this thread really boils down to is the installed AGP base, like myself, trying to nudge out every bit of performance to hold off the new build black hole that will see well over 2-3k of my hard earned dollars float effortless away when I upgrade to a 45nm Quad or Octal CPU next year. So for $300 I get another 5 or 10 fps that makes games like oblivion a little more enjoyable it is worth that cost to avoid the larger investment down the road, IMHO.

Sunin
Even with a low-end DX10 AGP card, I think you're going to see performance on par with maybe an x1600 or x1800 in this gen. It would be more like $300 for maybe 15 FPS in oblivion. But I agree completely with your point: if we've got a year to kill before we see the next gen of CPUs, why waste over $600 now to upgrade to PCIe, when we're going to spend $1000 in a year anyways? For most people, it doesn't make sense.
 
djBon2112 said:
The standard may be "dying" among the hardcore hardware people, but believe me it's still going strong for the average "I only have $100 to upgrade my system" consumers.

If you can't afford to convert your system to PCI-E, then chances are you can't afford Vista either.

The early adoption of Vista for DX10 gaming purposes is for high end users. If you are still on AGP, that isn't you.
 
Let's see, friends with PCI-E systems that will actually use the power of PCI-E: 1 (cause people with Dells don't count, this one friend of mine plays games maybe during the months before college gets out but she has an X600 and it's really more so her boyfriend can kick her off and play). I have one friend with a PCI-E desktop that is used for games, he's got an X1900XTX in there.

Friends with AGP systems who game: at least 10

Ratio: 1 PCI-E to 10 AGP, not counting myself. If I hadn't wanted to spend $3000 I could have just gotten a dual core proc and another AGP card for my A8V Deluxe system and called it a day. But I had too much money to throw into a computer. So HELLO SLI! But, as I have indicated, I only have one gamer friend who has PCI-E, the rest have AGP! The market penetration of PCI-E right now is small, only people who want it get it for SLI/CrossFire (gamers) and the rest who get it have it as part of a prebuilt system.

When AGP came out people said "OMFG PCI has been R0xor3d, it's dead!" Guess what? I still see cheap, lowend PCI videocards. That's the way it's going with AGP. There are still decent AGP cards (7800GS, 7600GT) but in the next generation that will start to fade. The market takes time to react to something like this.
 
Back
Top