How long till BTX Gets into the Mainstream?

Hate_Bot

2[H]4U
Joined
Jan 23, 2005
Messages
3,334
I was wondering, because I am building a new PC Soon, and I was thinking if I shoukd get a Case that suports BTX (For futureproofing). I had my sights on a Coolermaster Stacker, and I was just wondering How many companies were making BTX, and how long would it take for it to because widespread?

Also, any BTX Mobos currently available?

Thanks
 
Im not sure who is making cases in BTX form factor yet, but personnaly I hope it never takes off. Even though ATX is an old standard it still works. BTX is nothing more then a bandaid for Intel's hot cpu issue. I think one of the issues that keep it from taking off is exactly that. As well as that BTX is not just a Case form factor Its a new type of powersupply and motherboard layout. One thats not very freindly to AMD A64 setups. The AMD A64 Motherboards require equal length traces from memory to CPU on every single trace. Otherwise the onboard mem controle will perform Out of syn and not work. The BTX form factor pretty much screws that up making it impossible to do that. SO as far as Im concerned I hope never. and if it does Probably quite a while.
 
I 2nd that.. BTX is pointless if Intel wasn't having so many heat problems.. I wonder if Intel will can it, once they make a P4 replacement that isn't a space heater.. probably not.. they need a way to cut down on the competition, and rack up more royalties.. ;)
 
I also feel BTX is Intel's sly way of further shutting AMD out, and preventing them from gaining anymore market share.
 
Are you all actualy telling me that BTX isn't a better design for cooling. Intel or AMD there both going to be getting progressivly hotter I'd assume, how can lower temps not be a good idea?
 
BTX is a debatable design, that really isn't all that necessary. If you look at ANY other processor other than the P4, it has no problems staying cool in ATX cases.. The P4 has serious thermal issues, and needs the extra help to stay within a reasonable limit. So BTX was invented, to help out, as obviously the architecture itself isn't going to be fixing the problem anytime soon..

While other CPU's could benefit from BTX, it isn't necessary to sink the money into completely redesigning everything to confirm to it, as ATX does the job fine.. The performance DOES NOT justify the substantial cost involved. Only the P4 trully needs this format to avoid clock throttling at stock speeds.. ;)
 
n64man120 said:
Are you all actualy telling me that BTX isn't a better design for cooling. Intel or AMD there both going to be getting progressivly hotter I'd assume, how can lower temps not be a good idea?


The biggest thing is that AMD is not having the high heat issues that Intel does. The new 90nm cores that AMD has ben putting out have reduced overall heat and wattage by leaps and bounds. Take for instance my FX55. @ 130nm its a 105 w CPU the FX57 @ 90nm with be lucky if it hits 80watts and it will also be 200mhz faster. So even though the real answer to your statment might be yes they would benifit from the cooler air. it makes no diff. Cause the only company with heat issues is Intel and thats the only reason why its even been thought of being used. Besides as in my post above the real main reason AMD cannot go to BTX is One thats not very freindly to AMD A64 setups. The AMD A64 Motherboards require equal length traces from memory to CPU on every single trace via motherboard. Otherwise the onboard mem controler will perform Out of syn and not work. The BTX form factor pretty much screws that up making it impossible to have equal traces. So it would hurt AMD in a way that is unfair to make them conform all because Intel has heat issues.
 
Hate_Bot said:
I was wondering, because I am building a new PC Soon, and I was thinking if I shoukd get a Case that suports BTX (For futureproofing). I had my sights on a Coolermaster Stacker, and I was just wondering How many companies were making BTX, and how long would it take for it to because widespread?

Also, any BTX Mobos currently available?

Thanks


I'm not a BTX fan and to be honest hope it dies on the vine myself, but if you actually don't mind Thermaltake cases, under a sub-brand name "Thermalrock" I've seen a couple cases that convert to the BTX design. Thermalrock has it's own website, I think I saw a full tower called the Thermalrock "Armor" and a midtower called the Thermalrock "Kandalf" (no, that's not a typo, they spelled it "Kandalf"...this is a company started by Thermaltake...) that had BTX conversion kits, including the backplate behind the motherboard tray to support the CPU heatsink's weight.

Like Lian-Li the Thermalrock line also had a "psuedo BTX" case...i.e. an ATX case with an upside down motherboard...full tower called the Circle.

Err...I won't flame the looks, I know people who think Thermaltakes look fine, and if I ignore the Tsunami being a Coolermaster Wavemaster knockoff, IMO it's a decent looking case (but one of the few Thermaltakes I do like...), so not ALL of their designs are ugly...some of their heatsinks actually work well too IMO...they just get...interesting with a lot of their cases.

Although Thermalrock...maybe a cheesy comment...but it sounds like what Fred Flintstone would buy for a PC case...(Oh look, I'll get this Thermalrock case, and a CPU by AMDstone, motherboard by FlintSUS...)

Okay, I'll shut up now. Done embarassing myself...well, done if I had a sense of shame. ;)
 
BTX will likely remain limited to OEM-systems, perhaps it'll be seen outside this market for a moment in limited quantities, to vanish shortly after.

Even WTX was a bigger success than BTX will be :)
 
BTX is the standard now, just like rambus is the standard! Is even intel gonna bother w/ btx since thier dumpling p4's and focusing on "The era of thread parrallelism"?
 
Also note that current AMD archetecture designs will not work in a BTX case. IIRC, the forced layout of cpu to memory puts the DIMMs too far from the processor (and integrated memory controller), making the design unusable.

I think ATX is not going away
 
lopoetve said:
Also note that current AMD archetecture designs will not work in a BTX case. IIRC, the forced layout of cpu to memory puts the DIMMs too far from the processor (and integrated memory controller), making the design unusable.

I think ATX is not going away

Actually mentioned this eariler myself. But besides being further away the real issue is that every trace/channel in the mobo that goes between the mem slots and to the cpu socket(memory to mem controler channel) must be exact equal lengths or the timings of the memory to cpu will not be correct. If that happens the cpu could not and would not function due to timing conflicts. Its impossible on a BTX form to get these traces anywhere close to exact lengths per channel.

And I agree ATX here is to stay.
 
templarknightx said:
Well, ATX has its shatty air flow design. Works well enough though.


Its not that bad. I think its an over exaggeration by intel cause of the temps their cpu's run at. Besides if you take a case and make a rectangle and put fans in the front and back and ect and call it ATX and then take same rectangle box and move fans to slightly different location or put things on a mobo in different spot to take advantage of where the air flow is does not make it a better flowing design by any means. Just a way for Intel to CYA.
 
Back
Top