How Google Finally Got Design

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
To be honest, I didn't read this whole article. All I needed to read was the first paragraph and I was sold. ;)

It would have been crazy to say just a few years ago. But today, Google produces better-designed software than any other tech behemoth. If you don’t believe that, then set down your Apple-flavored Kool-Aid. Take a cleansing breath, open your mind, and compare Android and iOS.
 
I was thinking this last week. During their big summit, the main impression I had was that they actually seem to care about having a unified (and good-looking) design. For years it's been a mismash of different looks that were carried over from the various companies they acquired. Either that or their various dev teams weren't given any kind of directives.
Now they finally seem to get it.
 
Interesting Article.
I still think webOS is the best UI and OS for mobile devices, i just wish LG would bring it back to life on a new phone.
Fricken HP, burn in hell, along with Leo :mad:
 
And here I remember them screwing up a bunch of the UI for Youtube, losing functionality, requiring more clicks for the most basic functions, much of which still hasn't been fixed. Here's a refresher:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9u6Bfnq3aZk

I was going to make a similar post. Google's attempt to combine all of their products into a single login has made everything suck, especially for those of us who use the different products for different things, but use a single login.

Google Docs just got a horrible makeover as well. Right-click no longer gives browser context but brings up some other menu. It's awful.

Youtube settings never seem to stick. Somehow by magic annotations will come back on and the only way to get them back off is to close every tab, go to your user page, then the settings tab, then unclick "show annotations".

Youtube video buttons lack consistency as well. Sometimes there is no "watch later" button until you hit play. Once you hit play the button shows up. You move your mouse to click on it and right at the moment you get there, the closed captioning button shows up, pushing the "watch later" button to the left. So I accidentally click the CC button not because I can't aim, but because Google is stupid enough to think that their UI should move around.

Gmail got the works a few years ago. I guess they think that buttons/options should be hidden until you have something selected, except that humans like to start to move toward one thing while looking for the next item. My mouse moves toward the checkbox while I am looking for the delete button. By hiding it I have to select the box, and only then have the options revealed to me to search through. It may be good looking design, but it's bad for users.
 
I agree except for Lollipop which is the worst Android version ever. Its buggy even on Google's own phones and its a nightmare on the Note 4. Google's Android OS is not very impressive right now.

Otherwise Google pretty much handles everything else I need. But it seems at times Google prefers iOS in terms of stability.
 
I'm not sure how it compares to iOS, but I'm also not pleased with recent google design decisions. Still, they are typically better than other cheap/free alternatives.
 
I kind of liked android better when it had context menus. fancy icons are no substitute
 
Good design is an art, and if only more companies would understand this. Now, I'm not going to say if Google is good or bad, as I for the most part avoid using their products, but at least it's a step in the right direction.

Way too often, how a product functionally works in accordance to user interaction is given a very low priority. Let's just let any old software developer create it. Well, this isn't Silicon Valley on HBO (or any other show on TV for that matter). In the real world, even genius programmers have severe limitations, and more often than not they're pretty terrible when it comes to usability. (I know this will piss off a lot of developers, but many popular variants of Linux are prime examples of this). At least though it seems people at Google are smart enough to understand this to hire those who are more competent in that area.
 
They left out someone
Microsoft is a tech behemoth (still bigger than Google), and Windows Phone is actually pretty well designed. I find it much better than Android on that metric.
 
I don't think microsoft is that well designed. For instance, there main UI which (I think are called pivots?) is not information dense. You can see maybe 6 items in a grid format with no tabs which unless you change your complete menu structure, doesn't translate well from iOS and android. The sparse black background is fine but gets boring quickly. The live tiles are fine until you have more than one screen, then you can't get a dense screen of notifications. You would have to wait for each notification to "scroll" into the tile and then after observing all 8-16 tiles on the first screen you scroll down and wait some more for the next few. Having a notification center area makes it much easier.
 
And here I remember them screwing up a bunch of the UI for Youtube, losing functionality, requiring more clicks for the most basic functions, much of which still hasn't been fixed. Here's a refresher:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9u6Bfnq3aZk


YouTube is a complete mess, a disaster I might even be as bold to say. I preferred there old 2011/2012 UI far more than anything since. They seem to focus more of their attention to doing mindless changes than actual fixing issues.

Don't get me started on that new DASH protocol for loading videos. Grabbing parts of the video from multiple channels? Sounds like a good idea. Oh wait instead of it just downloading the video and being able to skip to any part, now it only buffers a small amount that isn't even really buffered. Hit the arrow key left or right to go 3 seconds forward or reverse causes it to re-download that entire chuck it claimed to buffer.

Completely broken "upgrade" that users have hated since 2013 ruining the immersion of watching videos.

At least they got Android Lolipop right. Finally, I'm actually impressed with something Google's done that hasn't been Search related.
 
Lollipop is nice. though I find the windows 10 mobile ui better at times. I have to agree with Lollipop being buggy, and it takes Google too much time just to fix it.
 
Lollipop is nice. though I find the windows 10 mobile ui better at times. I have to agree with Lollipop being buggy, and it takes Google too much time just to fix it.

If you are not running a pure Google phone like a Nexus 6, you cannot blame Google (most of the time). The problem is other phone companies have to add all their crapware in the phones and test it, then the provider (Verizon and AT&T for example) have to approve it and pushed out to the phones, which takes even more time and usually there already another update out by Google by the time it gets pushed out.
 
We can blame google, look companies for the most part especially all the smaller ones that are not apple and Samsung don't want to waste time and millions of dollars paying someone to program shit for their phones. The problem is that google moves way too damn slow and this forces companies to implement their own solutions to problems to please the customer. How long did Samsung have multi windows support for the note series before google did anything? That is only 1 obvious example but there are many others. If google made a feature rich current OS with all that is needed no one would need to do all this stuff themselves and the only that would try would be those that want a product differentiator.

On top of that google now has enough power to reign in at least all the smaller OEMs and the phone companies to make it so updates become universal things that google rolls out but they just haven't done this, they have allowed the cell providers to screw up phones and delay updates for as long as they please to shove some useless app in your face to try to trick you into paying $10 / month for GPS you can get for free.
 
If you are not running a pure Google phone like a Nexus 6, you cannot blame Google (most of the time). The problem is other phone companies have to add all their crapware in the phones and test it, then the provider (Verizon and AT&T for example) have to approve it and pushed out to the phones, which takes even more time and usually there already another update out by Google by the time it gets pushed out.

I actually have only a nexus 4 and 5, the camera kept crashing for example and waited til 5.1 to just have some stability to it (waited just two months btw lol)
 
My Nexus 4 works fine, except for wireless networks suddenly disappearing, making the phone go 3G and require a reboot to connect to WiFi again. It happened since 5.0, keeps happening in 5.1. Other than that, it's fine, but I don't use the camera.
 
Back
Top